Abstract
Objective. To describe the multimodal imaging of Schnyder corneal dystrophy. Methods. Seven eyes of seven patients (5 female and 2 male patients) aged 52 to 92 years were included in this prospective observational study. Diagnosis of SCD was confirmed by histology after keratoplasty. In vivo multimodal imaging consisted of spectral domain-optical coherence tomography with cross sections, en face scans, corneal pachymetry, and epithelial mapping, and in vivo confocal microscopy was recorded. Ex vivo full-field optical coherence tomography scans of two corneal buttons were analyzed. The seven corneal buttons obtained during penetrating or deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty were processed for light microscopy. Results. Slit-lamp examination showed central stromal opacities, arcus lipoides, and midperipheral haze. Corneal crystals were found in 2 out of 7 eyes. SD-OCT cross sections and en face scans showed diffuse hyperreflectivity of the anterior, mid, and posterior stroma with a maximum in the anterior stroma, hyporeflective stromal striae, and epithelial hyperreflectivity. Central corneal thickness ranged from 507 to 635 μm. IVCM revealed hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium and throughout the stroma, thin subepithelial nerves, and needle-shaped and rectangular crystals. Keratocyte nuclei were rare or undetectable. FF-OCT scans confirmed the presence of small round and needle-shaped hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium and stroma. Histology revealed vacuolization of the basal epithelial cells and empty interlamellar stromal vacuoles. Conclusion. High-resolution multimodal imaging demonstrates the characteristic features of SCD which involve both the corneal epithelium and stroma, and it provides diagnosis confirmation even in eyes with no visible corneal crystals at slit-lamp examination.
1. Introduction
Schnyder corneal dystrophy (SCD) is a rare autosomal dominant disease that results in deposits of cholesterol and phospholipids in the corneal stroma [1–3]. Mutations in the UBIAD1 gene (genetic locus 1p36) were shown to be responsible for the disease [4, 5]. Association with metabolic disorders, such as hypercholesterolemia, has been suggested [6]. The main clinical features of the dystrophy include corneal crystals, central discoid opacities, arcus lipoides, and stromal haze. However, crystals are only found in 54% of cases [7]. SCD is a bilateral slowly progressive disease, and corneal features are age-related. Central opacities and/or crystals are often observed in patients aged 23 years or younger, arcus lipoides appears in patients aged between 23 and 38 years, and finally midperipheral stromal haze can develop in patients after the age of 38, causing cloudiness of the cornea [8]. Visual acuity and photopic vision decrease with age.
The diagnosis of SCD is established with slit-lamp examination and confirmed by histopathology and genetic testing. Light microscopy analysis reveals abnormal deposits of both intracellular and extracellular esterified and unesterified phospholipids and cholesterol in basal epithelial cells, Bowman layer, and stroma [9]. Lipid accumulation has also been observed with transmission electron microscopy [10].
The absence of visible corneal crystals makes the diagnosis more challenging. Modern imaging techniques such as spectral domain-optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) and in vivo confocal microscopy (IVCM) allow a more precise approach to the disease at all stages, especially when crystals are absent. Both imaging techniques have become the modality of choice for in vivo assessment of corneal disorders.
Full-field optical coherence tomography (FF-OCT) is a noninvasive technique that provides detailed ex vivo en face and cross-sectional imaging of corneal structures with a theoretical resolution close to 1 μm in all three dimensions. It allows a cellular resolution very similar to histology [11, 12].
The objective of the present study was to report the distinguishing features of SCD in seven patients using SD-OCT, IVCM, and FF-OCT and the histological findings in corneal buttons obtained after keratoplasty.
2. Materials and Methods
This was a prospective observational study which was part of the MicroEye project. Informed consent was obtained, and Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval was obtained from the Patient Protection Committee, Ile-de-France V (14944). The study was carried out according to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki and followed international ethical requirements for human tissues.
Inclusion criteria were as follows: corneal disorder requiring transplantation, preoperative assessment with multimodal imaging (i.e., SD-OCT and IVCM), postoperative assessment of the recipient corneal button with histology and FF-OCT, diagnosis of Schnyder corneal dystrophy confirmed by histological analysis of the corneal button, and written informed consent. Exclusion criterion was as follows: nonconclusive histological analysis of the corneal button. Recipient age and sex were not included in inclusion/exclusion criteria.
