Research Article

A Comprehensive Survey on the Progress, Process, and Challenges of Lung Cancer Detection and Classification

Table 7

Advantages and disadvantages of segmentation methods.

AlgorithmsAdvantagesDisadvantages

Watershed [225]Being able to divide an image into its componentsTakes too long to run in order to meet the deadline, sensitivity to false edges and over-segmentation
U-Net [226]Images can be segmented quickly and accuratelyRedundancy occurs due to patch overlap, also relatively slow
MV-CNN [203]No user-interactive parameters or assumptions about the shape of nodules are neededThe loss of gradients may have an effect
CF-CNN [206]Gathered sensitive information about nodules from CT imaging dataLess adaptable for small nodules and cavitary nodules
FCM [188]Ignored noise sensitivity limitation, successfully overcoming the PCM’s clustering problemRow sum constraints must be equal to one in order to work
Hessian-based approaches [209]High robustness against noise and sensitivity to small objectsPerformance decreases for large nodule
SegNet + shape driven level set [213]Correct seed point initialization with no manual intervention in the level setSegments the lung nodule partly occluded, also takes a longer time
Faster R-CNN [214]The efficiency of detection is highIt could take a long time to reach convergence
Mask R-CNN [218]Easy to train, generalizable to other tasks, effective, and only adds a minor overheadLow-resolution motion blur detection typically fails to pick up on objects
RASM [219]Well suited to large shape models and parallel implementation allowing for short computation timesCannot segment areas with sharp angles and is not built to handle juxta-pleural nodules
Region growing [227]The concept is simple, multiple criteria can be selected simultaneously, and it performs well in terms of noiseComputing is time-consuming. Noise or variation may result in holes or over-segmentation, making it difficult to distinguish the shading of real images.