Research Article

Evaluation of the COVID-19 Pandemic Intervention Strategies with Hesitant F-AHP

Table 4

The fuzzy evaluation matrix for the intervention strategy alternatives ().

A1A2A3A4A5

A1(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.571, 2.000, 2.571)(1.357, 1.763, 2.214)(1.643, 2.143, 2.714)(1.500, 1.929, 2.571)
A2(0.399, 0.506, 0.691)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(0.954, 1.357, 1.571)(0.953, 1.239, 1.571)(1.167, 1.586, 2.000)
A3(0.556, 0.767, 1.024)(0.757, 0.810, 1.191)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.143, 1.586, 2.000)(1.357, 1.786, 2.429)
A4(0.379, 0.477, 0.667)(0.724, 0.906, 1.167)(0.601, 0.735, 1.001)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.286, 1.500, 1.929)
A5(0.399, 0.506, 0.739)(0.604, 0.846, 1.071)(0.419, 0.534, 0.787)(0.595, 0.781, 0.857)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)
A6(0.384, 0.481, 0.644)(0.747, 0.796, 1.143)(0.590, 0.677, 0.906)(0.690, 0.781, 1.071)(0.929, 1.024, 1.357)
A7(0.532, 0.671, 0.739)(0.881, 1.024, 1.357)(0.738, 0.867, 1.000)(0.796, 0.953, 1.381)(1.024, 1.357, 1.786)
A8(0.548, 0.696, 0.810)(0.904, 1.057, 1.286)(0.810, 0.977, 1.357)(0.881, 1.371, 1.714)(1.214, 1.524, 2.000)
A9(0.819, 1.043, 1.239)(1.047, 1.224, 1.571)(0.953, 1.071, 1.357)(1.000, 1.191, 1.571)(1.214, 1.524, 2.000)
A10(0.762, 0.863, 1.071)(0.819, 0.949, 1.167)(0.701, 0.953, 1.167)(0.787, 1.024, 1.214)(1.001, 1.357, 1.714)
A11(0.653, 0.796, 0.881)(0.763, 0.977, 1.357)(0.667, 0.820, 1.071)(0.810, 0.977, 1.214)(0.906, 1.167, 1.429)
A12(0.833, 0.996, 1.286)(1.057, 1.343, 1.643)(0.976, 1.224, 1.500)(1.010, 1.239, 1.453)(1.200, 1.524, 2.024)
A13(0.890, 1.153, 1.571)(1.095, 1.381, 1.714)(0.976, 1.224, 1.571)(1.238, 1.429, 1.857)(1.334, 1.714, 2.143)
A14(0.604, 0.773, 1.024)(0.929, 1.120, 1.500)(0.700, 0.859, 1.167)(0.881, 1.049, 1.429)(1.000, 1.239, 1.714)
A15(1.190, 1.510, 1.857)(1.095, 1.524, 1.929)(0.952, 1.191, 1.714)(1.500, 1.786, 2.143)(1.596, 2.071, 2.571)

