Stakeholder Perceptions of Sustainable Infrastructure Project Delivery: A Comparative Analysis between Guangdong, Hong Kong, and Macao
Table 4
Mean score of each sustainability concern in Guangdong province, Hong Kong SAR, and Macao SAR.
(a)
Sustainability concern
Stakeholder groups
Government department
Owners
Designers
Contractors
Supervising engineers
Operators
End-users
NGOs
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
ECO1
6.75 (1)
6.67 (2)
6.50 (3)
5.70 (11)
6.14 (9)
6.13 (10)
5.14 (12)
4.67 (17)
5.25 (9)
5.33 (8)
4.71 (13)
5.22 (9)
5.38 (9)
5.29 (9)
5.43 (8)
6.00 (9)
5.43 (15)
5.86 (13)
5.88 (15)
5.33 (16)
6.00 (13)
6.50 (2)
5.38 (14)
6.33 (2)
ECO2
6.63 (3)
6.83 (1)
6.67 (2)
5.80 (9)
6.00 (13)
6.00 (15)
5.00 (13)
5.67 (3)
5.13 (10)
5.78 (5)
5.86 (2)
5.89 (2)
5.63 (5)
5.86 (3)
5.86 (2)
6.17 (6)
6.00 (9)
6.29 (2)
6.38 (9)
5.78 (15)
6.43 (4)
5.83 (12)
5.25 (15)
6.00 (8)
ECO3
6.50 (4)
6.67 (2)
6.50 (3)
5.60 (13)
5.86 (16)
6.13 (10)
5.43 (8)
5.33 (8)
5.50 (4)
5.44 (7)
4.86 (11)
5.67 (5)
5.50 (8)
5.71 (7)
5.57 (6)
6.00 (9)
6.00 (9)
6.14 (9)
6.63 (3)
5.89 (13)
6.57 (2)
6.00 (11)
4.75 (16)
6.17 (5)
ECO4
6.38 (7)
6.50 (5)
6.83 (1)
5.50 (14)
6.00 (13)
6.25 (6)
5.00 (13)
4.33 (18)
5.13 (10)
4.89 (11)
4.57 (14)
4.78 (14)
5.00 (12)
5.00 (15)
5.00 (14)
5.83 (15)
5.14 (18)
5.86 (13)
6.13 (12)
5.33 (16)
6.14 (11)
6.17 (9)
4.63 (17)
6.00 (8)
ECO5
6.00 (14)
6.33 (9)
6.33 (8)
6.60 (2)
6.71 (1)
6.50 (1)
6.00 (2)
5.50 (5)
6.13 (1)
6.11 (1)
5.43 (6)
6.00 (1)
6.25 (1)
5.86 (3)
6.14 (1)
6.17 (6)
6.14 (6)
6.14 (9)
6.00 (13)
6.00 (11)
5.86 (15)
6.33 (7)
6.00 (10)
6.17 (5)
ENV1
6.13 (12)
5.67 (17)
5.67 (17)
6.00 (7)
6.14 (9)
6.13 (10)
5.86 (4)
5.17 (11)
5.00 (13)
5.78 (5)
4.43 (18)
4.33 (18)
5.75 (4)
4.43 (18)
4.29 (18)
6.67 (2)
5.43 (15)
5.29 (18)
6.50 (7)
6.11 (9)
5.86 (15)
6.33 (7)
5.63 (12)
5.50 (16)
ENV2
6.50 (4)
6.50 (5)
6.33 (8)
6.10 (5)
6.29 (6)
6.13 (10)
6.00 (2)
5.83 (2)
5.38 (8)
6.11 (1)
6.00 (1)
5.67 (5)
5.88 (3)
5.86 (3)
5.71 (4)
6.50 (4)
5.86 (12)
5.71 (17)
6.25 (11)
6.11 (9)
5.86 (15)
6.50 (2)
6.25 (5)
6.00 (8)
ENV3
6.25 (9)
6.00 (15)
5.83 (15)
6.30 (3)
6.29 (6)
5.75 (17)
5.71 (5)
5.33 (8)
5.00 (13)
5.89 (4)
5.29 (8)
5.22 (9)
5.63 (5)
5.14 (13)
5.00 (14)
6.83 (1)
6.29 (3)
6.14 (9)
6.63 (3)
6.44 (4)
6.43 (4)
6.50 (2)
6.13 (7)
5.67 (15)
ENV4
6.75 (1)
6.33 (9)
6.00 (13)
6.78 (1)
5.86 (16)
6.00 (15)
6.29 (1)
4.83 (14)
4.75 (18)
6.00 (3)
5.14 (9)
5.00 (12)
6.25 (1)
5.86 (3)
5.71 (4)
6.67 (2)
6.43 (2)
6.29 (2)
6.75 (1)
6.44 (4)
6.29 (7)
6.83 (1)
6.38 (2)
6.00 (8)
Note: GD: Guangdong province; HK: Hong Kong SAR; and MC: Macao SAR. denotes the ranking of a sustainability concern among the overall 18 items as rated by a stakeholder group in a region ().
