Research Article

Evaluation of the COVID-19 Pandemic Intervention Strategies with Hesitant F-AHP

Table 1

COVID-19 intervention strategies and country examples.

A1Quarantine/lockdown of patients and those suspected of infectionPolicies to quarantine or shelter in place for at least 14 days. For example, “Hong Kong, a semiautonomous Chinese region, requires travelers from all countries to self-quarantine for 14 days”
A2Internal border restrictions reducing the ability to move freely (transportation) within a countryGovernment policies which reduce the ability to move freely within a country. For example, in Peru as of March 15 2020, “officials are also restricting the movement of people across provinces”
A3Social distancingGovernment policies that limit physical contact between individuals to 1.5 meters or 6 feet. For example, in Germany, “a 1.5 meter (4.9 feet) distance should be kept at all times when in public”
A4Health monitoringGovernment policies that seek to monitor the health of individuals who are afflicted with or who are likely to be afflicted with the coronavirus. For example, “Taiwan CDC monitors all individuals who had traveled to Wuhan within 14 days and exhibited a fever or symptoms of upper respiratory tract infections”
A5Public awareness campaignsEfforts to disseminate and convey reliable information about COVID-19, including ways to prevent or mitigate the health effects of COVID-19. For example, on March 22, 2020, it was announced that “the Provincial Youth Council in Namibia carried out an intense public awareness campaign on methods of disease prevention, during which, young associates distributed pamphlets with statements about the pandemic and ways of prevention”
A6Restriction of nonessential businessesGovernment policies that restrict nonessential commercial activity. For example, in Serbia, “as of March 21, 2020, the following measures are in effect: supermarkets, gas stations, restaurants, post offices, banks and other service providers will be reducing their hours to observe the curfew, with some closing at 6 : 00 PM or earlier. Cafes, restaurants and shopping centers are closed, however food delivery is allowed”
A7Restrictions of mass gatheringsGovernment policies that limit the number of people allowed to congregate in a place. For example, on March 16, 2020, in the United States, “the latest recommendation announced Monday by the federal government to promote social distancing and limit the transmission of the coronavirus is: no more than 10 people in one place”
A8External border restrictions reducing the ability to exit or enter a countryGovernment policies which reduce the ability to access ports of entry to or exit from a country. For example, “Namibian government suspends inbound and outbound flights for 30 days”
A9Closure of schoolsGovernment policy that closes educational establishments in a country. For example, in Slovakia, as of March 12, 2020, “all schools and educational establishments will be shut down”
A10Government policies that affect the country’s health resources (materials and health worker)Government policies which affect the material (e.g., medical equipment, number of hospitals for public health) or human (e.g., doctors, nurses) health resources of a country. For example, “Taiwan bans exports of face masks; ban extended to the end of April (2020)” or “Government approves plan to build 60 production lines to make an additional 6 million masks per day”
A11Formation of new task units/bureaus and government policies changing administrative capacity to respond to the crisisGovernment policy that changes the administrative capacity of a part of government to respond to the crisis. For example, on January 20, 2020, “Taiwan activated the Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) which mobilizes government funds and military personnel to facilitate face mask production”
A12Common health testing (independent of suspected infection)Government policies which seek to sample large populations for coronavirus regardless of suspected likelihood of affliction with coronavirus.
A13CurfewGovernment policies that limit domestic freedom of movement to certain times of the day. For example, in Serbia, “as of March 21, 2020 the following measures are in effect: curfew for all residents with few exceptions from 8:00pm to 5:00am the next day”
A14Restriction of nonessential government servicesGovernment policy that restricts nonessential government services. For example, in Malaysia, from March 18, 2020, to March 31, 2020, “all government and private services except those involved in essential services such as water, electricity, power, telecommunications, postal, transportation, fuel, finance, banking, health, pharmacy, fire, port, airport, security, retail and food supply will also be closed”
A15Declaration of emergencyThe head of government declares a state of national emergency. For example, on March 15, 2020, in South Africa: “President Ramaphosa announces national state of disaster”