Energy Management for Energy Harvesting-Based Embedded Systems: A Systematic Mapping Study

Table 4

Data extracted from the selected papers.

ID	Ref	RQ1	RQ2	RQ3	RQ4	RQ5
		Research type	Research goal	Application scenario	Tool or method	Year	Publish type	Publisher
1	[20]	Validation research	Application	—	Tool	2019	Journal	Others
2	[21]	Evaluation research	Power strategy	—	Method	2019	Journal	Springer
3	[22]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	—	2019	Journal	IEEE
4	[23]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2019	Conferences	ACM
5	[24]	Evaluation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2019	Journal	ACM
6	[25]	Solution proposal	Application	Building	—	2019	Journal	Others
7	[26]	Solution proposal	Application	—	—	2019	Journal	Others
8	[27]	Solution proposal	Application	Machine	—	2018	Journal	Wiley
9	[28]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2018	Conferences	IEEE
10	[29]	Solution proposal	Harvest	strategy	Method	2018	Conferences	ACM
11	[30]	Validation research	Application	—	Tool	2018	Conferences	ACM
12	[31]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2018	Symposium	IEEE
13	[32]	Experience papers	Application	—	—	2018	Conferences	IEEE
14	[33]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2018	Journal	IEEE
15	[34]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2018	Conferences	Springer
16	[35]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2018	Conferences	IEEE
17	[36]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2018	Conferences	IEEE
18	[37]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2018	Conferences	IEEE
19	[38]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	Machine	—	2018	Journal	Others
20	[39]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	—	2018	Journal	Others
21	[40]	Solution proposal	Application	Wearable equipment	Method	2017	Conferences	ACM
22	[41]	Solution proposal	Application	Machine	Method	2017	Conferences	IEEE
23	[42]	Validation research	Power strategy	—	Tool	2017	Conferences	IEEE
24	[43]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2017	Journal	Others
25	[44]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2017	Conferences	IEEE
26	[45]	Validation research	Power strategy	—	Method	2017	Journal	ACM
27	[46]	Evaluation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2017	Conferences	IEEE
28	[47]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	—	2017	Journal	Others
29	[48]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2016	Journal	Others
30	[49]	Solution proposal	Application	Medical	—	2016	Conferences	Others
31	[50]	Validation research	Application	Building	Method	2016	Journal	Others
32	[51]	Validation research	Power strategy	—	Method	2016	Conferences	IEEE
33	[52]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2016	Journal	Others
34	[53]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2016	Journal	Others
35	[54]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2015	Conferences	IEEE
36	[55]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2015	Conferences	IEEE
37	[56]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2015	Conferences	ACM
38	[57]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	Method	2015	Conferences	IEEE
39	[10]	Validation research	Application	Medical	—	2015	Conferences	IEEE
40	[58]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2015	Conferences	IEEE
41	[59]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2015	Conferences	IEEE
42	[60]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2015	Journal	IEEE
43	[61]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2015	Journal	IEEE
44	[62]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2014	Conferences	ACM
45	[63]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2014	Conferences	IEEE
46	[64]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2014	Journal	IEEE
47	[65]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2014	Journal	IEEE
48	[66]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2014	Conferences	IEEE
49	[67]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Tool	2014	Conferences	ACM
50	[68]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2014	Journal	IEEE
51	[69]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2014	Conferences	Others
52	[70]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2014	Conferences	IEEE
53	[71]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2014	Symposium	ACM
54	[72]	Solution proposal	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2014	Journal	Others
55	[73]	Evaluation research	Application	Building	—	2014	Journal	Springer
56	[74]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	—	2014	Journal	IEEE
57	[5]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2013	Symposium	IEEE
58	[75]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2013	Conferences	IEEE
59	[76]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2013	Conferences	Others
60	[77]	Evaluation research	Application	Machine	Tool	2013	Journal	ACM
61	[78]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2013	Workshop	IEEE
62	[79]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2013	Journal	Others
63	[80]	Validation research	Power strategy	—	Method	2013	Journal	Others
64	[81]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	—	2013	Journal	Others
65	[82]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2013	Journal	Others
66	[83]	Evaluation research	Application	Machine	—	2013	Journal	Others
67	[84]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2013	Conferences	IEEE
68	[85]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2013	Workshop	ACM
69	[86]	Validation research	Application	Medical	—	2013	Journal	Others
70	[87]	Evaluation research	Power strategy	—	Method	2013	Workshop	ACM
