Journal of Thyroid Research

Journal of Thyroid Research / 2012 / Article
Special Issue

Prognostic Factors for Thyroid Carcinoma Originating from Follicular Cells

View this Special Issue

Clinical Study | Open Access

Volume 2012 |Article ID 230283 |

Yasuhiro Ito, Mitsuyoshi Hirokawa, Takuya Higashiyama, Minoru Kihara, Chisato Tomoda, Yuuki Takamura, Kaoru Kobayashi, Akihiro Miya, Akira Miyauchi, "Biological Behavior of Papillary Carcinoma of the Thyroid Including Squamous Cell Carcinoma Components and Prognosis of Patients Who Underwent Locally Curative Surgery", Journal of Thyroid Research, vol. 2012, Article ID 230283, 5 pages, 2012.

Biological Behavior of Papillary Carcinoma of the Thyroid Including Squamous Cell Carcinoma Components and Prognosis of Patients Who Underwent Locally Curative Surgery

Academic Editor: Nikola Bešič
Received21 Jun 2011
Accepted18 Jul 2011
Published18 Sep 2011


Thyroid carcinoma showing squamous differentiation throughout the entire lesion is diagnosed as squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid (SCCT) in the WHO classification. This entity is a rare disease and shows a dire prognosis; however, squamous differentiation is more frequently detected in only a portion of papillary thyroid carcinoma. In this paper, we present our experience of 10 patients (8 primary lesions and 2 with recurrence in the lymph nodes) with papillary thyroid carcinoma having an SCC component (PTC-SCC). Only 3 of 8 primary lesions (38%) and none of the 2 recurrent nodes were preoperatively diagnosed as or suspected of having SCC components. All 10 patients underwent locally curative surgery. To date, 3 patients have died of carcinoma, and 2 had distant metastasis at diagnosis or had an undifferentiated carcinoma component. The other 7 are currently alive 5 to 43 months after diagnosis. Systemic adjuvant therapy after the detection of recurrence was effective for 2 patients. It is possible that some PTC-SCC patients without distant metastasis who undergo locally curative surgery can survive for a prolonged period and adjuvant therapies can be effective for local and distant recurrences.

1. Introduction

Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid (SCCT) is known to show very aggressive characteristics and a dire prognosis. In the WHO classification [1], SCCT is defined as “squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid should be composed entirely of tumour cells with squamous differentiation.” According to this definition, SCCT is an extremely rare disease [25]. However, squamous differentiation can be more frequently observed as a SCC component in a portion of the papillary carcinoma (PTC) lesion, especially in the tall cell variant [6]. Most previous studies investigating a comparably large number of patients investigated SCCT and PTC with an SCC component (PTC-SCC) as a single group, and our knowledge regarding the biological characteristics of PTC-SCC remains poor because of its rarity. To date, we have encountered 10 patients who were diagnosed as having PTC-SCC on postoperative pathological examination. In this study, we present their clinicopathological features, therapies, and clinical outcomes to elucidate the biological behavior of this disease.

2. Patients and Methods

We reviewed the surgical and pathological records of patients who underwent surgery for thyroid carcinoma between 2006 and 2010. In this period, 5749 patients underwent surgery for primary or recurred PTC. Of these, 10 patients (0.2%) were diagnosed as PTC-SCC and were enrolled in this study. In this period, no patients were diagnosed as SCCT. These diagnoses were rereviewed by a thyroid pathologist (M.H.) based on the WHO classification [1]. PTC-SCC was diagnosed in 8 primary lesions obtained at initial surgery and 2 recurrent lymph nodes obtained at second surgery. Patients who had SCC sites other than the thyroid were excluded from the series. Patients who were diagnosed as having PTC with squamous cell metaplasia (squamous lesions appear benign) or squamoid subtype in undifferentiated carcinoma (UC) were excluded from the study. In this period, 3 patients were suspected as having PTC-SCC (1 primary lesion and 2 recurring lesions) but underwent biopsy only. One patient died of carcinoma one month after detection, and two patients were referred to other hospitals, and their prognoses are unknown. These patients were also excluded from the study. In our department, all patients with PTC undergo thyroid ultrasonography, and neck CT scan is also performed for those who have clinical lymph node metastasis and whose primary lesions are suspected of having extension to adjacent organs. All patients in our series also underwent ultrasonography. Neck CT scan (plain and enhanced) was performed for 9 patients. Furthermore, all patients underwent chest CT scan to screen for lung metastasis and 3 patients who were cytologically suspected of having SCC or UC also underwent abdominal CT scan also. None of these patients underwent PET-CT preoperatively, although two underwent PET-CT after surgery. All patients underwent ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) for diagnosis. Furthermore, 3 patients who were suspected of SCC or UC on cytology underwent also ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy (CNB) to confirm the diagnosis. None of these patients showed any complications of CNB, such as hemorrhage, hematoma, and recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis. On pathological examination, UC lesion was also detected in 2 patients (one primary lesion and one recurrent lymph node). One patient also had primary lung carcinoma, which was detected on CT scan before thyroid surgery. After thyroid surgery, this patient was referred to another hospital and underwent surgery and chemotherapy for lung carcinoma. The histology of lung carcinoma was adenocarcinoma.

