|
Ref | Material type | Growth process | Electrolyte | Specific surface area | Specific capacitance | Energy and power density |
|
[41] | CNFs. PAN in DMF Activated in steam | Electrospun | KOH (0.9 V) | 1230 m2/g Micropores 64% | 175 F/g | |
|
[42] | ACFF | | 1 M H2SO4 (0.75 V) | 134 m2/g | 146 F/g 10.9 µF/cm2 | |
CNFs on ACFF | CVD | 1 M H2SO4 0.8 V | 784 m2/g | 117 F/g 14.9 µF/cm2 | |
0.8 M TEABF4 2 V | 34 F/g 4.3 µF/cm2 | |
|
[43] | CNFs mesoporous and sidewalls openings | Template method | 1 M KOH (1.1 V) | 1424 m2/g. Micropore vol. 327 cm3/g | 152 F/ | |
| 1 M LiClO4 in EC/DEC (1 : 1) | | 70 F/g | |
|
[44] | CNFs on 3D nickel | TCVD | 2 M Li2SO4 salt. | SSA 500 g/m2 | 1.2 F/cm2. 89.8% after 3000 cycles | 2.4 ohm |
|
[45] | CNFs PAI + DMF | Electrospun | 1 M H2SO4, (1 V) | 240 m2/g | 30 F g−1 | |
Activated- CNF | 6 M KOH | 1250 m2/g Pore size 4–6 nm. | 150 F/g | |
196 F/g | |
|
[46] | CNFs PAN + (PMHS) in DMF | Electrospun | 6 M KOH (1 V) | 302 m2/g | 127 F/g, | 10–17 Wh/kg 0.4–20 kW/kg |
|
[47] | PAN based CNFs | Electrospun. | 6 M KOH (1 V). | 502 m2/g, pore vol. 0.1654 cm3/g, pore size. 17 nm | 60 F g−1 | 6–2 wh/kg 0.1–40 kW/kg. |
PAN/pitch base CNFs | | 966.3 m2/g, pore vol.: 0.379 cm3/g, pore size: 1.573 nm | 130.7 F g−1 | 15.0 Wh/kg 100 kW/kg. |
|
[48] | CNFs On CF/Fe | WA-TCVD | 0.5 M Na2SO4 (0.7 V) | | 142 F/g | |
|
[49] | CNFs (PS-b-PEO) + resol opening on walls. | Template | | 643 m2/g. Pore vol. 0.157 m3/g Pore size 2.32 nm | 172 F/g | |
|
[50] | PAN based CNFs | Electrospun | 0.5 M K2SO4 (1 V) | 339 m2/g Mesopores 0.128 cm3/g | 20 F/g,. | |
CNFs PAN + nafion | 1499 m2/g Mesopores 1.336 cm3/g Pore size. 4.69 nm | 210 F/g | 4 Wh/kg at 20 kW/kg. |
|
Doping |
|
[51] | CNFs@Ppy Annealed at 900°C | Template. | | 562 m2/s. Pore volume. 0.51 cm3/g. Pore size. 3.65 nm | 202 F/g. | 7.11 Wh/kg 7-8 kW/kg Max. 98 kW/kg 0.14 Ω ESR |
|
[52] | CNFs Bacterial cellulose N, P-codoped | | 2 M H2SO4 (1 V) | 289 m2/g Pore vol.: 0.101 cm3/g Pore size: 2.21 nm | 205 F/g Stable up 4000 cycles. | 7.76 Wh/kg. 186 kW/kg. ESR < 1 Ω. |
B, P doped | 512 m2/g Pore vol.: 0.1735 cm3/g Pore size: 3.64 nm | 200 F/g | |
|
[53] | CNFs PAN + DEF | Electrospun | 2 M KOH (1 V). | 247 m2/g Pore volume 0.167 cm3/g Micropores 0.085 cm3/g Mesopores 0.082 cm3/g | 167 F/g 129° wetting angle | |
Oxygen plasma treatment | 274 m2/g Pore volume 0.181 cm3/g Micropore 0.099 cm3/g Mesopores 0.082 cm3/g | 377 F/g Complete wetting | |
|
[12] | CNFs, PANI on PAN N2 doped | Electrospun | 1 M H2SO4 | 410 m2/g | 335 F/g 86% after 10000 cycles | 9.2 Wh/kg 5.8 kW/kg. 4 Ω ESR. |
| Gel electrolyte | 260 F/g 0.35 F/cm2 4 F/cm3 | |
|