71	[88]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	—	2013	Conferences	IEEE
72	[89]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2013	Conferences	IEEE
73	[90]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2013	Journal	Others
74	[91]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2013	Journal	ACM
75	[92]	Validation research	Application	—	Method	2012	Journal	Springer
76	[93]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2012	Conferences	IEEE
77	[94]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2012	Conferences	IEEE
78	[95]	Validation research	Application	Medical	Tool	2012	Conferences	IEEE
79	[96]	Validation research	Application	Machine	Tool	2012	Journal	Others
80	[97]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2012	Conferences	IEEE
81	[98]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2012	Conferences	ACM
82	[99]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2012	Journal	Others
83	[100]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2012	Journal	IEEE
84	[101]	Validation research	Application	—	—	2012	Conferences	IEEE
85	[102]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2012	Journal	IEEE
86	[103]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Conferences	IEEE
87	[104]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Journal	Others
88	[105]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Conferences	IEEE
89	[106]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2011	Journal	Others
90	[107]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Conferences	ACM
91	[108]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2011	Workshop	IEEE
92	[109]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Journal	Others
93	[110]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2011	Conferences	IEEE
94	[111]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Conferences	IEEE
95	[112]	Validation research	Application	—	Tool	2011	Journal	IEEE
96	[113]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2011	Conferences	Springer
97	[114]	Evaluation research	Application	Building	—	2011	Symposium	IEEE
98	[115]	Evaluation research	Application	Building	—	2011	Journal	Others
99	[116]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	—	2011	Journal	Springer
100	[117]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	—	2010	Conferences	ACM
101	[118]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2010	Journal	Others
102	[119]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2010	Journal	Others
103	[120]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2010	Conferences	IEEE
104	[121]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2010	Conferences	IEEE
105	[122]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2010	Journal	ACM
106	[123]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2010	Workshop	ACM
107	[124]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2010	Journal	ACM
108	[125]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2010	Journal	Others
109	[126]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2010	Conferences	IEEE
110	[127]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2010	Journal	ACM
111	[128]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2009	Others	Others
112	[129]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2009	Journal	Others
113	[130]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2009	Journal	IEEE
114	[131]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2009	Conferences	IEEE
115	[132]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2009	Journal	IEEE
116	[133]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2009	Symposium	ACM
117	[134]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2009	Conferences	IEEE
118	[135]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2009	Conferences	ACM
119	[136]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	Building	Method	2008	Conferences	IEEE
120	[137]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Tool	2008	Conferences	IEEE
121	[138]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2008	Conferences	IEEE
122	[139]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Tool	2008	Journal	Others
123	[140]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2008	Conferences	IEEE
124	[141]	Validation research	Application	Building	—	2008	Journal	Others
125	[142]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2008	Conferences	Others
126	[143]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	—	2008	Conferences	IEEE
127	[144]	Validation research	Application	—	Method	2008	Conferences	IEEE
128	[145]	Validation research	Application	Medical	Tool	2007	Symposium	IEEE
129	[146]	Validation research	Application	—	Method	2007	Symposium	IEEE
130	[147]	Solution proposal	Energy schedule	—	Method	2007	Journal	ACM
131	[148]	Validation research	Application	Machine	—	2007	Journal	Others
132	[149]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2007	Conferences	IEEE
133	[150]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2007	Symposium	IEEE
134	[151]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2007	Symposium	ACM
135	[152]	Evaluation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2006	Conferences	ACM
136	[153]	Solution proposal	Harvest strategy	—	—	2006	Symposium	ACM
137	[154]	Solution proposal	Application	Building	Method	2005	Conferences	AMC
138	[155]	Validation research	Application	Wearable equipment	—	2005	Journal	IEEE
139	[156]	Validation research	Energy schedule	—	Method	2005	Conferences	ACM
140	[157]	Validation research	Harvest strategy	—	Method	2005	Conferences	ACM
141	[158]	Evaluation research	Harvest strategy	—	Tool	2005	Symposium	ACM
142	[159]	Evaluation	Application	—	—	2005	Journal	IEEE