Sensors and Applications in Agricultural and Environmental MonitoringView this Special Issue
Research Article | Open Access
Fancheng Zeng, Liang Xu, Caiyun Sun, Hong Liu, Libo Chen, "A Novel Bioflocculant from Raoultella planticola Enhances Removal of Copper Ions from Water", Journal of Sensors, vol. 2020, Article ID 2581205, 10 pages, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/2581205
A Novel Bioflocculant from Raoultella planticola Enhances Removal of Copper Ions from Water
Copper is one of the most toxic heavy metals. In this work, a sampling survey of copper ions in the water of Songhua River flowing through the chemical and living areas of Jilin City was studied. A new bioflocculant from Raoultella planticola was obtained. The investigation of Songhua River flowing through Jilin City shows that the copper concentration is between 0.07 ppb and 0.16 ppb. The bioflocculant supporting graphite oxide (GO) as a bioflocculant inducer used in this study has been utilized in treatment of copper ions in water. GO and bioflocculant infrared radiation (IR) spectrum and zeta potential were studied. Flocculational conditions of copper ion (0.2 ppm) were modeled and optimized using RSM (response surface methodology). Our data showed that flocculation efficiency was over 80%. Significant influencing factors and variables were pH, flocculation time, bioflocculant dosage, and GO inducer which had major impact effects on flocculation efficiency. The highest flocculation efficiency which is 86.01% was achieved at , at 1.62 h and 13.11 mg bioflocculant with 13.11 mg GO as an inducer. However, temperature (A) and GO inducer were significant impact factors on the flocculation efficiency.
Copper is widely used in metallurgy, machine manufacturing, electroplating, chemistry, and other industries. In agriculture and forestry, copper sulfate can prevent diseases and insect pests and inhibit the proliferation of algae in water. Copper chloride, copper sulfate, and copper nitrate are easy to dissolve in water. The total content of copper in a normal human body is about 100-150 mg . However, excessive intake will stimulate the digestive system, causing abdominal pain and vomiting. The oral lethal dose of humans is about 10 g . The toxicity of copper to lower organisms and crops is relatively high. When the concentration of copper reaches 0.1-0.2 mg/L , fish will die. When it coexists with zinc, the toxicity will increase, and the toxicity to shellfish water will be greater . Generally, the concentration of copper in water for aquaculture is required to be below 0.01 mg/L . For crops, copper is the most toxic heavy metal, which is fixed in the root cortex after absorbing copper ions, affecting nutrient absorption. When the copper content in irrigation water is high, it accumulates in soil and crops, which can make crops wither .
Bioflocculant is a kind of polymer compound. It must be secreted by specific microbial groups under specific growth conditions. The complexity of the molecular components of bioflocculant, such as protein, polysaccharide, and glycoprotein, determines its good electrochemical properties. Therefore, it is endowed with good flocculation characteristics [7, 8]. At present, it is widely explored and studied as a new flocculant. Many publications have reported on bioflocculants to replace traditional industrial flocculants in drinking and wastewater treatment process and fermentation processes because of its high removal efficiency, low dosage, and less secondary pollution in the environment [9, 10]. Graphene oxide (GO) is a new material which has attracted wide attention in recent years. Because of its excellent electrochemical properties, it has been widely used in electronic technology, biosensors, nanotubes, semiconductors, and other fields. Graphite oxide, as a novel material with a unique structure and excellent properties, has attracted extensive attention [11, 12]. GO is a two-dimensional nanomaterial with a honeycomb-like monolayer structure and has a large number of its surface’s active groups, such as epoxy groups, hydroxyl, and carboxyl. GO has an aromatic structure and can adsorb aromatic compounds through the interaction between the active groups and the electron cloud .
Therefore, due to graphite oxide’s unique structure, there are excellent physical and chemical properties and good biocompatibility. Though graphene oxide has been used as a flocculant in water treatment, the main research is still at the laboratory level, and there are few reports on the actual application of wastewater treatment. The bioflocculant supporting graphite oxide as a bioflocculant inducer used in this study has been studied in the treatment of copper ions in surface water. Accordingly, the objectives of this work are to (1) study a sample survey of copper ions in the water of Songhua River flowing through the chemical and living areas of Jilin City; (2) screen bioflocculant-producing strains for flocculation of copper ions; (3) optimize temperature, pH, bioflocculant dosage, GO inducer, and flocculation time on the flocculation process by response surface methodology (RSM); and (4) analyze the end group properties of bioflocculant and the potential changes in the process of flocculation.
