Clinical Study | Open Access
Muhsin Eraslan, Eren Cerman, Sumru Onal, Mehdi Suha Ogut, "Superior Oblique Anterior Transposition with Horizontal Recti Recession-Resection for Total Third-Nerve Palsy", Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 2015, Article ID 780139, 8 pages, 2015. https://doi.org/10.1155/2015/780139
Superior Oblique Anterior Transposition with Horizontal Recti Recession-Resection for Total Third-Nerve Palsy
Aims. To report the results of lateral rectus muscle recession, medial rectus muscle resection, and superior oblique muscle transposition in the restoration and maintenance of ocular alignment in primary position for patients with total third-nerve palsy. Methods. The medical records of patients who underwent surgery between March 2007 and September 2011 for total third-nerve palsy were reviewed. All patients underwent a preoperative assessment, including a detailed ophthalmologic examination. Results. A total of 6 patients (age range, 14–45 years) were included. The median preoperative horizontal deviation was 67.5 Prism Diopter (PD) (interquartile range [IQR] 57.5–70) and vertical deviation was 13.5 PD (IQR 10–20). The median postoperative horizontal residual exodeviation was 8.0 PD (IQR 1–16), and the vertical deviation was 0 PD (IQR 0–4). The median correction of hypotropia following superior oblique transposition was 13.5 ± 2.9 PD (range, 10–16). All cases were vertically aligned within 5 PD. Four of the six cases were aligned within 10 PD of the horizontal deviation. Adduction and head posture were improved in all patients. All patients gained new area of binocular single vision in the primary position after the operation. Conclusion. Lateral rectus recession, medial rectus resection, and superior oblique transposition may be used to achieve satisfactory cosmetic and functional results in total third-nerve palsy.
Oculomotor nerve palsy, in contrast to paralysis of the fourth or sixth cranial nerves that may affect the function of only one extraocular muscle, may affect the function of four of the six extraocular muscles. In complete third-nerve palsy the eye is fixed in a position of abduction, depression, and intorsion, because of the two remaining functional muscles, the lateral rectus and the superior oblique. In partial third-nerve palsy any or all of these functions may be incompletely effected. Ptosis may occur due to paralysis of levator palpebrae.
The surgical correction of oculomotor nerve palsy remains a challenge for ophthalmologists. The main goal of surgery in total third-nerve palsy is to align the paralyzed eye in a primary position, regardless of which surgical procedure is employed. Restoring adduction and elevation functions is often secondary in importance. Various surgical techniques have been described to achieve this goal .
Examples include modified Jensen and modified Hummelsheim operations or horizontal rectus muscle surgeries and superior transposition of these muscles, with or without tenotomy of the superior oblique muscle. Other modalities used are globe fixation procedures which may include periosteal flap fixation of the globe  and the suture/T-plate anchoring platform systems .
We report herein the results of surgeries undertaken for the treatment of total third-nerve palsy.
2. Materials and Methods
This is an observational case series of patients who underwent surgery for total nerve palsy. We reviewed the medical records of six patients who were evaluated at our pediatric ophthalmology and strabismus clinic from March 2007 to September 2011. This study is conducted in accordance with the amended Declaration of Helsinki and ethical clearance was obtained from the Human Research Ethics Committee of our university. The written permissions and informed consent were obtained from the patients to publish the photographs. All six patients underwent lateral rectus muscle recession, combined with medial rectus muscle resection and superior oblique muscle transposition. Only patients with a minimum of six months’ postoperative follow-up were included in the study. All the patients had functioning lateral rectus and superior oblique muscles. Demographic features, etiology of third-nerve palsy, and clinical features of the patients are shown in Table 1.
The preoperative assessment included a detailed ophthalmologic examination, including best corrected visual acuity, an external examination, a slit-lamp examination, tonometry, a fundus examination, and an assessment of ocular motility. Deviations were determined in prism diopters (PD) with a Krimsky test. The Worth four-dot test at 6 m was used to assess diplopia in the primary position. Surgery was performed at least after six months of onset.
