Occupational Disease and Injury in Malaysia: A Thematic Review of Literature from 2016 to 2021
Table 5
Table of the literature included for manuscript entitled “the occupational disease and injury in Malaysia: a thematic review of literature from 2016 to 2021.”
ID
Author
Years
Measure
Main hazard
Main health problems
Workplace
Occupation
MASCO
MSIC
SS
SD
Findings
(1)
Othman and Sivasubramaniam
2019
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
Prevalence of depression (43.0%), anxiety (68.0%), and stress (32.3%)
(2)
Hashim and Samad
2019
Psychological distress
Psychosocial
Mental health
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
Respiratory problems were the significant risk factors for poor mental health status () of teachers in schools
(3)
Omar and Sallehudin
2018
Psychological distress
Psychosocial
Mental health
NS
Contractor
Managers and senior officials
F
2
1
Work demand is the main factor contributing to the high-pressure jobs
(4)
Rasdi et al.
2019
Psychological distress
Psychosocial
Mental health
Factory
Factory worker
Elementary occupations
C
1
1
36.6% of respondents reported to have job strain and 53.6% reported to have excessive daytime sleepiness
(5)
Noor and Shaker
2017
Psychological distress
Psychosocial
Mental health
NS
General worker
Elementary occupations
NS
2
2
Workplace discrimination was positively related to psychological distress
(6)
Chan et al.
2019
Workplace bullying
Psychosocial
Mental health
NS
Employee
NS
NS
1
1
A total of 2045 (39.1%) participants reported ever being bullied
(7)
Awai et al.
2021
Workplace bullying
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
Prevalence of workplace bullying in this sample was 11.2%
(8)
Al-Dubai et al.
2016
Psychological distress
Psychosocial
Mental health
NS
Railway worker
NS
H
1
1
Mean (SD) perceived stress was 18.8 (4.3), with above 15 as the normal cutoff score
(9)
Zakaria et al.
2019
Burnout
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
Among the burnout features were fatigue with 52.2% and frequent physical illness and feel unappreciated with 48.6% and 45.9%, respectively. The job-related issues which predisposed to burnout were demand coping with an angry public with 70.2%, job overload 63.9%, lack clear guideline or rapid program changes 54%, and pay too little 53.1%.
(10)
Woon and Tiong
2020
Burnout
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
Burnout rates were 17.5% (personal burnout), 13.9% (work burnout), and 6.0% (client burnout)
(11)
Boo et al.
2018
Burnout
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
15.9% of the respondents experienced high burnout syndrome
(12)
Khoo et al.
2017
Emotional exhaustion
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
High and moderate emotional exhaustion was reported by 25.4% and 24.4% doctors, respectively
(13)
Ismail et al.
2021
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
Prevalence of stress, anxiety, and depression was 29.7%, 39.9%, and 26.2%
(14)
Abd Gaffar et al.
2021
Quality of life
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
Being female and having depression were found to be associated with lower QOWL
(15)
Minn et al.
2019
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
Prevalence of psychiatric morbidities such as depression (42%), anxiety (50%), and stress (42.7%)
(16)
Ng et al.
2020
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
2
1
HCWs undergoing contact swabbing and quarantine are vulnerable to depression, anxiety, and stress
(17)
Mohd Fauzi et al.
2020
Fatigue
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
Work demands generally worsen, while recovery experiences protect mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic with the caveat of the role of detachment experiences
(18)
Woon et al.
2020
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
Prevalence rates of depression, anxiety, and stress were 21.8%, 31.6%, and 29.1%, respectively
(19)
Noor et al.
2021
Anxiety
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
2
Non-frontline healthcare providers require psychological support similar to that of frontline healthcare providers during the COVID-19 pandemic
(20)
Roslan et al.
2021
Burnout
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
More than half of Malaysian healthcare workers in this sample experienced burnout
(21)
Sze Kiat et al.
2021
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
2
1
Healthcare workers had mild anxiety, with the majority experiencing mild stress (57.1%) and almost half of the respondents experiencing mild depression (41%)
(22)
Sahimi et al.
2021
Suicidal ideation
Psychosocial
Mental health
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
Current suicidal ideation (19/171) and clinical depression (17/171) were good HRQOL with the mean score of overall HRQOL was 72.42 ± 14.99. 11.1 and 9.9%
(23)
Ashri et al.