2. Material and Methods
2.1. Identification of Bioflocculant-Producing Strains
Approximately 200 isolates (-1 to -200) were screened from the activated sludge of the Secondary Wastewater Treatment Plant in Jilin, China. The 16s rDNA was amplified by PCR in Shanghai Sangon Biotechnology Co., Ltd. Primers (27F: AGAGTTTGATCCTGGCTCAG and 1492R: GGTTACCTTGTTACGACTT) were used in 16s rDNA amplification and identification of strains. Sequence similarity was over 97.1%. The comparison of sequencing data showed that the species of the strain was Raoultella planticola by which ncbi access No. is KC456530.1. The Nikon-e100 microscope was used to observe the morphological characteristics of the strain, and the Bergey system bacteriology manual was used to identify the physiological and biochemical characteristics of the strain. Raoultella planticola is a gram-negative, aerobic, rod bacterium.
2.2. Culture Medium for Raoultella planticola Bioflocculant Production
Raoultella planticola was cultivated using beef extract-peptone medium containing 5 g/L of peptone, 1.5 g/L of beef extract, 1.5 g/L of yeast extract, and 5 g/L of NaCl. Bioflocculant production culture medium was different from PT-1 which we used in former work [14, 15]. Composition of the bioflocculant medium in this study was as follows: glucose, 20 g/L; yeast extract, 0.5 g/L; urea, 0.5 g/L; (NH4)2SO4, 0.2 g/L; KH2PO4, 7 g/L; MgSO4, 0.2 g/L; and NaCl, 0.1 g/L. The initial pH of the medium was adjusted to . After sterilization, the strain was put into the flask containing the medium, the culture temperature was 30°C, the vibration frequency was 150 rpm, and the best time for bacteria to secrete flocculant was 72 hours.
2.3. Preparation of the Raoultella planticola Bioflocculant (MBF-51)
Raoultella planticola was inoculated into a 150 mL flask containing 50 mL PT-1 medium. The bioflocculant was termed MBF-51 and was produced by shaking the flask at 30°C at 150 rpm for 72 h. Cell-free supernatants were obtained by centrifugation at 7000 rpm for 30 min. Bioflocculant purification methods were conducted according to previous methods. Briefly, two volumes of cold ethanol (at 4°C) were added to 1 L culture broth. Following centrifugation at 8000 rpm for 30 min, the precipitate was washed with ethanol, dissolved in 5 mL of deionized water, and vacuum-dried resulting in approximately g of MBF-51 per 1 L of culture broth.
2.4. Preparation of Nanoscale Graphene Oxide
Graphene oxide was prepared by the modified Hummers method . The preparation steps were as follows: 2.0 g graphite powder was added into 50 mL concentrated H2SO4 solution with 2.0 g NaNO3 dissolved. After stirring for 15 minutes, 6.0 g KMnO4 was added slowly (keeping system temperature below 15°C), reaction at 35°C for 1 h, heating up to 90°C for 15 min, distilled water at 200 mL was added. Graphite powder was heated with boiling reaction for 15 min. As the graphite dropped to room temperature, it is added with 12 mL H2O2 for 8 hours. Then, the mixture is filtered and collected after centrifugation. SO4 ion was removed by washing with distilled water. The powder was vacuum-dried until constant weight. Then, GO powder was obtained. 0.2 g GO powder is dispersed in 400 mL distilled water to make the concentration to 0.5 mg/mL.
2.5. Batch Experiment of Microbial Flocculation of Copper
By adding distilled water, the microbial flocculant MBF-51 was diluted to 60 mg/L for copper flocculation. The impacts of flocculation conditions (temperature (°C), pH value, flocculation time (hour), dosage of bioflocculant (mg/L), and dosage of GO inducer (mg/L)) on flocculation effect were analyzed. The pH was adjusted from 0.1 M HCl and 0.1 M NaOH to about 3.0-1.0. Similarly, the effect of temperature is cultivated at the desired temperature.