One of the authors (MSO) performed all the surgeries under general anesthesia using an operation microscope. The final decision about the surgical dose was made peroperatively according to the forced-duction test. Using a limbal conjunctival approach, conventional lateral rectus recession was applied. The scleral fixation of the muscle was carried out with a double-armed 6.0 Vicryl suture (Vicryl, Ethicon, Somerville, NJ). Medial rectus muscle resection was then performed. Afterwards, the eye was deviated inferiorly, and the medial conjunctival incision was extended superiorly to isolate the superior oblique muscle tendon under the superior rectus. The tendons of the superior oblique muscle were isolated and cut at the medial margin of the superior rectus muscle. Then, if necessary, a resection was performed to shorten and tighten the muscle sufficiently to ensure the eye was in the primary position when it was fixed to the superior edge of the medial rectus insertion. The conjunctival incisions were closed in the conventional way. Postoperatively, commercially available topical corticosteroid-antibiotic drops were prescribed for two weeks.
The amount of recession and resection of the horizontal rectus muscles was recorded. Deviations were measured at the first day, one week, one month, and six months after the surgery, as well as during the patient’s last follow-up visit. Ocular deviations were measured by placing prisms in front of the operated eye. They were determined in PD by an alternate cover test for far and near fixation. Primary outcome measures were those defined in previous studies: the achievement of horizontal alignment within 10 PD and vertical alignment within 5 PD of orthophoria in the primary position, without the head position and relief of diplopia [9, 10].
The percentage change in the angle of deviation following the surgery for far and near fixation was reported as a secondary outcome measure. It was calculated using the preoperative and postoperative deviation obtained at the last examination.
At least after six months following the strabismus surgery, when the alignment was stabilized, ptosis was repaired in required patients with prediction of probable postoperative diplopia due to ptosis correction.
The analysis was carried out with the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) Windows version 17.0 (SPSS for Windows Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).
3. Report of Cases
3.1. Patient Number 3
A 14-year-old male presented with congenital total third-nerve palsy in the right eye. He had no history of previous ocular surgeries. On examination, he had mild ptosis and anisocoria. His best corrected visual acuity was 0.6 in the right eye and 1.0 (Snellen chart) in the left eye. Preoperative examination of eye movements revealed limitations in adduction, elevation, and depression in the right eye, but ductions were normal in the left eye. In the primary gaze position, he had exotropia of 65 PD and hypotropia of 12 PD (Figure 1). No pathological changes were identified with cranial MRI. There was a marked secondary deviation in the contralateral eye when fixing with the right eye. All movements, except abduction, were grossly limited in the right eye. Ductions of the noninvolved eye were normal. A peroperative forced-duction test revealed no restriction. He underwent a 7 mm recession of the right lateral rectus muscle, a 5 mm resection of the right medial rectus, and superior oblique transposition to the superior edge of the medial rectus.
|Preop. = preoperative. Postop. = postoperative. R = right. L = left. MR = medial rectus muscle. LR = lateral rectus muscle. SO = superior oblique muscle. Rc = recession. Rs = resection. Tr = transposition. Exotropia = XT. Esophoria = EP. Hypotropia = Ho. Prism diopter = PD.|
Numbers indicate deviation in prism diopters and millimeters of surgery performed.
On the first postoperative day, the patient had 8 PD exotropia, and his eyes were vertically aligned. He had stable alignment within 10 PD of orthotropia in follow-up examinations at one week, one month, and six months (Figure 1).
3.2. Patient Number 6
A 45-year-old male presented with total third-nerve palsy in his right eye. He had a history of hypophyseal macroadenoma and a gamma-knife procedure. Postoperatively, ptosis and squint developed. He had no history of previous ocular surgeries. Best corrected visual acuity in the right and left eye was 0.8 and 1.0 (Snellen chart), respectively. He fixated with the left eye. Mild upper lid retraction on downgaze indicated possible aberrant regeneration. In the right eye, all movements, except abduction, were grossly limited. Ductions in the noninvolved eye were normal. There was no evidence of restriction in a forced-duction test. Preoperatively, he had exotropia of 60 PD and hypotropia of 10 PD (Figure 2). He underwent a 9 mm recession of the right lateral rectus muscle, a 6 mm right medial rectus resection, and superior oblique resection and transposition.