We included 7 eyes of 7 patients who had been previously clinically diagnosed with SCD between 2013 and 2017 and who were referred for transplantation in our institution. The diagnosis was confirmed by histology of the corneal button after keratoplasty in all eyes. Best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), slit-lamp photographs, and central corneal thickness were recorded. All patients underwent SD-OCT with epithelial mapping, as well as IVCM imaging for six patients before keratoplasty. Corneal buttons obtained from either penetrating or deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty were processed for light microscopy analysis. FF-OCT was performed before processing of tissue for histology on 2 out of 7 corneal buttons.
SD-OCT cross-sectional and en face scans were obtained using the RTVue® device (Optovue, Inc., Fremont, CA), with an axial theoretical resolution of 5 μm. In vivo corneal morphology was assessed using the Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II with a Rostock Cornea Module (HRT II RCM) (Heidelberg Engineering GmbH, Dossenheim, Germany). 400 × 400 μm en face images of all the corneal layers were acquired. The LightCT FF-OCT device (LLTech, Paris, France) was used to analyze corneal buttons. Stacks of 800 μm × 800 μm en face images were captured in the central zone of the cornea, and cross-sectional views were reconstructed from the 3D data stack. All corneal buttons were fixed in formaldehyde (10%) and embedded in paraffin. Multiple sections were then stained with hematoxylin-eosin-safran (HES), periodic acid-Schiff (PAS), and Masson’s trichrome stain and observed with a light microscope.
A retrospective healthy group was used as control. It included five eyes of patients with normal corneas imaged with FF-OCT and IVCM and two normal human donor corneas imaged with FF-OCT.
3. Results
Seven eyes of five female and two male patients aged 52 to 92 years were included in our study. Preoperative best-corrected visual acuity ranged from 20/2000 to 20/50. All patients had a family history of cloudy corneas. Slit-lamp examination revealed central opacities, midperipheral stromal haze, and peripheral arcus lipoides (Figure 1(a)) in all seven patients, except in the youngest patient who only presented with central disciform opacity (Figure 1(b)). Corneal crystals were observed in only 2 out of 7 patients (Figures 1(c) and 1(d)). The mean (±standard deviation) central corneal thickness was 563 ± 44 μm (range, 507–635 μm). The clinical data, corneal pachymetry, and epithelial mapping of all patients are shown in Table 1.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Cross-sectional SD-OCT showed diffuse hyperreflective corneal stromal opacities which were maximum in the anterior stroma (Figure 2(a)), expanding to the limbus when arcus lipoides was present (Figure 2(b)). In one patient with prominent corneal crystals, diffuse posterior optical shadow from the stromal side was observed (Figure 2(c)). Epithelial mapping revealed areas of thick and irregular epithelium, ranging from 62 to 76 μm within the central 5 mm zone. In one case, SD-OCT showed a thick hyperreflective epithelial basement membrane (Figure 2(d)) that appeared to expand into the epithelium in en face OCT scans. En face OCT scans revealed diffuse hyperreflective opacities located in the epithelium (Figure 2(e)), anterior (Figure 2(f)), and mid and posterior stroma (Figure 2(g)) in all patients, and hyporeflective stromal striae in the posterior stroma in three patients (Figure 2(g)).
IVCM of the epithelium showed small round hyperreflective deposits with increased background reflectivity in five patients (Figure 3(a)), undulations of the epithelial basement membrane and Bowman layer, and thin subbasal nerves in four patients (Figures 3(c) and 3(d)). The subbasal nerve plexus was not detected in the remaining 3 patients. Epithelial cells featured normal shape in the superficial, intermediate, and basal cell layers. In one patient, epithelial deposits appeared to be rod-shaped (Figure 3(b)). The keratocyte nuclei were either rare or undetectable. Increased background reflectivity was observed in the anterior, mid, and posterior stroma. Most hyperreflective deposits appeared to be needle-shaped (Figures 3(e), 3(g), and 3(h)), and in one patient, rectangular-shaped deposits were noted as well (Figure 3(f)). Stromal striae were more easily visible with IVCM than with en face SD-OCT (Figures 3(e)–3(h)). Endothelial cells appeared normal (Figure 3(i)).