After the setting of fixed variable factors, the mixture containing MBF-51 solution, GO inducer, and copper ion (CuCl2) was shaken in the track vibrating screen (mode-hzq-x100, HDL Equipment Co., Ltd., China) and stirred at a constant speed of 250 rpm. The initial copper concentration was selected as 0.2 ppm (area No. 4). The optical density of supernatant was measured at the middle height of clarified liquid. The culture medium without flocculant and GO was used as the control. Flocculation efficiency of copper was calculated by where is the value of the atomic absorption spectrum determined by the sample and is the value of the reference sample determined by atomic absorption spectrometry.
2.6. The Establishment of Mathematical Model for the Influence of Different Factors
The Design-Expert software (8.3 edition) adopts the experimental statistical design and data analysis, and the experimental design is referred to our previous research papers . The narrow temperature, pH value, flocculation time, the dosage of bioflocculant, and the range of GO inducer were determined before central composite design (CCD) and response surface method (RSM) were used for modeling. The narrower ranges of temperature, pH, flocculation time, bioflocculant dosage, and GO inducer were chosen as 5–35°C, 4–10, 0-3 hours, 2.5-17.5 mg/L, and 1.5–10.5 mg/L, respectively. Five independent factors at different levels (-2, -1, 0, +1, and +2) were studied. The experimental design is shown in Table 1.
The relationship between the response variable () of flocculation efficiency and each factor variable is fitted by the second-order model, and the following quadratic polynomial equation (2) is finally obtained for calculation:
All analyses are in triplicate. The data in the response surface was fitted with the average of three groups of repeated data, and variance analysis was carried out.
2.7. Analytical Methods
Zeta potential measurement was conducted by a zeta potential analyzer (Malvern Nano ZS, Malvern, England). A Fourier-transform infrared spectrometer (Nicolet 6700, ThermoFisher, USA) was used for space atmospheric component detection. A scanning electron microscope (XL30-ESEM, FEI, USA) was used for studies. An atomic absorption spectrometer (180-Series, HITACHI, Japan) was used to determine the total copper concentration in water. The positions and longitude and latitude of the required logging stations are shown in Table 2.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Investigation on Copper Content in Water in Songhua River Section Flowing through Jilin City
Jilin City is located in the east of the central part of Jilin Province, the northeast hinterland of Changbai Mountains, the junction of Songnen Plain and Changbai Mountains. It is the secondary economic and cultural center of northeast Jilin Province as is shown in Figure 1(a). Its geographical coordinates are between 42 degrees north latitude 31 to 44 degrees 40 and 125 degrees 40 to 127 degrees east longitude 56. The north and south are about 91 kilometers long and 44 kilometers wide. The total area under the jurisdiction of Jilin City is 27700 square kilometers, of which the urban area is 3774.35 square kilometers; by the end of 2016, the urban area of Jilin City is 498.75 square kilometers, and the built-up area is 189.04 square kilometers. The positions and longitude and latitude of the required logging stations are shown in Table 2. The investigation in Figure 1(a) shows that the copper concentration in this area is the lowest 0.066 ppb (area No. 10) and the highest is 0.159 ppb (area No. 4). From data in Figure 1(b), it can be seen that the copper content index of the three water samples did not exceed the Class III standard of the Surface Water Quality Standard .
3.2. Zeta Potential and Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectrometer Analysis of GO and Bioflocculant
GO and bioflocculant infrared radiation (IR) spectrum was investigated. The IR spectrum of GO exhibited a carboxyl band at 1620, 1582, and 1384 cm-1 as presented in Figure 2(a). The absorption peaks at 1620 cm-1 and 1582 cm-1 are caused by C=O carbonyl expansion and C=C expansion in the GO skeleton, respectively. The absorption peaks at 1384-1 and 587 cm-1 are related to the deformation vibration of C-O-H and the bending vibration of -O, respectively , as shown in Figure 2(a). The adsorption peak at 587 cm-1 indicated the C-O-H stretching vibration  as shown in Figures 2(a) and 2(b). Further FTIR characterization of bioflocculant is shown in Figure 1(b). It is found that the peaks of GO and bioflocculant at 2920 cm-1 and 2850 cm-1 correspond to the characteristic absorption peaks of -OH and -C-H, respectively . The enhancement of absorption peaks at 3420 cm-1 and 1620 cm-1 is attributed to the O-H and N-H vibrations in C-OH and N-OH groups which form hydrogen bonds. Oxygen-containing groups above, especially the strong polar groups such as -OH, are abundant on the surface of the materials, which makes the materials in water-soluble solvents. The dispersion is good, and the polarity is enhanced, and the adsorption of copper by adsorbents is promoted. Zeta potential measurement of bioflocculant with GO inducer solution (Figure 1(c)), indicated that the solution before flocculation of copper was negatively charged in both alkaline solution and acidic solution; however, zeta potential of the solution after flocculation with copper (Figure 1(d)) was electrically neutral () and was increased by Cu(OH)2 in alkaline ().