On the first postoperative day, the patient had orthophoria, and his eyes were horizontally and vertically aligned. The ptosis was not covering the optical axis and he had no diplopia in primary position. One week, one month, and six months after the surgery, he had orthophoria in a primary position (Figure 2).
The median age of the patients was 36.5 years (age range, 14–45 years). The median follow-up time was 37 (6–54) months. The median preoperative horizontal exodeviation was 67.5 PD (interquartile range [IQR] 57.5–70) and vertical deviation was 13.5 PD (IQR 10–20), respectively. The median postoperative horizontal residual exodeviation was 8.0 PD (IQR 1–16), and the vertical deviation was 0 PD (IQR 0–4). The median correction of hypotropia was PD (range, 10–16) with superior oblique transposition. All the cases were aligned within 5 PD of vertical deviation, and four of the six cases were aligned within 10 PD of horizontal deviation. Adduction and head posture improved in all the patients. The horizontal diplopia was compensated by head deviation in patients with postoperative horizontal deviation over 10 PD (patients 1 and 2). The preoperative and postoperative patient data and the resection-recession amounts are summarized in Table 2. The preoperative and postoperative limitations of ocular movement are summarized in Table 3. Preoperative and postoperative binocular single vision area limits of all study patients and binocular visual field test results of patients number 3 and number 6 are shown in Figure 3.
Oculomotor nerve palsy is a well-defined disorder. However, the best surgical treatment technique remains controversial. In the surgical treatment of third-nerve palsy, as in any paralytic strabismus, the surgeon has to balance the muscular forces acting on the globe . In third-nerve palsies, like in all other cranial nerve palsies, if the palsy persists after the acute phase, surgery may be beneficial, if the patient understands the postoperative expectations well and agrees to undergo surgery. The aim of the surgery should be to eliminate the diplopia, to achieve a good cosmetic appearance in the primary position, and if possible to restore adduction function or to create or relocate a binocular single vision area to the most suitable place for the patient.
Many different types of surgical procedures have been described in the literature [1, 4–7, 12–19]. In the absence of medial rectus function, supramaximal resection of the medial rectus, combined with supramaximal recession of the lateral rectus, is mostly insufficient to align the primary gaze in third-nerve palsies. In total paralysis, adduction will not be gained without medial transposition of a functioning muscle. Therefore, most authors advocate transposition procedures [4, 13].
In a study conducted in 1996, Von Noorden  suggested transposition of the vertical recti to the insertion of the medial rectus following tenotomy of the lateral rectus and the superior oblique muscles. Peter  and later Aoki et al.  described a different technique involving fracturing the trochlea and attaching the shortened superior oblique tendon to the medial rectus insertion. Scott  modified this procedure by transposing the superior oblique tendon without trochleatomy. As shown in the study of Harley  more adduction is achieved using the procedure proposed by Jackson than that proposed by Scott. However, Maruo et al.  reported cosmetically satisfactory results with Scott’s procedure when combined with recession of the lateral and superior recti. Gottlob et al.  achieved satisfactory long-term results with Scott’s procedure, combined with recession of the lateral rectus, in seven patients with total third-nerve palsy. We are of the opinion that it is important to assess the functions of all muscles affected in partial third-nerve palsy before deciding the right trade-off for this procedure. Any transposition procedure would not create a new force; it only may change or possibly increase the binocular single vision area. As an example in patient 3 the procedure created a limitation in depression; however patient gained a new area of binocular single vision in the primary position as given in example in Figure 3.
Arblaster and Burke also reported that cosmetic as well as substantial subjective and objective functional improvements can be achieved in longstanding strabismus, even in cases of Chiari II malformation causing bilateral internuclear ophthalmoplegia and unilateral third-nerve palsy. They showed the enlarged and centralized binocular single vision area following surgeries using Goldman visual field testing similar to our report. Their patient reported significant functional improvements in daily activities even when minimal objective improvements were achieved in adduction and primary position alignment .