3. Results

We analyzed the backgrounds and preoperative findings on imaging studies of 10 PTC-SCC (Table 1). Patients consisted of 7 females and 3 males, and patient ages ranged from 68 to 83 years. Of 8 patients who underwent initial surgery, only 3 (38%) (patient nos. 1, 4, and 8) were preoperatively diagnosed as or suspected of having an SCC component on FNAB or CNB. Tumors of these 3 patients were suspected to significantly extend to adjacent organs. Therefore, these patients underwent chemotherapy using paclitaxel [7] before surgery, considering the possibility of UC with Stage IVB [8], to promote tumor shrinkage and make locally curative surgery easier. There was no evidence of carcinoma progression during preoperative chemotherapy, although no patients were judged as complete response (manuscript in preparation). The remaining 5 primary lesions were diagnosed as PTC on cytology. Tumor size ranged from 3.5 to 5.6 cm, and 7 of these patients also had lymph node metastasis detected on preoperative imaging studies. Three patients (patient nos. 6, 7, and 8) also underwent FNAB for metastatic nodes and were diagnosed as or suspected of having PTC. Two patients (patients nos. 2 and 3) had previously undergone initial surgery for PTC, and recurrence was detected in the lymph nodes, which measured 0.9 cm and 3.9 cm, respectively. The cytological results of these nodes were PTC and UC, respectively. Two patients (patient nos. 1 and 3) had lung metastasis at surgery, and one (patient no. 10) had primary lung carcinoma that was treated after surgery for thyroid carcinoma at another hospital, as indicated above.

Patient no.GenderAgeInitial surgery?Rapid growth *Preoperative diagnosis (primary) *Preoperative diagnosis (LN meta)Tumor size (cm)LN meta size (cm)Distant metastasis at surgery

4Female67YesNoUC or SCCx4.9xNo
5Female83YesNoPTC or PDCx5.21.7No
8Female68YesNoPTC or SCCPTC?4.42.7No
1 0 Female71YesNoPTCx4.7 2.7No

PTC: papillary thyroid carcinoma, UC: undifferentiated carcinoma; PDC: poorly differentiated carcinoma, SCC: squamous cell carcinoma.
*Based on FNAB or CNB.
A l s o had lung carcinoma.

Table 2 summarizes the intraoperative and postoperative findings and clinical courses of these 10 patients. All 8 primary lesions showed significant extrathyroid extension corresponding to T4a in the UICC TNM classification [8], but all these patients could undergo locally curative surgery. Of 8 patients, 2 (patient nos. 4 and 5) were SCC dominant, and the remaining 6 (patient nos. 1, 6–10) were PTC dominant on pathological examination for primary lesions. PTC lesion was dominant in 2 patients who underwent surgery for lymph node recurrence (patient nos. 2 and 3). The range of the portion of SCC component was less than 10% in 2 patients (patient nos. 2 and 6), 10–20% in 5 patients (patient nos. 1, 7–10), and 40% or more in 3 patients (patient nos. 3–5). The PTC lesions of 4 patients (50%) were tall cell variant. Two patients (patient nos. 3 and 4) also demonstrated UC lesion.

Patient no.Surgical designsResectionExtrathyroid extensionPathology (primary)Pathology (LN meta)Adjuvant therapiesCarcinoma recurrenceOutcome after diagnosis

1TT + MNDR0?Yes **PTC > SCC (10%)PTC *chemoBone18 m DOC
2CT + MNDR0xxPTC > SCC (<10%)x x43 m ANEC
3MNDR0xxPTC > SCC (40%) > UCChemo x33 m AWC
4TT + CNDR0YesSCC (40%) > UC > PTCPTC *chemo L a r y n , Bone23 m DOC
5TT + MND R0YesSCC (80%) > PTC (tall)PTCChemo + EBRTSkin, local18 m ANEC
6TT + MNDR0?YesPTC > SCC (<10%)PTCx x14 m ANEC
7TT + MND R0YesPTC (tall) > SCC (40%)PTCEBRT x13 m ANEC
8LI + MNDR0YesPTC (tall) > SCC (10%)PTC *chemo + EBRT x9 m ANEC
9TT + MNDR0YesPTC (tall) > SCC (20%)PTCImmunotherapyLung9 m DOC
10TT + MMD R1YesPTC > SCC (20%)PTCChemo for lung carcinomax5 m ANEC

*Preoperative chemotherapy was also performed. R e c u r r e n c e of UC. **A > B indicates A occupied a larger portion than B.
TT: total thyroidectomy, CT: completion total thyroidectomy, LI: lobectomy with is thymectomy, CND: central node dissection, MND: modified radical neck dissection, EBRT; external beam radiotherapy.
DOC; Died of carcinoma.
ANEC: Alive with no evidence of Carcinoma.
AWC: Alive with carcinoma.