Two corneal buttons were analyzed with FF-OCT after keratoplasty. Cross-sectional scans showed diffuse hyperreflective opacities in the anterior stroma (Figure 4(a)), and en face images revealed small round hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium (Figures 4(b)-4(c)) and small needle-shaped deposits in the anterior, mid, and posterior stroma (Figures 4(d)–4(e)). We also observed hyperreflective basement membrane. Keratocyte nuclei were undetectable, and stromal striae were also more easily visible compared with en face SD-OCT scans (Figure 4(e)).
All patients underwent keratoplasty, and corneal buttons were processed for histology which showed cytoplasmic vacuolization of basal epithelial cells. Basal epithelial cell nuclei were surrounded by a clear halo (Figures 5(a)–5(c)) in five patients, and empty interlamellar stromal vacuoles were observed in all patients (Figure 5(a)). The Bowman layer was preserved (Figure 5(c)). Keratocyte density was low from the anterior down to the posterior corneal stroma. Endothelium and Descemet membrane appeared to be normal (Figure 5(d)).
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Multimodal imaging of normal human corneas (Figure 6) did not reveal any of the indicators of Schnyder dystrophy revealed by SD-OCT, IVCCM, and FF-OCT.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
The SD-OCT, IVCM, FF-OCT, and histology findings of all subjects are shown in Table 2.
Comparison with patient other eye did not reveal bilateral asymmetric disease presentation. Corneal central thickness was symmetric, and same SD-OCT and IVCM features of Schnyder dystrophy were observed in fellow eyes. Last, FF-OCT and histology were available only in the transplanted eyes.
4. Discussion
Corneal changes in SCD are age-dependent. Arcus lipoides tends to appear between 23 and 38 years of age, and midperipheral stromal haze develops in older patients [3]. Our patients featured late age of diagnosis and surgery. As our institution is a tertiary reference center, all our patients were referred at the time keratoplasty. As a matter of fact, the age of inclusion does not reflect the age of onset of the dystrophy. The youngest patient (52 years old) presented only with central disk-like corneal opacity with no arcus lipoides. Stromal haze was prominent in three of our oldest patients, aged 82, 84, and 92 years. According to Weiss et al., corneal crystals are found in approximately 50% of patients with SCD [7]. Only two of our seven patients presented with crystals. However, the number of patients examined was relatively low compared with that of the previous studies [13]. Absence of crystals renders the diagnosis of SCD more challenging and previous studies have shown the ability of modern imaging techniques such as SD-OCT and IVCM to identify the corneal features of SCD by allowing an in-depth evaluation of corneal structures [13–16].
Previously published data on SD-OCT in SCD included hyperreflective corneal opacities located under the epithelium and in the anterior stroma and a diffuse optical shadow from the stromal side [15]. This was consistent with our findings. We observed hyperreflective corneal opacities in the anterior stroma that extended to the limbus, except in our youngest patient who did not present with arcus lipoides (Figure 1(b)). In addition, we observed diffuse optical shadow from the stromal side in one patient who had prominent central corneal crystals on slit-lamp examination. Pachymetry was normal, and epithelial mapping revealed areas of irregular and thickened epithelium within the central 5 mm zone in all patients, which may be consistent with the presence of lipid and cholesterol deposits in the central epithelium as suggested by histology findings.
SD-OCT en face images showed diffuse high reflectivity in the epithelium, anterior, mid, and posterior stroma, which corresponded to the hyperreflective deposits observed with IVCM and FF-OCT at the same level. Presence of epithelial hyperreflectivity was consistent with presence of areas of thick and irregular epithelium on epithelial mapping. A previous study also reported highly reflective anterior corneal stroma on en face OCT scans suggesting crystal and/or lipid deposits in a SCD case, but the epithelium and Bowman layer seemed intact [17]. Stromal striae were visualized with SD-OCT en face scans in 3 patients. These striae correspond to undulations of the stromal lamellae associated with the viscoelastic behavior of the corneal stroma [18]. They are usually difficult to visualize with SD-OCT in normal corneas and easy to visualize with IVCM due to the higher resolution of the latter technique. Increased background reflectivity of the stroma in SCD may enhance the contrast between striae and the remaining stroma and makes the former easier to visualize with SD-OCT.
