Hybrid Design of Optimal Capacitor Placement and Reconfiguration for Performance Improvement in a Radial Distribution System

Table 10

Results and comparisons of IEEE 69-bus RDS without and with individual OCP technique.

Parameters	Without OCP	Literature algorithms					Proposed algorithms
		LS [49]	GSA [51]	FPA [52]	MFO [53]	LMDE [55]	MBBO	CS	MIC	MBFBO
Year	—	2018	2015	2016	2018	2019	2019	2019	2019	2019
(kVAr)	—	[350, 1200]	[150, 150, 1050]	[1350]	[300, 1350]	[200, 250, 250, 600, 300]	[300, 900, 150]	[450, 600, 900]	[1350, 150, 450]	[600, 300, 300]
Location	—	[17, 61]	[26, 13, 15]	[61]	[17, 61]	[21, 59, 61, 62, 65]	[12, 60, 21]	[15, 50, 61]	[59, 69, 15]	[59, 68, 20]
(kVAr)	—	1550	1350	1350	1650	1600	1350	1950	1950	1200
($)	—	8450	6089.4	2179.45	6084.45	10012	6044.7	6110.55	6168.3	6042
(kW)	224.9606	146.61	145.9	150.28	145.6945	146.31	61.5959	90.8139	120.6084	101.8776
(p. u.)	0.90901	0.93	0.9519	0.9333	0.9330	0.9310	0.96	0.96	0.9501	0.955
(p. u.)	1	1	1	1	1	0.9999	1	1	1	1
	—	34.8285	35.1441	33.197	35.235	34.95	72.6192	59.6312	46.3869	54.7131
($)	118239	85508	82774	81167	82661	86913	38420	53842	69560	59589
($)	—	32731	35465	37073	35578	31326	79820	64397	48679	58650
	—	27.6820	29.9943	31.3543	30.0899	26.4937	67.5073	54.4634	41.1700	49.6029
	—	20	2500	25	20	NR	30	30	20	30
	—	1000	750	100	20	100	100	100	100	100