3.3. RSM Optimization of Copper Flocculation Process
3.3.1. Analysis of the Effect of Single Factor on Flocculation Efficiency
The experimental tasks and the collected response data are shown in Table 1. As shown in Table 3, the linear terms of pH (B), flocculation time (C), dosage of bioflocculant (D), and GO inducer (E) have a significant impact on flocculation efficiency ( value < 0.05), while temperature (A) has no significant impact on flocculation efficiency. Figure 3(a) shows the highest flocculation efficiency achieved at . With the increase of pH value from 4 to 5, the flocculation efficiency increased from 85.65% to 86.01%, and with the increase of pH value to 9, the flocculation efficiency decreased to 65.66%. If the pH value is changed, the flocculation will be completely different; for example, copper ion will precipitate in alkaline condition. Figure 3(b) shows that the flocculation efficiency reaches the maximum at 1.62 h and increases from 51.21% to 80.55% as the flocculation time increases from 0.05 to 1.62 h and decreases to 60.16% as the flocculation time increases to 3 h. Figure 3(c) shows that the flocculation efficiency reaches the maximum at 13.11 mg. With the increase of bioflocculant dosage from 2.5 mg to 13.11 mg, the flocculation efficiency increased from 12.77% to 87.26%. With the increase of bioflocculant dosage to 17.5, the flocculation efficiency decreased to 76.60%. Figure 3(d) shows the highest flocculation efficiency achieved at 10.5 mg. With the increase of the GO inducer from 1.5 to 10.5, the flocculation efficiency increased from 76.59% to 90.88%. Table 3 and Figure 4 show that temperature has no significant effect on flocculation, the flocculation efficiency only increases by 8.39%, and the temperature rises from 5°C to 35°C.
aFlocculation efficiency. bFlocculation time. cFlocculant dosage. dTemperature. eGO inducer.
3.3.2. Analysis of the Effect of Two Factors on Flocculation Efficiency
Table 3 shows that temperature (A) and GO inducer (E) are important factors affecting flocculation efficiency. RSM provides a response surface and contour map to study the interaction between parameters and flocculation efficiency in Figure 5 by changing the other two variables in the experimental range and keeping the values of other variables at a medium level. As shown in Figure 3, under the fixed pH value, flocculation time, and bioflocculant dosage, the flocculation efficiency increases from 48.91% to 84.46% as the dosage increases from 5 mg/L to 15 mg/L; when the dosage of MBF-51 is 10 mg/L, the flocculation efficiency increases from 67.48% to 75.15%, and the time increases from 0.5 hours to 2.5 hours.
The large surface of GO is rich in oxygen-containing functional groups, such as hydroxyl and carboxyl, which makes it extremely hydrophilic in the water environment (Figure 4(a)), but at the same time, as a lamellar organic matter, its ionic properties are also very good, which is the main reason why we use it as coagulant aids. In the research and experiment, such characteristics play a key role in the removal of copper ions . In the process of flocculation, net catching is the main factor of flocculation mechanism, as shown in Figure 4(b), but at the same time, our experiment shows that due to the function of the GO coagulant aid, electric neutralization and compression double electric layers also play a key role in flocculation. Although we only have data results of zeta potential, it is obvious that such a conclusion is . The induction efficiency of a low dose of 12 mg/L was over 80%. As a long-chain biopolymer, MBF-51 bridges between GO particles and copper, as shown in Figure 4(b). When MBF-51 is insufficient, a bridging phenomenon will not form effectively. At the same time, even if GO plays the role of compressing the double electric layer to make copper ions adhere to its surface for a short time, because there is not enough bioflocculant, such removal effect cannot be played for a long time, so the dosage of bioflocculant is the guarantee of the removal rate. These oxygen functional groups make GO have good dispersibility in water. As shown in Figure 2, the zeta potential measurement of MBF-51 shows that MBF-51 is mainly negatively charged under alkaline and acidic conditions. It is reported that GO has different electric states at different pH values. It is a positive charge under acidic conditions (pH value lower than 4) and a negative charge under neutral and alkaline conditions (pH value higher than 4). This result just proves that the copper ion, as a cation, can fully connect with GO and bioflocculant to attach and adsorb and finally be removed ([24, 25]).
