Research Article

Antimicrobial-Resistant Escherichia coli from Environmental Waters in Northern Colorado

Table 1

Relative abundances of total detected bacteria and E. coli by water source and by ESBL and KPC production.

SourceSampling eventsTotal detected bacteria (CFU/100 mL)Escherichia coli (CFU/100 mL)
AllESBLKPCAllESBLKPC

Sewer water62.1E + 08b,c (2.8E + 08)2.5E + 06b,c (1.3E + 06)3.2E + 06b,c (1.5E + 06)7.6E + 07b,c (1.2E + 08)3.1E + 05b (2.6E + 05)2.1E + 05 (2.1E + 05)

WWTP influent33.5E + 08d,e (3.2E + 08)3.5E + 06d,e (1.9E + 06)3.6E + 06d,e (1.3E + 06)7.7E + 07d,e (1.5E + 08)2.3E + 05d (1.1E + 05)7.8E + 04 (7.0E + 04)

WWTP effluent21.5E + 05b,d (2.2E + 05)1.4E + 03b,d (1.4E+ 03)1.6E + 02b,d (1.3E + 02)3.6E + 03b,d (4.3E + 03)100d,b (102)BDL

Surface water62.1E + 04c,e (3.8E + 04)1.4E + 03c,e (1.9E + 03)5.8E + 02c,e (5.5E + 02)2.9E + 03c,e (4.7E + 03)500 (0)BDL

Data represent colony counts collected during membrane filtration; all data are presented as mean (±standard deviation). Abundance was measured as colony-forming units/100 mL. Plates with counts between 15 and 300 total CFUs were considered for analysis. CFU = colony-forming unit. BDL = below detection limit. ESBL = extended-spectrum beta-lactamase. KPC = Klebsiella pneumoniae carbapenemase. WWTP = wastewater treatment plant. Statistical differences () are noted between water sources with the following letters: asewer water and WWTP influent, bsewer water and WWTP effluent, csewer water and surface water, dWWTP influent and WWTP effluent, and eWWTP influent and surface water.