2021
Quality of life
Psychosocial
Mental health
Office
Office worker
NS
O
1
1
Good HRQOL with the mean score of overall HRQOL was 72.42 ± 14.99.
(24)
Nazali et al.
2021
Quality of life
Psychosocial
Mental health
Higher education
University staff
NS
P
1
1
Participants had low QOL in the domains of physical health (P-QOL) (11.2%), psychological health (PSY-QOL) (9.7%), social relationships (SR-QOL) (19.1%), and environment (E-QOL) (14.4%)
(25)
Shahril Abu Hanifah and Ismail
2020
Fatigue
Psychosocial
Mental health
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
1
1
General fatigue (54.5%)
(26)
Htay et al.
2020
Psychological distress
Psychosocial
Mental health
NS
General worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
79.2% had poor mental well-being according to the WHO-5 scale
(27)
Lee and Lai
2020
Depression, anxiety, and stress
Psychosocial
Mental health
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
Majority of the female teachers tend to have normal level for stress, anxiety, and depression
(28)
Ah et al.
2020
Sleepiness
Psychosocial
Mental health
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
1
1
Sleepiness among shift workers found to be increased by the end of the shift. Around 30% of workers did not have an adequate amount of daily sleep.
(29)
Jalali et al.
2020
Workplace bullying
Psychosocial
Mental health
NS
Employee
NS
NS
2
1
Workplace bullying has a positive impact on job insecurity as well as emotional exhaustion while also having a positive indirect effect on emotional exhaustion through job insecurity
(30)
Kisomi et al.
2016
Tick-borne diseases
Biology
Infection
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
1
1
More than half of the farmworkers (n = 91) reported an experience of tick bites
(31)
Shamsul et al.
2016
Escherichia coli
Biology
Infection
Abattoir
Animal slaughter
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
1
1
Prevalence of 9.7% was recorded for all samples during work for Escherichia coli O157 : H7 isolated on the hands of before and after work. For non-O157 : H7, total prevalence of 33.3% during work and 13% after work was obtained.
(32)
Bamaiyi et al.
2017
Seroprevalence of brucellosis
Biology
Infection
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
1
1
Seroprevalence of brucellosis among farmers and non-farmers (veterinary technical staff and others) of 446 people studied was 1.35% (95% CI = 0.28–2.42)
(33)
Najib et al.
2020
Fasciola infection
Biology
Infection
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
13.6% of the migrant workers were found to be seropositive for hydatid disease
(35)
Jeffree et al.
2018
Malaria
Biology
Infection
Farm
Rubber tapper
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
1
2
Malarial attack rate was 2.3%, 6/11 smears have gametocyte, and the case fatality rate was 9.1%
(36)
Kho et al.
2017
Rickettsia disease
Biology
Infection
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
2
1
Indigenous community had significantly higher seropositivity rates for R. conorii () and R. felis (), as compared to blood donors from urban (n = 61). Similarly, higher seropositivity rates for R. conorii () and R. felis () were noted for animal farm workers, as compared to urban blood donors.
(37)
Lee et al.
2017
Bacterial infections
Biology
Infection
Food stall
Food handler
Personal service occupations
I
2
1
Moderate levels of food safety knowledge (61.7%) with good attitude (51.9/60) and self-reported practices (53.2/60). It is noteworthy that the good self-reported practices were not reflected in the microbiological assessment of food handlers’ hands, in which 65% of the food handlers examined had a total aerobic count ≥20 CFU/cm2 and Salmonella was detected on 48% of the food handlers’ hands.
(38)
Woh et al.
2017
Salmonella carriers
Biology
Infection
Food stall
Food handler
Personal service occupations
I
1
1
Nine (2.8%) stool samples were confirmed to be Salmonella positive
(39)
Wickersham et al.
2017
Sexual transmitted diseases
Biology
Infection
NS
Sex worker
Personal service occupations
R
1
1
Screening for STI was low. Inconsistent condom use and drug use during sex work were not uncommon.
(40)
Noor Azian et al.
2016
Leishmaniasis
Biology
Infection
Palm oil plantation
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
55.3% were seropositive, with the highest was among the Nepalese (68.6%), followed by Indians (62.2%), Bangladeshi (54.9%), Myanmar (44.4%), Vietnamese (25.8%), and Indonesian (25.6%)
(41)
Mohd Ridzuan et al.