3.3.3. ANOVA Analysis of Quadratic Model
As shown in Table 4, the experimental data of flocculation efficiency were analyzed by ANOVA. All factors are consistent with the quadratic equation model fitted in the above material method, and our quadratic equation model has significant statistical significance and value, because the results show that our equation value is far less than 0.05. The results show that temperature (A) has little effect on flocculation. Its value is greater than 0.05 (data not shown in Table 3 and Table 4). At the same time, the variance analysis of the response surface quadratic model also proves that temperature is not a key factor in the flocculation process . The value less than 0.05 indicates that the model term is important, and the insignificant terms ( value > 0.05) are removed from the final expression of the model . We assume that the most ideal flocculation efficiency is 100%, and the logit equation is used to fit, and the determined upper limit of the dependent variable of flocculation rateis 100. According to the factor change of the flocculation process and the experiment of five factors without levels, the quadratic equation (2) is finally obtained. As shown in Table 4, the value of the equation is less than 0.0001 (far less than 0.05). Using the SNR parameter to evaluate the equation, it is found that the SNR is less than 4, which also has statistical value . The missing of fitting value is not significant compared with the pure error. The correlation coefficient () obtained in this study is 0.87, close to adj (0.78), indicating that the predicted value of the experiment is in good agreement with the observed value .
The results showed that Raoultella planticola produced flocculant which had never been reported before. The bioflocculant supporting graphite oxide as a bioflocculant inducer used in this study has been studied in the treatment of copper ions in surface water. Raoultella planticola was inoculated in PT-1 medium and resulted in approximately g of MBF-51 per 1 L of culture broth. The investigation of copper ions in the water of Songhua River flowing through the chemical and living areas of Jilin City shows that the copper concentration in this area is between 0.066 ppb and 0.159 ppb. Our sampling time is in the dry season, during which the pollutant concentration is the highest. We did not test it at other times. The copper content index of the three water samples did not exceed the Class III standard of the Surface Water Quality Standard. GO and bioflocculant infrared radiation (IR) spectrum were investigated. It is found that the peaks of GO and bioflocculant at 2920 cm-1 and 2850 cm-1 correspond to the characteristic absorption peaks of -OH and -C-H, respectively. The enhancement of absorption peaks at 3420 cm-1 and 1620 cm-1 is attributed to the O-H and N-H vibrations in C-OH and N-OH groups which form hydrogen bonds. Oxygen-containing groups above, especially the strong polar groups such as -OH, are abundant on the surface of the materials, which promoted the adsorption of copper. Zeta potential measurement of bioflocculant with GO inducer solution indicated that the solution before flocculation of copper was negatively charged in both alkaline solution and acidic solution. Flocculation conditions of copper ion (0.2 ppm) were optimized using response surface methodology. The results showed that the highest flocculation efficiency over 80% occurred under optimistic conditions. We determined the influencing factors and the corresponding value range through the preexperiment. At the same time, in the preexperiment, we also found that the bioflocculant aid GO also has a certain adsorption effect on copper ions. We use the adsorption here because we found the phenomenon of saturation and desorption in the experiment. The linear terms for pH (B), flocculation time (C), bioflocculant dosage (D), and GO inducer (E) had significant effects on flocculation efficiency ( value < 0.05), but temperature (A) had no significant effects on the flocculation efficiency. The highest flocculation efficiency which is 86.01% was achieved at , at 1.62 h and 13.11 mg bioflocculant with 13.11 mg GO as an inducer. The influence of temperature on flocculation was not significant, and the flocculation efficiency just increased by 8.39%, with temperature rising from 5 to 35°C; however, the temperature (A) and GO inducer (E) were significant impact factors on the flocculation efficiency. As for the mechanism of flocculation, our SEM results do not fully explain the mechanism. However, we speculate that the flocculation removal of copper ions is mainly due to the adsorption and compression of double electric layers. This research has some special significance and value compared with the previous research in our laboratory, although it seems that the research methods and article structure are similar . First of all, this article found a new strain. According to our research results, the flocculant production of this strain is very competitive, and the flocculant secretion ability of this strain is much higher than that of the strain mentioned in the previous article [14, 17]. Second, another difference is that graphene oxide is no longer regarded as a pollutant in this work but developed by us as a coagulant aid. This is also because of the use of graphene oxide itself, which has produced new and different flocculation mechanisms and effects. I think this is the greatest value of this article. At the same time, the nanosized GO plays a key role in this process, which may include both adsorption and ion balance change. But we still lack further research and data.