In the technique presented herein, vertical recti are preserved, and the procedure is applied only to the affected eye and completed in one session. We achieved cosmetically and functionally satisfactory outcomes in all patients. All cases were vertically aligned within 5 PD, and four cases were horizontally aligned within 10 PD. All patients were eventually satisfied with their cosmetic appearance. The patients also gained some adduction function. The horizontal diplopia was compensated by head deviation in two patients with postoperative horizontal deviation over 10 PD (patients 1 and 2). Two cases (patients 3 and 5) showed a limitation in the inferior gaze that could be compensated with a 10-degree head tilt.
The median correction of hypodeviation following superior oblique transposition was found to be (10–16) PD. We are of the opinion that superior oblique transposition adds about 15 to 20 PD (median ) corrections of exodeviation when compared with the standard surgical dose table . Other types of procedures, including horizontal recti surgeries alone, can also help in achievement of orthophoria in primary position for short-term, but most cases show disruption of alignment in long-term. Modified Scott’s procedure can help in achievement of orthophoria and most importantly helps in stabilization of alignment in primary position for long-term.
Although we obtained satisfactory results with the procedure described herein, it has some limitations, including postoperative hyperdeviation, which was within 5 PD. But patient satisfaction was generally good because all patients increased their binocular single vision area eventually. Hypertropia and extorsion may occur due to the loss of superior oblique muscle function. Hypertropia can be resolved secondarily with a superior rectus muscle recession, and hypotropia can be resolved with an inferior rectus recession . More studies should be done to optimize the localization of the superior oblique muscle in transposition.
Blepharoptosis is a common finding in patients with third cranial nerve palsy . Ptosis correction in such patients is challenging and most of the patients need multistep surgical plan. The possibility of postoperative diplopia following ptosis correction procedure must be kept in mind before deciding for surgery. The examination for diplopia has to be done with upper eyelids lifted to consider whether existing ptosis prevents the underlying diplopia. In this kind of patients with an underlying diplopia the correction may lead to disturbance of vision and may reduce patient’s quality of life. Although the surgical treatment of ptosis due to third cranial nerve palsy is difficult, an appropriate approach and previously planned multiple interventions might achieve acceptable results in considerable number of patients . In our case series we followed the patients at least six months after the strabismus surgery; ptosis was repaired in required patients after a detailed diplopia examination as described previously when the alignment was stabilized.
Not evaluating stereopsis and torsion is the limitation of the study.
In conclusion, patients with third-nerve palsies may regain acceptable eye alignments with this technique. Some patients may even regain limited adduction function after the procedure, whereas others may experience limitations in downgaze.
English-language editing of this manuscript was provided by Scribendi.
The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.
Conflict of Interests
The authors report no conflict of interests. The authors have no financial interest on any of the materials mentioned in the study.
Design of the study was done by Muhsin Eraslan, Sumru Onal, and Mehdi Suha Ogut; conducting the study was done by Muhsin Eraslan, Eren Cerman, Sumru Onal, and Mehdi Suha Ogut; collection was done by Muhsin Eraslan; management was done by Muhsin Eraslan; analysis and interpretation of the data were done by Muhsin Eraslan and Eren Cerman; preparation was done by Muhsin Eraslan, Eren Cerman, and Sumru Onal; review was done by Muhsin Eraslan, Eren Cerman, and Mehdi Suha Ogut.
- A. W. Biglan and P. G. Walden, “Results following surgical management of oculomotor nerve palsy with a modified Knapp procedure,” Ophthalmic Surgery, vol. 16, no. 12, pp. 759–764, 1985.
- R. Ahmed, D. K. Coats, and M. T. Yen, “Periosteal flap fixation of the globe for surgical treatment of severe restrictive strabismus: a report of eight cases with outcomes,” Binocular Vision and Strabology Quarterly, vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 230–235, 2011.
- K. A. Sadagopan and B. N. Wasserman, “Managing the patient with oculomotor nerve palsy,” Current Opinion in Ophthalmology, vol. 24, no. 5, pp. 438–447, 2013.
- I. Gottlob, R. A. Catalano, and R. D. Reinecke, “Surgical management of oculomotor nerve palsy,” American Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 111, no. 1, pp. 71–76, 1991.