2016
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Palm oil plantation
Palm oil plantation worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
A
1
1
100 of 350 workers tested positive for leptospiral antibodies, hence a seroprevalence of 28.6% (95% CI 23.8% to 33.3%)
(42)
Rahman et al.
2018
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Wet market
Wet market worker
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
I
1
1
Seroprevalence for leptospirosis among the respondents was 33.6% (95% CI = 27.5, 39.7)
(43)
Samsudin et al.
2018
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Wet market
Wet market worker
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
I
1
1
Seroprevalence of leptospirosis among healthy workers was 46.3%
(44)
Goh et al.
2019
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Animal shelter
Dog handler
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
1
1
A total of 22.2% of dogs and 21.7% of dog handlers were seropositive
(45)
Binti Daud et al.
2018
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
2
1
Seroprevalence of leptospiral antibodies was 72.5% (95% CI 63.5% to 80.1%) and the prevalence of pathogenic Leptospira in the cattle farms environment was 12.1% (95% CI 8.4% to 17.0%)
(46)
Neela et al.
2019
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Forest
Army recruit
Armed forces
O
2
1
Among 12 patients, two (2/12; 16.6%) were confirmed positive for leptospirosis by microscopic agglutination test (MAT with titres 400–800)
(47)
Atil et al.
2020
Leptospirosis
Biology
Infection
Municipal
General worker
Elementary occupations
E
1
1
Positive Leptospira was 9.4% (95% CI: 6.8–12.8). Urban sweepers and lorry drivers made up the highest proportion of positive Leptospira respondents, contributing 15.5% and 9.4%, respectively
(48)
Mani et al.
2021
COVID-19 infection
Biology
Infection
Clinic
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
1
1
Most dentists limited their clinical services during the MCO and resumed work once restrictions were lifted during the C-MCO and R-MCO. Many reported adopting appropriate precautionary measures to mitigate the spread of COVID-19.
(49)
Tan-Loh and Cheong
2021
COVID-19 infection
Biology
Infection
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
2
1
47 HCWs in HTI tested positive for COVID-19. 7 patients (15.2%) had at least more than one comorbidity.
(50)
Wan et al.
2021
COVID-19 effect
Biology
Infection
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
One-third (35.2%) were symptomatic, with sore throat (23.6%), cough (19.8%), and fever (5.0%) being the most commonly reported symptoms. A total of 17 healthcare workers tested positive for COVID-19, with a prevalence of 0.3% among all the healthcare workers. Risk category and presence of symptoms were associated with a positive COVID-19 test (). Fever (), cough (), shortness of breath (), and sore throat () were associated with case positivity.
(51)
Woon et al.
2021
COVID-19 infection
Biology
Infection
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
One hundred and fifteen (29%) participants claimed to have had contact with known COVID-19 persons outside of their workplace
(52)
Sahimin et al.
2020
Blastocystis
Biology
Infection
Farm
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
A third of the study cohort (30.9%; n = 68/220) screened were infected with Blastocystis sp. predominantly with ST3 (54.5%; n = 12), followed by ST1 (36.4%; n = 8) and ST2 (9.1%; n = 2)
(53)
Sahimin et al.
2019
Entamoeba infections
Biology
Infection
Farm
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
Seroprevalence of 7.4% (n = 36; CL95 = 5.3–10.1%) with only one factor statistically associated with seropositivity of anti-amoebic antibodies, i.e., years of residence in Malaysia (χ21 = 4.007, )
(54)
Sahimin et al.
2018
Giardia duodenalis
Biology
Infection
Farm
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
10.8% (n = 42) were found to be positive with Giardia spp. and 3.1% (n = 12) were found to be positive with Cryptosporidium spp. infections
(55)
Sahimin et al.
2017
Hookworm
Biology
Infection
Farm
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
51 samples (13.1%) were positive by microscopy for hookworm infections
(56)
Sahimin et al.
2017
Toxoplasma gondii infection
Biology
Infection
Farm
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
Seroprevalence of T. gondii was 57.4% (n = 278; 95% CI: 52.7–61.8%)
(57)
Sahimin et al.