The data used to support the findings of this study are included within the article.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 51708248, 51708094, and 51908241) and funded by the China Scholarship Council (No.201808220182), Doctoral Fund of Jilin Institute of Chemical Technology (No. 2018001), and Program of Science and Technology of Jilin Institute of Chemical Technology (No. 2018044). I also want to thank the support of the China Scholarship Council.
- T. Lech and J. Sadlik, “Copper concentration in body tissues and fluids in normal subjects of southern Poland,” Biological Trace Element Research, vol. 118, no. 1, pp. 10–15, 2007.
- G. Arakeri, S. Patil, D. Ramesh, S. Hunasgi, and P. Brennan, “Evaluation of the possible role of copper ions in drinking water in the pathogenesis of oral submucous fibrosis: a pilot study,” British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, vol. 52, no. 1, pp. 24–28, 2014.
- Y. Li, Z. Gu, H. Liu, H. Shen, and J. Yang, “Biochemical response of the mussel Mytilus coruscus(Mytiloida:Mytilidae) exposed to in vivo sub-lethal copper concentrations,” Chinese Journal of Oceanology and Limnology, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 738–745, 2012.
- A. A. Filippov and I. L. Golovanova, “Separate and joint effects of copper and zinc on the intestine carbohydrase activity in vitro in freshwater teleosts,” Inland Water Biology, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 96–101, 2010.
- L. Song, M. G. Vijver, W. J. G. M. Peijnenburg, T. S. Galloway, and C. R. Tyler, “A comparative analysis on the in vivo toxicity of copper nanoparticles in three species of freshwater fish,” Chemosphere, vol. 139, pp. 181–189, 2015.
- A. Bhatia, S. D. Singh, and A. Kumar, “Heavy metal contamination of soil, irrigation water and vegetables in peri-urban agricultural areas and markets of Delhi,” Water Environment Research, vol. 87, no. 11, pp. 2027–2034, 2015.
- Q. Liu, C. Zhao, D. Zhao, and Y. Zhang, “Screening of Bioflocculant-Producing Strains and Study on the Production and Oily Wastewater Flocculation Characteristics,” in 2012 2nd International Conference on Remote Sensing, Environment and Transportation Engineering, Nanjing, China, 2012.
- P. Sun, C. Hui, N. Bai et al., “Revealing the characteristics of a novel bioflocculant and its flocculation performance in _Microcystis aeruginosa_ removal,” Scientific Reports, vol. 5, p. 17465, 2015.
- L. Peng, C. Yang, G. Zeng et al., “Characterization and application of bioflocculant prepared by Rhodococcus erythropolis using sludge and livestock wastewater as cheap culture media,” Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, vol. 98, no. 15, pp. 6847–6858, 2014.
- S. Zaki, M. Elkady, S. Farag, and D. Abd-El-Haleem, “Characterization and flocculation properties of a carbohydrate bioflocculant from a newly isolated Bacillus velezensis 40B,” Journal of Environmental Biology, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 51–58, 2012.
- X. Hu, Y. Yu, J. Zhou, and L. Song, “Effect of graphite precursor on oxidation degree, hydrophilicity and microstructure of graphene oxide,” Nano, vol. 9, no. 3, p. 1450037, 2014.
