Research Article

Stakeholder Perceptions of Sustainable Infrastructure Project Delivery: A Comparative Analysis between Guangdong, Hong Kong, and Macao

Table 6

Significantly different regional stakeholder perceptions.

Stakeholder groupsStakeholder perceptions with significant differenceSum of squaresdfMean squareSig.

Government departmentSOC1 (between groups)5.29222.6465.835.012
SOC5 (between groups)8.34224.1718.638.003

OwnersSOC5 (between groups)27.326213.66337.044.000
SOC9 (between groups)5.62622.8136.058.008
ENV3 (between groups)1.6112.8063.525.047
ENV4 (between groups)4.58322.2917.807.003

DesignersSOC5 (between groups)3.43521.7179.854.001
SOC7 (between groups)7.71423.8577.364.005
ENV1 (between groups)2.97621.4884.707.023
ENV4 (between groups)10.52425.26225.177.000

ContractorsSOC1 (between groups)6.77623.3888.296.002
SOC2 (between groups)2.92621.4634.172.029
SOC5 (between groups)11.43425.71717.453.000
SOC8 (between groups)12.62726.31411.190.000
ENV1 (between groups)11.37025.68517.204.000
ENV3 (between groups)2.36721.1834.433.024
ENV4 (between groups)5.14322.5715.211.014

Supervising engineersSOC1 (between groups)4.98222.4914.296.029
SOC3 (between groups)3.81221.9067.041.005
SOC4 (between groups)7.57823.7898.688.002
SOC5 (between groups)6.72923.36413.929.000
SOC8 (between groups)19.00629.50314.044.000
ENV1 (between groups)9.94824.97414.227.000

OperatorsENV1 (between groups)7.27423.6377.294.005

End-usersECO3 (between groups)2.85521.4283.536.047
ECO4 (between groups)3.60121.8014.890.018

NGOsECO1 (between groups)5.29222.6466.705.007
ECO3 (between groups)8.61724.30816.902.000
ECO4 (between groups)10.29225.14613.040.000
SOC5 (between groups)4.00822.0047.502.005
ENV1 (between groups)2.49221.2464.498.027
ENV4 (between groups)2.09221.0463.776.044