2016
Intestinal parasitic infections
Biology
Infection
Farm
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
NS
1
1
Prevalence of infections with A. lumbricoides (43.3%) was recorded followed by hookworms (13.1%), E. histolytica/dispar (11.6%), Giardia sp. (10.8%), T. trichura (9.5%), Cryptosporidium spp. (3.1%), H. nana (1.8%), and E. vermicularis (0.5%)
(58)
Che Hasan et al.
2020
Carpal tunnel syndrome
Physical
WRMSD
Higher education
Office worker
Administration and secretarial occupations
O
2
1
Probable carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) was 16.5% (n = 10)
(59)
Azmir and Yahya
2017
Hand arm vibration syndrome
Physical
WRMSD
Road
Hand-held grass-cutting worker
Elementary occupations
E
1
1
HAVS is diagnosed in Malaysia especially in agriculture sector
(60)
Ali et al.
2018
Hand arm vibration syndrome
Physical
WRMSD
Road
Hand-held grass-cutting worker
Elementary occupations
E
1
1
Daily vibration value depicted an exceeded exposure action value of 2.5 m/s2 for both hands and 80% of the workers experienced colour change in any of their fingers
(61)
Qamruddin et al.
2019
Hand arm vibration syndrome
Physical
WRMSD
Tyre shop
Tyre shop
Craft and related trade workers
G
1
1
Prevalence of the vascular, neurological, and musculoskeletal symptoms was 12.5% (95% CI 10.16 to 14.84), 37.0% (95% CI 30.31 to 43.69), and 44.5% (95% CI 37.61 to 51.38), respectively
(62)
Zamri et al.
2017
Low back pain
Physical
WRMSD
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
LBP and NSP among teachers in the past 12 months were 48.0% (95% (CI) 45.2%, 50.9%) and 60.1% (95% CI 57.4%, 62.9%)
(63)
Awang Lukman et al.
2019
Low back pain
Physical
WRMSD
NS
Commercial vehicle driver
Craft and related trade workers
H
2
1
Prevalence of LBP was 66.4%. The percentage of drivers who had frequent manual handling of heavy loads was 45.5% and those who handled heavy loads in awkward postures accounted for 86.4%.
(64)
Zamri et al.
2020
Low back pain
Physical
WRMSD
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
3
Prevalence of LBP at baseline and 12-month follow-up was 48.1% (95% CI: 45.6%, 51.7%) and 44.4% (95% CI: 40.6%, 48.0%), respectively
(65)
Ibrahim et al.
2019
Low back pain
Physical
WRMSD
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Associate professionals and technical officers
Q
1
1
989 (76.5%) nurses suffered from LBP
(66)
Tuan Lonik et al.
2017
Low back pain
Physical
WRMSD
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Personal service occupations
Q
1
1
Lifetime prevalence of LBP among the respondents was 65.0% (95% CI 57.1–72.9), with 12-month and 7-day prevalence rate of 88.8% (95% CI 83.6–94.0) and 20.3% (95% CI 13.6–26.9), respectively
6-month period prevalence of MSD discomfort was 92.8% (95% CI: 90.2–95.2%)
(69)
Raghavendra Kamath et al.
2020
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Higher education
University staff
Associate professional and technical officers
C
2
1
Working on cutting machines and lathe in the machine shop and working in the foundry section record a RULA and REBA score of greater than 6, which states that there is a requirement of immediate action concerning the working posture on this equipment
(70)
Mohd Din et al.
2016
MSD
Physical
WRMSD
Forest
Army recruit
Armed forces
O
1
3
12% of the recruits were diagnosed with incident MSI and 80% reported incident MSD
(71)
Aziz et al.
2017
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
NM
1
MSD prevalence for lower back (75.4%), upper back (63.2%), right shoulder (61.4%), and right wrist (60%)
(72)
Taib et al.
2017
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Clinic
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
2
1
The shoulders were most often affected by symptoms of MSDs (92.7%). MSDs of the neck and upper back were most likely to prevent these practitioners from engaging in normal activities (32.9%).
(73)
Amin et al.
2018
MSD
Physical
WRMSD
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Associate professionals and technical officers
Q
1
1
73.1% of the nursing staff experienced WRMSDs in at least one anatomical site 12 months prior to the study. 75% of nurses expressed emotional distress.