A6A7A8A9A10
A1(1.643, 2.143, 2.643)(1.500, 1.786, 2.214)(1.357, 1.643, 2.143)(1.190, 1.439, 1.786)(1.071, 1.371, 1.643)
A2(1.001, 1.357, 1.643)(0.787, 1.024, 1.214)(0.952, 1.120, 1.286)(0.867, 1.129, 1.310)(0.953, 1.300, 1.500)
A3(1.238, 1.643, 2.000)(1.096, 1.286, 1.571)(0.810, 0.977, 1.357)(0.810, 0.906, 1.071)(0.953, 1.167, 1.571)
A4(1.144, 1.500, 1.786)(0.844, 1.143, 1.429)(0.691, 0.808, 1.214)(0.734, 1.000, 1.191)(0.881, 1.024, 1.357)
A5(0.787, 1.024, 1.143)(0.606, 0.787, 1.024)(0.571, 0.806, 1.000)(0.567, 0.796, 0.977)(0.690, 0.773, 1.143)
A6(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(0.668, 0.906, 1.000)(0.661, 0.796, 0.977)(0.548, 0.687, 0.952)(0.715, 0.906, 1.071)
A7(1.000, 1.071, 1.571)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(0.858, 1.167, 1.357)(0.953, 1.000, 1.143)(0.930, 1.214, 1.429)
A8(1.214, 1.524, 1.857)(0.843, 0.953, 1.310)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.143, 1.310, 1.643)(0.977, 1.286, 1.643)
A9(1.167, 1.571, 2.071)(0.929, 0.953, 1.071)(0.762, 0.900, 1.024)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.096, 1.452, 1.857)
A10(0.953, 1.143, 1.500)(0.796, 0.881, 1.167)(0.677, 0.834, 1.096)(0.624, 0.739, 1.073)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)
A11(0.977, 1.214, 1.429)(0.811, 0.986, 1.167)(0.667, 0.891, 1.143)(0.614, 0.724, 1.049)(0.929, 0.953, 1.071)
A12(1.357, 1.739, 2.143)(0.986, 1.167, 1.524)(1.033, 1.343, 1.739)(1.000, 1.191, 1.571)(1.096, 1.429, 1.786)
A13(1.429, 1.857, 2.429)(1.200, 1.571, 2.024)(1.057, 1.310, 1.739)(1.096, 1.310, 1.643)(1.143, 1.381, 1.857)
A14(1.000, 1.071, 1.286)(0.843, 0.881, 1.024)(0.881, 0.971, 1.167)(0.771, 0.834, 1.024)(0.905, 1.239, 1.571)
A15(1.571, 2.071, 2.714)(1.381, 1.857, 2.286)(1.191, 1.500, 1.786)(1.286, 1.571, 2.071)(1.429, 1.643, 2.000)

A11A12A13A14A15
A1(1.214, 1.429, 1.786)(1.119, 1.367, 1.714)(0.890, 1.081, 1.571)(1.143, 1.524, 1.929)(0.794, 0.924, 1.239)
A2(0.810, 1.048, 1.429)(0.876, 1.057, 1.406)(0.700, 0.796, 1.096)(0.748, 1.024, 1.239)(0.604, 0.773, 1.096)
A3(1.049, 1.357, 1.714)(0.904, 1.106, 1.357)(0.857, 1.034, 1.357)(0.953, 1.310, 1.643)(0.700, 0.939, 1.286)
A4(0.881, 1.024, 1.357)(0.890, 1.057, 1.310)(0.643, 0.781, 0.929)(0.773, 1.071, 1.310)(0.580, 0.671, 0.739)
A5(0.796, 0.953, 1.239)(0.661, 0.900, 1.167)(0.580, 0.671, 0.929)(0.630, 0.906, 1.096)(0.446, 0.514, 0.739)
A6(0.796, 0.881, 1.096)(0.566, 0.710, 0.906)(0.433, 0.567, 0.763)(0.834, 0.953, 1.000)(0.374, 0.467, 0.714)
A7(0.953, 1.096, 1.429)(0.806, 1.071, 1.263)(0.619, 0.830, 1.071)(1.024, 1.214, 1.357)(0.494, 0.591, 0.834)
A8(1.024, 1.239, 1.714)(0.843, 1.106, 1.381)(0.757, 0.986, 1.239)(1.081, 1.286, 1.524)(0.686, 0.771, 0.977)
A9(1.167, 1.524, 1.929)(0.734, 1.000, 1.191)(0.724, 0.843, 1.096)(1.024, 1.286, 1.500)(0.543, 0.677, 0.834)
A10(0.953, 1.071, 1.143)(0.643, 0.773, 1.000)(0.639, 0.843, 1.024)(0.724, 0.906, 1.239)(0.619, 0.743, 0.786)
A11(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(0.676, 0.749, 0.953)(0.653, 0.796, 1.000)(0.724, 0.906, 1.096)(0.570, 0.649, 0.786)
A12(1.167, 1.500, 1.786)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.071, 1.263, 1.500)(1.286, 1.524, 2.071)(1.119, 1.296, 1.500)
A13(1.096, 1.357, 1.786)(0.819, 0.914, 1.167)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(1.429, 1.929, 2.500)(0.667, 0.820, 0.929)
A14(1.000, 1.239, 1.571)(0.557, 0.781, 0.953)(0.413, 0.530, 0.762)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)(0.501, 0.687, 0.881)
A15(1.429, 1.786, 2.143)(0.951, 1.114, 1.286)(1.143, 1.357, 1.714)(1.214, 1.500, 2.143)(1.000, 1.000, 1.000)