(b)
Sustainability concern
Stakeholder groups
Government department
Owners
Designers
Contractors
Supervising engineers
Operators
End-users
NGOs
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
GD
HK
MC
SOC1
4.88 (17)
6.00 (15)
5.83 (15)
6.10 (5)
6.14 (9)
6.25 (6)
4.86 (15)
5.33 (8)
5.50 (4)
4.67 (13)
5.71 (4)
5.78 (3)
4.38 (14)
5.29 (9)
5.43 (8)
6.33 (5)
6.14 (6)
6.21 (5)
6.75 (1)
6.44 (4)
6.29 (7)
5.83 (12)
5.50 (13)
5.33 (17)
SOC2
6.13 (12)
5.67 (17)
5.67 (17)
5.80 (9)
6.29 (6)
6.25 (6)
5.29 (9)
4.83 (14)
4.88 (16)
5.33 (8)
4.57 (14)
4.67 (15)
5.25 (10)
4.71 (17)
4.86 (16)
6.17 (6)
5.86 (12)
5.83 (13)
6.63 (3)
6.33 (7)
6.29 (7)
6.17 (9)
5.88 (11)
5.83 (14)
SOC3
6.00 (14)
6.50 (5)
6.17 (12)
5.70 (11)
6.14 (9)
6.25 (6)
5.57 (7)
5.50 (5)
5.50 (4)
4.67 (13)
5.00 (10)
5.11 (11)
4.50 (13)
5.29 (9)
5.43 (8)
6.00 (9)
6.14 (6)
6.21 (5)
6.38 (9)
6.67 (2)
6.57 (2)
5.67 (15)
6.38 (2)
6.33 (2)
SOC4
5.63 (16)
6.17 (14)
6.33 (8)
5.50 (14)
6.00 (13)
6.13 (10)
4.29 (17)
4.83 (14)
4.88 (16)
4.44 (15)
4.57 (14)
4.67 (15)
4.00 (15)
5.14 (13)
5.29 (12)
6.00 (9)
6.29 (3)
6.17 (7)
6.50 (7)
6.56 (3)
6.43 (4)
5.33 (16)
6.13 (7)
6.00 (8)
SOC5
4.88 (17)
6.33 (9)
6.00 (13)
4.40 (18)
6.57 (2)
6.50 (1)
5.29 (9)
6.17 (1)
6.13 (1)
4.22 (17)
5.71 (4)
5.56 (7)
3.88 (17)
4.86 (16)
5.14 (13)
6.00 (9)
6.29 (3)
6.17 (7)
6.00 (13)
5.89 (13)
6.00 (13)
5.17 (17)
6.13 (7)
6.17 (5)
SOC6
6.25 (9)
6.50 (5)
6.50 (3)
5.30 (17)
5.71 (18)
5.75 (17)
5.29 (9)
5.17 (11)
5.13 (10)
4.78 (12)
5.43 (6)
5.44 (8)
5.63 (5)
5.43 (8)
5.57 (6)
5.67 (17)
6.00 (9)
6.24 (4)
5.25 (17)
6.00 (11)
6.14 (11)
6.50 (2)
6.63 (1)
6.50 (1)
SOC7
6.50 (4)
6.33 (9)
6.33 (8)
5.90 (8)
6.43 (3)
6.38 (5)
3.71 (18)
5.00 (13)
5.00 (13)
4.11 (18)
4.57 (14)
4.56 (17)
3.88 (17)
6.00 (1)
4.86 (16)
5.17 (18)
5.43 (15)
5.86 (13)
5.88 (15)
6.33 (7)
6.29 (7)
5.83 (12)
6.25 (5)
6.00 (8)
SOC8
6.38 (7)
6.67 (2)
6.50 (3)
6.20 (4)
6.43 (3)
6.50 (1)
5.71 (5)
5.67 (3)
5.50 (4)
4.33 (16)
5.86 (2)
5.78 (3)
4.00 (16)
6.00 (1)
5.86 (2)
6.00 (9)
5.86 (12)
5.98 (12)
4.63 (18)
4.33 (18)
4.43 (18)
3.83 (18)
4.25 (18)
4.33 (18)
SOC9
6.25 (9)
6.33 (9)
6.50 (3)
5.50 (14)
6.43 (3)
6.50 (1)
4.86 (15)
5.50 (5)
5.63 (3)
5.11 (10)
4.86 (11)
4.89 (13)
5.13 (11)
5.29 (9)
5.43 (8)
5.83 (15)
6.57 (1)
6.34 (1)
6.63 (3)
6.78 (1)
6.86 (1)
6.50 (2)
6.38 (2)
6.33 (2)
Note: GD: Guangdong province; HK: Hong Kong SAR; and MC: Macao SAR. denotes the ranking of a sustainability concern among the overall 18 items as rated by a stakeholder group in a region ().