One patient presented an irregular epithelial basement membrane expanding into the epithelium which is a common finding in corneal epithelial basement membrane dystrophy [19]. Association of SCD with the latter dystrophy/degeneration may be the consequence of the high prevalence of the latter corneal disorder.
Previously published IVCM findings in SCD included damaged subepithelial nerves, increased background stromal reflectivity, and needle-shaped or rectangular deposits in the anterior stroma [14–16]. We observed small round hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium in four patients, as well as undulated basement membrane, but epithelial cells appeared normal in all layers. Evans et al. also observed round hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium and anterior stroma in an 8-year old child with SCD, as well as needle-shaped crystals, but posterior stroma was unaffected [16]. Vesaluoma et al. suggested that in advanced stages of SCD, large crystals are deposited in the anterior stroma and subbasal nerves are damaged, thus leading to decreased corneal sensation [20]. This observation was consistent with our findings. All seven patients, aged 52 years and older, presented with advanced forms of SCD, and although corneal sensation was not tested, IVCM scans revealed thin subbasal nerves in four patients, whereas subbasal nerves were undetectable in the remaining two patients assessed with IVCM.
Weiss showed that, although crystals were always subepithelial, SCD affected the entire thickness of the corneal stroma in the majority of patients [7]. This was corroborated by our findings. However, to the best of our knowledge, hyperreflective deposits in the posterior stroma have not yet been described with IVCM in SCD. Thanks to its high lateral resolution, IVCM showed hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium, needle-shaped crystals in the anterior stroma, sometimes coexisting with rectangular crystals, as well as hyperreflective material and increased background reflectivity in the mid and posterior stroma. Endothelium and Descemet membrane appeared normal in all IVCM images.
This study reports for the first time full-field optical coherence tomography findings in SCD. FF-OCT provides a cellular resolution similar to histology with no need for staining and fixatives [12]. It showed the hyperreflective deposits observed with IVCM in the epithelium and throughout the stroma. However, the needle-shaped and rectangular crystals were better highlighted with IVCM.
Documented histological findings in crystalline and noncrystalline forms of SCD included epithelial, stromal, and endothelial changes, characterized by the presence of vacuoles in basal cells, stroma, and endothelial cells [15, 21]. Interestingly, we observed similar cytoplasmic vacuolization in addition to nuclei surrounded by a clear halo in basal epithelial cells in five patients. The hyperreflective deposits in the epithelium evidenced with IVCM, en face OCT scans, and FF-OCT may correspond to lipid and/or cholesterol accumulation in the epithelium. This would be consistent with the clear halo surrounding nuclei and mild cytoplasmic vacuolization observed in the basal epithelial cells with histology. In fact, the histology preparation process including paraffin embedding dissolves lipids which appear as empty spaces in stained samples observed with light microscopy. Staining with oil red O or Sudan black would reveal lipids but it was not available in our series. Abnormal lipid and cholesterol accumulation in epithelial cells has also been documented with electron microscopy of corneas with SCD [9, 21, 22]. Unlike Nowinska et al., we did not observe any vacuoles in endothelial cells [15].
Our findings show that not only SCD results in stromal and epithelial lipid deposits but also it involves corneal cells as keratocytes, subbasal nerves, and basal epithelial cells were found to be affected by the disease process.
The main limitation of this study, besides the small number of patients included, was the lack of genetic testing for mutations in the UBIAD1 gene. However, SCD was confirmed by conventional histology following keratoplasty which provided diagnosis evidence. Another limitation of the study was that all the patients enrolled were old and none of subjects were in early disease or developing disease. Further longitudinal studies are needed to determine whether the multimodal imaging features of Schnyder dystrophy can be detected in the early stage of the disease.
5. Conclusion
High-resolution multimodal imaging techniques demonstrate the characteristic features of SCD which involve both the corneal epithelium and stroma and provide diagnosis confirmation even in eyes with no visible corneal crystals at slit-lamp examination.
Data Availability
The anonymized data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.
Conflicts of Interest
VMB works at Chiesi (Parma, Italy; consulting).
Authors’ Contributions
VMB and WG designed and conducted the study and prepared the manuscript. WG, CG, KG, NB, and VMB were responsible for collection, management, analysis, and interpretation of the data and reviewed and approved the manuscript.
Acknowledgments
The research was funded by an ANR PRTS Grant (ANR-13-PRTS-0009; Paris, France).