(74)
Labao et al.
2018
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
NS
General worker
Elementary occupations
NS
2
1
Filipino migrant workers mostly complain of pain in the low back area (60%) and shoulder pain (60%), followed by pain in the upper back (48.3%) and neck pain (45%) in the last 12 months
(75)
Anwar et al.
2019
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Factory
Welder
Craft and related trade workers
C
2
1
25.9% had encountered neck pain, 11.1% experienced discomfort while performing repetitive actions, and 48.5% experienced discomfort and pain for both elbow/hand and wrist when lifting objects heavier than 5 kg
(76)
Alias et al.
2020
MSD
Physical
WRMSD
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
Prevalence for any parts of the body was 40.1%. The most affected part of the body was feet, with 32.5% for the past 12 months and 36.8% for the past 7 days.
(77)
Masri et al.
2017
MSD
Physical
WRMSD
Tea plantation
Tea plucker
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
1
1
Ergonomic risk factors faced by the tea puckers while performing their daily work tasks in the tea plantations are lifting, lifting with one shoulder, lifting above the shoulder, pushing, and pulling loads more than 25 kg
(78)
Shariat et al.
2018
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Office
Office worker
Administration and secretarial occupations
O
1
1
Significant association between pain severity in gender and right () and left () sides of the shoulders. There was also a significant association between BMI and severity of pain in the lower back area (). It was revealed that total pain score in the shoulders was significantly associated with age ().
(79)
Taib et al.
2018
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Professionals
Q
2
1
32.6% of them reported that they have musculoskeletal discomfort at a single body region during the last year, 16.3% reported two regions, and 9.3% reported three regions where the most prevalent region affected was the neck area where 27.9% of the respondent reported they experienced symptoms or pain in this region, followed by wrists/hands (26.7%), lower back (19.8%), and upper back (14.0%)
(80)
Yahya and Zahid
2018
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
2
1
30 respondents out of 36 respondents suffered from WMDs especially at shoulder, wrists, and lower back
(81)
Ng et al.
2019
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
MSD during the previous 6 months was 80.1% (95% CI: 75.8–84.2%), with 80.5% of female and 77.5% of male teachers reporting symptomatic pain
(82)
Rahman et al.
2020
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Hospital
Healthcare worker
Associate professionals and technical officers
Q
2
1
Most of the respondents had been troubled with ache, pain, and discomfort at the neck, 54.9% (95% confidence interval 44.0%, 66.0%). In addition, they were troubled mainly with distress at the low back (34.1%) and the ankle or feet (34.1%) which had prevented the respondents from doing their regular job over the past 12 months.
(83)
Syed Abudaheer et al.
2020
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Higher education
University staff
Professionals
P
2
1
(n = 62) 73.8%. Shoulder, neck, and lower back region with slight variance in ranking. Shoulder is the highest at any time during the last 12 months. Neck has the highest prevalence at any time during the last seven days
(84)
Lim et al.
2021
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Municipal
Landscape workers
Elementary occupations
E
2
1
Overall prevalence of WRMSDs among landscape workers was 85.5%. The highest prevalence involving the shoulder (65.5%), followed by neck (23.6%), wrist/hand (23.6%), and lower back (20.0%) regions based on their self-reported WRMSD symptoms over the past 12 months
(85)
Yusof and Shahida
2021
Musculoskeletal
Physical
WRMSD
Factory
Factory worker
Craft and related trade workers
C
2
3
Workers experienced the highest discomfort in three body parts: (1) lower back, (2) shoulders, and (3) upper back. The discomfort felt by the workers was 74.36%, 8.96%, and 5.52% in the lower back, shoulders, and upper back, respectively.
(86)
Abdullahi et al.
2016
Sharp injury
Physical
Injury
Abattoir
Animal slaughter
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
2
1
Mean (SD) for occupational hazards = 2.32 (2.721). Proportion of injury by sharp equipment (20.0%), noise exposure (17.0%), and due to offensive odour within the abattoir premises (12.0%)
(87)
Hamid et al.
2016
Injury
Physical
Injury
Sport centre
Athlete
Professionals
R
1
1
83 injuries and 64 illnesses. Muscle strains and tears were the most common injuries followed by ligamentous injury and soft tissue contusion.