- H. S. Metz and D. Yee, “Third nerve palsy: superior oblique transposition surgery,” Annals of Ophthalmology, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 215–218, 1973.
- R. D. Harley, “Paralytic strabismus in children. Etiologic incidence and management of the third, fourth, and sixth nerve palsies,” Ophthalmology, vol. 87, no. 1, pp. 24–43, 1980.
- A. B. Scott, “Transposition of the superior oblique,” The American Orthoptic Journal, vol. 27, pp. 11–14, 1977.
- T. L. Young, B. M. Conahan, C. G. Summers, and J. E. Egbert, “Anterior transposition of the superior oblique tendon in the treatment of oculomotor nerve palsy and its influence on postoperative hypertropia,” Journal of Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 149–155, 2000.
- C. P. Noonan and M. O'Connor, “Surgical management of third nerve palsy,” The British Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 79, no. 5, pp. 431–434, 1995.
- G. R. Beauchamp, B. C. Black, D. K. Coats et al., “The management of strabismus in adults—I. Clinical characteristics and treatment,” Journal of AAPOS, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 233–240, 2003.
- T. Yanovitch and E. Buckley, “Diagnosis and management of third nerve palsy,” Current Opinion in Ophthalmology, vol. 18, no. 5, pp. 373–378, 2007.
- T. Maruo, H. Iwashige, N. Kubota et al., “Results of surgery for paralytic exotropia due to oculomotor palsy,” Ophthalmologica, vol. 210, no. 3, pp. 163–167, 1996.
- M. D. Daniell, R. M. Gregson, and J. P. Lee, “Management of fixed divergent squint in third nerve palsy using traction sutures,” Australian and New Zealand Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 261–265, 1996.
- R. A. Saunders and G. L. Rogers, “Superior oblique transposition for third nerve palsy,” Ophthalmology, vol. 89, no. 4, pp. 310–316, 1982.
- P. Prakash, P. S. Negi, and V. Menon, “Anterior segment ischaemia following muscle transposition procedures—(an experimental study on monkeys),” Indian Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 35, no. 5-6, pp. 372–374, 1987.
- L. C. Peter, “The use of the superior oblique as an internal rotator in third nerve paralysis,” Transactions of the American Ophthalmological Society, vol. 31, pp. 232–237, 1933.
- K. Aoki, T. Sakaue, N. Kubota, and T. Maruo, “Outcome of surgery for bilateral third nerve palsy,” Japanese Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 46, no. 5, pp. 540–547, 2002.
- H. E. A. Bicas, “A surgically implanted elastic band to restore paralyzed ocular rotations,” Journal of Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 10–13, 1991.
- E. G. Buckley and L. M. Townshend, “A simple transposition procedure for complicated strabismus,” American Journal of Ophthalmology, vol. 111, no. 3, pp. 302–306, 1991.
- G. Von Noorden, Paralytic Strabismus, Mosby, Santiago, Chile, 1996.
- G. Arblaster and J. P. Burke, “Restoration of binocular single vision following multiple treatments for longstanding bilateral internuclear ophthalmoplegia and unilateral 3rd nerve paresis,” British and Irish Orthoptic Journal, vol. 9, pp. 70–73, 2012.
- A. B. Scott, A. J. Mash, and A. Jampolsky, “Quantitative guidelines for exotropia surgery,” Investigative Ophthalmology, vol. 14, no. 6, pp. 428–436, 1975.
- J. Yonghong, Z. Kanxing, L. Wei, W. Xiao, W. Jinghui, and Z. Fanghua, “Surgical management of large-angle incomitant strabismus in patients with oculomotor nerve palsy,” Journal of AAPOS, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 49–53, 2008.
- C. K. Beyer and R. W. McCarthy, “Surgical treatment of ptosis in acquired third nerve paralysis,” Annals of Ophthalmology, vol. 13, no. 3, pp. 373–376, 1981.
- A. Bagheri, M. Borhani, S. Salehirad, S. Yazdani, and M. Tavakoli, “Blepharoptosis associated with third cranial nerve palsy,” Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 357–360, 2015.
Copyright © 2015 Muhsin Eraslan et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.