A Study on High Secure and Efficient MANET Routing Scheme

Table 3

The comparison table of secure function.

	Boukerche et al. [31]	PD-ZAP	G-ZAP	RR-ZAP	Ours
Anonymity
Source	○				○
Destination	○	△	△	△	○
Middle node	X	△	△	△	○
Security	○	○	○	○	○
Confidentiality	○	○	○	○	○
Authentication	○	○	○	○	○
Traceability	△	X	X	X	○
Nonrepudiation	○	△	△	△	○
Unforgeability	○	X	X	X	○
Uncounterfeit	○	X	X	X	○
Flexibility for multipaths	X	X	X	X	○

○: achieved, X: unachieved, △: partially achieved, and : not considered.