(88)
Ruslan et al.
2017
Injury
Physical
Injury
Palm oil plantation
Palm oil plantation worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
A
2
1
Prevalence of injury among palm oil mill workers was 39.4% with sprain and burn being the common types of injury reported. Press plant workers reported to have high cases of injuries. Majority of workers (78.8%) stated noise was the main hazard in the palm oil mill, followed by heat hazard.
(89)
Ishak et al.
2019
Sharps injury
Biology
Injury
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
Works in the logging site and charcoal kiln could be carried out continuously with 25% of working efficiency on achieving maximum productivity and 75% of the rest needed, work in the nursery site it could be carried out continuously with 75% of working on achieving productivity and 25% of the rest needed
(90)
Achuthan et al.
2020
Heat stress
Physical
Injury
Forest
Forestry worker
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
NM
1
Works in the logging site and charcoal kiln could be carried out continuously with 25% of working efficiency on achieving maximum productivity and 75% of the rest needed, work in the nursery site it could be carried out continuously with 75% of working on achieving productivity and 25% of the rest needed
(91)
How et al.
2020
Heat stress
Physical
Injury
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
2
1
Significant difference between HSI, blood pressure, and blood glucose levels among organic and conventional farmers. Both groups of farmers also have a significant association between blood glucose and blood pressure. Pesticide use can act as a synergistic effect, resulting in more significant health effects for those who were exposed to heat in their work environment.
(92)
Abidin et al.
2021
Sharp injury
Physical
Injury
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
1
1
Prevalence of occupational injury for the past 12 months was at 18%. The most often injured body parts were hands and legs while among the most common injury types were open wound, burns, and bleeding.
(93)
Ahmad et al.
2021
Occupational blood and body fluid exposure
Biology
Injury
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
Prevalence of OBBE was 25.1% (95% confidence interval: 20.6–30.2), mostly due to percutaneous injuries, which were not reported to authorities
(94)
Lee et al.
2021
Injury
Physical
Injury
Sport centre
Athlete
Professionals
R
2
1
Pain was the predominantly observed symptom, with a predilection for the wrist, ring and middle fingers, and thumb. De Quervain’s tenosynovitis was found in 53.8% (n = 21) of the subjects, with 52.4% and 42.9% of them experiencing pain during and after training, respectively.
(95)
Nawi et al.
2016
Injury
Physical
Injury
Palm oil plantation
Palm oil plantation worker
Elementary occupations
A
2
1
Using of manual tools should be avoided and plantation workers should be provided with ergonomic machines that can help them reduce their workload and injuries
(96)
Zerguine et al.
2018
Injury
Physical
Injury
Site
Construction workers
Elementary occupations
F
1
1
Work-related injuries in a one-year period was 22.6%, where most of the injuries were of moderate severity (39.7%) and falls from heights represented the main source (31.5%)
(97)
Mansor et al.
2019
Heat stress
Physical
Injury
Municipal
General worker
Elementary occupations
E
1
1
Percentage of respondents who experienced moderate to severe HRI was 44.1%
(98)
Sulaiman et al.
2019
Post-pesticide exposure
Chemical
Injury
Palm oil plantation
Palm oil plantation worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
A
1
1
Aware of the health hazards of pesticide use and suffered from symptoms (with mean duration of three days) such as vomiting, diarrhoea, skin irritation, and dizziness. Most of the workers responded that they did not receive any training in pesticide handling and used partial personal protective equipment (glasses, hats, shirt, and gloves) during working hours. Interestingly, a large percentage responded that they would not read the safety material even if it was provided.
(99)
Wahab et al.
2019
Sharps injury
Physical
Injury
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
165 reported cases from 2013–2015. 65 (39.4%) were males, while 100 (60.6%) were females. The mean age was 27.41 (SD: 6.06). More than half of the reported sharps injury occurred among doctor, 113 (68.5%) specifically house officer; 89 (53.9%) followed by paramedic, 26 (15.8%) and others, 26 (15.8%). Mostly occurred in ward, 114 (69.1%)
(100)
Hamzah et al.
2016
Metal dust
Chemical
Respiratory
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
1
1
Only few workers (36.4%) were found to wear their masks all times during the working hours. There was an exposure-response relationship of cumulative metal dust exposure with the deterioration of lung function values
(101)
Hamsan et al.
