Compilation of Smart Cities Attributes and Quantitative Identification of Mismatch in Rankings

Table 3

Summary of ranking of the 6 common cities in all the 7 ranking studies considered.

Ranking study	City
	Total ranked cities	Berlin	Chicago	Dubai	Melbourne	New York	Singapore
Smart Cities Index, 2019	119	21	24	75	53	23	9
Smart Cities Index, 2018	121	13	4	101	74	14	41
Smart City Governments	50	29	17	40	8	4	2
Cities in Motion Index, 2019	174	9	17	99	20	2	7
Cities in Motion Index, 2018	165	11	14	60	12	1	6
Smart Cities—What’s in it for citizens?	20	7	5	11	10	3	1
Smart Cities Prospects—repeated scores counted as different ranks	20	18	10	16	3	14	2
Smart Cities Prospects—repeated scores counted as a single rank	12	10	6	10	3	9	2