- X. Ji, Y. Xu, W. Zhang, L. Cui, and J. Liu, “Review of functionalization, structure and properties of graphene/polymer composite fibers,” Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, vol. 87, pp. 29–45, 2016.
- Q.-J. Wang, H.-J. Sun, T.-J. Peng, and M.-Z. Feng, “Structure development during the cation exchange processes of graphite oxide,” Acta Physico-Chimica Sinica, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 413–418, 2017.
- L. Xu, R. S. Ma, C. Y. Sun, and D. Z. Sun, “Enterococcus faecalis bioflocculant enhances recovery of graphene oxide from water,” Polish Journal of Environmental Studies, vol. 27, no. 6, pp. 2811–2820, 2018.
- Z. H. Yang, Y. Tao, G. M. Zeng, Y. Xiao, and E. J. Deng, “Culture medium and grading culture technics for bioflocculant production by Paenibacillus polymyxa GA1,” Environmental Science, vol. 27, pp. 1444–1449, 2006.
- H. Yu, B. Zhang, C. Bulin, R. Li, and R. Xing, “High-efficient synthesis of graphene oxide based on improved hummers method,” Scientific Reports, vol. 6, no. 1, 2016.
- L. Xu, M. Huo, W. Yang, D. Zhou, and H. Huo, “Klebsiella pneumoniaemetabolites enhanceMicrocystis aeruginosabiomass flocculation,” Chemistry and Ecology, vol. 32, no. 9, pp. 858–871, 2016.
- Y. Wang, K. Tang, J. Weng, and R. Wang, “Research on water quality standards of drinking water sources,” China Standardization, vol. 3, pp. 70–74, 2014.
- Y. L. Pei, Z. S. Wu, X. Y. Shi, X. N. Pan, and Y. J. Qiao, “Nir assignment of magnolol by 2d-cos technology and model application huoxiangzhengqi oral liduid,” Guang pu xue yu guang pu fen xi = Guang pu, vol. 35, no. 8, pp. 2119–2123, 2015.
- G. A. Pitsevich, A. E. Malevich, E. N. Kozlovskaya et al., “Theoretical study of the C-H/O-H stretching vibrations in malonaldehyde,” Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy, vol. 145, pp. 384–393, 2015.
- Y. Li, H. A. Ma, X. Jia et al. et al., “Electrical properties of diamond single crystals co-doped with hydrogen and boron,” CrystEngComm, vol. 16, no. 32, p. 7547, 2014.
- J. Vlček, L. Lapčík, M. Havrdová et al., “Flow induced HeLa cell detachment kinetics show that oxygen-containing functional groups in graphene oxide are potent cell adhesion enhancers,” Nanoscale, vol. 11, no. 7, pp. 3222–3228, 2019.
- Y. Li, Y. Xu, T. Zheng, and H. Wang, “Flocculation mechanism of the actinomycete Streptomyces sp. hsn06 on Chlorella vulgaris,” Bioresource Technology, vol. 239, pp. 137–143, 2017.
- O. Bajjou, A. Bakour, M. Khenfouch et al., “Charge carrier dynamics and ph effect on optical properties of anionic and cationic porphyrin–graphene oxide composites,” Journal of Electronic Materials, vol. 47, no. 5, pp. 2897–2904, 2018.
- Y. Q. He, H. B. Chen, H. Sun, X. D. Wang, and J. P. Gao, “A pH and electric responsive graphene oxide based composite hydrogel,” Advanced Materials Research, vol. 430-432, pp. 327–330, 2012.
- H. Ding, P.-M. Feng, W. Chen, and H. Lin, “Identification of bacteriophage virion proteins by the ANOVA feature selection and analysis,” Molecular BioSystems, vol. 10, no. 8, pp. 2229–2235, 2014.
- J. Dick and M. Gnewuch, “Optimal randomized changing dimension algorithms for infinite-dimensional integration on function spaces with anova-type decomposition,” Journal of Approximation Theory, vol. 184, pp. 111–145, 2014.
- A. O. J. Cramer, D. van Ravenzwaaij, D. Matzke et al., “Hidden multiplicity in exploratory multiway anova: prevalence and remedies,” Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 640–647, 2016.
- A. Cuevas, M. Febrero, and R. Fraiman, “An anova test for functional data,” Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. 111–122, 2004.
Copyright © 2020 Fancheng Zeng et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.