2017
Pesticide concentrations
Chemical
Respiratory
Farm
Farmer
Skilled agricultural, forestry, livestock, and fishery workers
A
2
1
Hazard quotient (HQ) was less than 1 and the hazard index (HI) value was 3.86 × 10−3, indicating that the risk of pesticides related diseases was not significant. The lifetime cancer risk (LCR) for pymetrozine was at an acceptable level (LCR b 10−6) with 4.10 × 10−8.
(102)
Bakri et al.
2018
Respiratory illness
Chemical
Respiratory
Factory
Welder
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
2
1
Lung function decrement was established in linear regression for FEV1 and FEV1/FVC, respectively, although not statistically significant. Analysis conducted revealed the presence of the following trace elements concentration in ascending sequence: As < Al < Cu < Mn < Cr < Ni < Co < Fe (in the toenail) and Co < Al < Cu < Ni < As < Cr < Fe < Mn (in the cassette), respectively
(103)
Fandi et al.
2018
Air pollutants
Chemical
Respiratory
Road
Policemen
Personal service occupations
O
2
2
Mean personal exposure level of PM10 among the traffic policemen was 150.14 ± 130.66 μg/m3 compared to only 84.14 ± 94.11 μg/m3 in the comparative group. A median concentration of benzene documented significantly higher at the selected sampling roadsides areas (median = 0.157 ppm) than indoor office areas (median = 0.071 ppm).
(104)
Chean et al.
2019
Respiratory illness
Chemical
Respiratory
Road
Firefighters, traffic police
Personal service occupations
O
1
2
We recruited 706 participants—211 firefighters, 198 traffic police, and 297 from general population. Smokers had significantly higher scores than non-smokers in all SGRQ domains. Regardless of smoking status, the “occupationally exposed group” had higher symptoms score than the “occupationally unexposed group.”
(105)
Lim et al.
2019
Air pollutants
Chemical
Respiratory
Office
Office worker
Administration and secretarial occupations
O
1
1
9.6% of the workers had doctor-diagnosed asthma, 15.5% had wheezing, 18.4% had daytime attacks of breathlessness, and 25.8% had elevated FeNO (25 ppb). Median levels in office dust were 11.3 EU/mg endotoxin and 62.9 ng/g [1, 3]-b-glucan. After adjusting for personal and home environment factors, endotoxin concentration in dust was associated with wheezing () and rhinoconjunctivitis (). The amount of surface dust () and [1, 3]-b-glucan concentration dust () was associated with elevated FeNO.
(106)
Bakar et al.
2020
Dust
Chemical
Respiratory
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
2
1
Total dust concentration in the casting room is 3.402 ± 0.003 mg/m³ from area sampling and that for the personal air sampling is 5.573 ± 0.040 mg/m³ which are below 15 mg/m³ PEL.
(107)
Jamil et al.
2020
Air pollutants
Chemical
Respiratory
Road
Policemen
Personal service occupations
O
2
1
Occupational factors play a crucial role, and hence the authorities should take action in generating flexible working hours and the duration of services accordingly
(108)
Ratnasingam et al.
2016
Dust
Chemical
Respiratory
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
1
1
Highest dust emission from the sanding operation resulted in respiratory ailments among workers. The occurrence of injuries particularly to the hand, wrist, fingers, and forearm was due to the prevailing working conditions, safety climate, and workers’ characteristics. The dust exposure levels and working conditions were much more severe in the bamboo furniture manufacturing industry.
(109)
Zakaria et al.
2019
Dust
Chemical
Respiratory
Factory
Factory worker
NS
C
2
1
Most of workers in the same environment are suffering from restrictive pattern of pulmonary disease.
(110)
Md Shakri et al.
2020
Endotoxin
Chemical
Respiratory
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
2
2
Mean concentration of endotoxin for areas was 0.26 (standard deviation (SD) = 0.12) EU/m3, whereas the mean personal inhalable endotoxin level among the rice millers was 0.29 (SD = 0.15) EU/m3. Post-shift lung function tests for FEV1/FVC measured appeared lower among rice millers (54%) compared to non-exposed workers (62%), but not statistically significant ().
(111)
Salvaraji et al.
2020
Respiratory illness
Chemical
Respiratory
Municipal
Domestic waste collector
Elementary occupations
E
1
1
Respiratory symptoms were seen in 21% of the workers. The identified significant risk factors were determined as underlying chronic diseases (OR = 2.34; 95% CI = 1.054, 5.219) and contact with pets (OR = 1.87; 95% CI = 1.004, 3.288)
(112)
Hasan et al.
2016
Cardiovascular disease risk
Other
Cardiovascular disease
Office
Office worker
Administration and secretarial occupations
O
2
1
Respiratory symptoms were seen in 21% of the workers. The identified significant risk factors were determined as underlying chronic diseases (OR = 2.34; 95% CI = 1.054, 5.219) and contact with pets (OR = 1.87; 95% CI = 1.004, 3.288)
(113)
Lee et al.
2017
Cardiovascular disease risk
Other
Cardiovascular disease
School
Teacher
Professionals
P
1
1
MONO was 17.7% (95% confidence interval (CI), 15.3e20.4). Prevalence of metabolic syndrome among the normal weight and overweight participants was 8.3% (95% CI, 5.8e11.8) and 29.9% (95% CI, 26.3e33.7)
(114)
Kit et al.
2020
Overweight and obesity
Other
Cardiovascular disease
Clinic
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
49.9% of the healthcare workers were overweight or obese, 51.0% were at risk of having abdominal obesity, and 79.6% had a high body fat percentage
(115)
Kuan et al.
2020
Cardiovascular disease risk
Other
Cardiovascular disease
Hospital
Healthcare worker
NS
Q
1
1
47.4% of the subjects were of normal weight, 30.2% were overweight, 17.2% were obese and 5.2% were underweight
(116)
Rahimi et al.
2016
Cardiovascular disease risk
Other
Cardiovascular disease
Office
Rescue firefighter personnel
Personal service occupations
O
1
1
41.5% were normal, 44.8% were overweight, and 13% were obese. The percentage of 34.8% firefighters with WC values of more than 90 cm means that they were at greater risk to have cardiovascular and diabetes disease.
(117)
Samsuddin et al.
2016
Pesticide exposure
Chemical
Cardiovascular disease
Site
Healthcare worker
Personal service occupations
Q
1
2
Diazoxonase was significantly lower and ox-LDL was higher among pesticide-exposed workers than the comparison group. Age, body mass index (BMI), smoking, and pesticide exposure were independent predictors of brachial and aortic DBP and SBP. Pesticide exposure was also associated with heart rate, but not with PWV. Lipid profiles, PON1 enzymes, and ox-LDL showed no association with any of the CVS parameters.
(118)
Jeffree et al.
2016
Noise exposure
Physical
Hearing loss
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
2
2
Hearing impairment was significantly () associated with older age, lower education level, high smoking dose, high occupational daily noise dose, longer duration of service, infrequent used of hearing protection device (HPD), and low perception of sound on HPD usage
(119)
Sam et al.
2017
Noise exposure
Physical
Hearing loss
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
2
1
Prevalence of HL was 73.3% and the prevalence of hearing impairment was 23.3%. Male workers (63.0%) had higher prevalence of HL than female workers (36.4%). Mean hearing threshold levels of HL respondents were significantly higher than respondents with normal hearing.
(120)
Selamat and Zulkifli
2016
Noise exposure
Physical
Hearing loss
Factory
Factory worker
Plant and machine operators and assemblers
C
2
1
Nearly all the identified work areas exceeded the action level of 85 dB (A) and four of these areas noise levels are more than 90 dB (A) which is the permissible exposure limit. For the questionnaire, it was found that annoyance topped the noise effect list with 51.4%, followed by stress with 40.0%, hearing deterioration (14.3%), and job performance deterioration (2.9%).
NS: not specified. SS = sample size, 1 = 150 and above, 2 =< 150, SD = study design, 1 = cross-sectional, 2 = case-control, 3 = others, Malaysia Standard Industrial Classification (MSIC) 2008, A: agriculture, forestry, and fishing, C: manufacturing, E: water supply; sewerage, waste management, and remediation activities, F: construction, G: wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles and motorcycle, H: transportation and storage, I: accommodation and food service activities, O: public administration and defense; compulsory social security, P: education, Q: human health and social work activities, and R: arts, entertainment, and recreation.