None of these 10 patients underwent radioactive iodine (RAI) therapy after surgery. The 3 patients who underwent preoperative chemotherapy continued to receive it after surgery. Chemotherapy was initiated after surgery for patient nos. 3 and 5. Patient no. 3 underwent chemotherapy immediately after initial surgery because of lung metastasis and involvement of a UC component and patient no. 5 underwent chemotherapy after the detection of local recurrence. Patient no. 9 showed recurrence in the lung 3 months after surgery and underwent immunotherapy using dendritic cells pulsed with WT1 peptide at the patient’s request [9]. Three patients (patients nos. 5, 7, and 8) underwent external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) of the whole neck at 50–60 Gy immediately after surgery. However, 2 local recurrences were detected during EBRT in patient no. 5. One was located in front of the common carotid artery and was diagnosed as SCC on CNB, and another was found in the skin, for which neither FNAB nor CNB was performed. The former disappeared by postoperative chemotherapy, and the latter was resected by second surgery. The histology of the second surgical specimen was SCC.

During followup, patient no. 1, who had lung metastasis at surgery, developed recurrence in the bone and died of carcinoma 18 months after diagnosis because of the enlargement of lung metastasis. Patient no. 3 is currently alive despite the development of lung metastasis that had been present before surgery. Patient no. 4, who had a UC component, developed recurrence in the larynx and underwent a second surgery at another hospital. The recurrent tumor was pathologically diagnosed as UC, and this patient died of UC progression 23 months after diagnosis. In patient no. 5, there has been no further evidence of carcinoma recurrence to date after chemotherapy and second surgery. Lung metastasis was stable in patient no. 9 for 6 months after the initiation of immunotherapy, but he died of sudden respiratory tract hemorrhage 9 months after surgery. The remaining 5 (patients nos. 2, 6–8, 10) are currently alive with no evidence of carcinoma recurrence, although patient no. 10 is currently undergoing chemotherapy for lung carcinoma.

4. Discussion

In this study, we demonstrated that it is difficult to diagnose PTC-SCC on preoperative FNAB or CNB. Only 3 of 8 patients (38%) having primary lesions were preoperatively diagnosed as or suspected of having SCC components. This is partially because of the difficulty in differential diagnosis between SCC and UC on cytology. Furthermore, SCC cells may not be aspirated or biopsied if the needle does not appropriately hit SCC components. In our series, all patients were older, 7 patients had carcinoma larger than 4 cm, clinical node metastasis was detected in 7 patients, all had significant extrathyroid extension, and the PTC lesions of 4 patients were diagnosed as tall cell variant. These clinicopathological features were recognized as predicting poor prognosis, indicating that squamous differentiation occurs in PTC with biologically aggressive behavior [1013].

Previous studies investigated SCCT and PTC-SCC as a single group and demonstrated that most of these patients showed a poor prognosis. Booya et al. showed that the median survival period was only 8.6 months for 10 patients [2]. According to a review by Syed et al. in 2010 [14], median survival periods in reports published between 1985 and 2009 ranged from 3 to 24 months but mostly 12 months or even shorter. Furthermore, Cook et al. demonstrated that all patients with SCCT or PTC-SCC who underwent incomplete resection or biopsy died within a short period despite adjuvant therapies [3], which was similar to the results of UC, as we previously demonstrated [15].

In this study, we investigated 10 patients with PTC-SCC who underwent locally curative resection, indicating that they were potential long-term survivors. In our series, 7 patients have survived for 8 months to 43 months to date. Two patients (patients nos. 2 and 6) with only focal SCC lesions who did not show distant metastasis at diagnosis have survived without any further recurrence for 14 and 43 months after diagnosis, respectively, although they underwent no adjuvant therapies. The remaining 5 with larger lesions of SCC components, who underwent either or both chemotherapy and EBRT, have also survived with or without recurrence. Of the 3 patients who died of carcinoma, 2 had distant metastasis at diagnosis or had a UC component. These findings suggest that long-term survival can be expected for some PTC-SCC patients if they undergo locally curative surgery and do not have distant metastasis at diagnosis or a UC component.

Previous studies demonstrated controversial results of adjuvant chemotherapy [1618]. In our series, 3 patients who were cytologically diagnosed as or suspected of having SCC underwent preoperative adjuvant chemotherapy. These tumors were large and were suspected of extending to adjacent organs. In order to make locally curative surgery easier, we performed preoperative chemotherapy based on the protocol for UC [7]. If a tumor is small without the suspicion of extrathyroid extension and locally curative surgery is expected to be easy, immediate surgery may be preferred to avoid losing time. Postoperative chemotherapy should be performed for patients having distant metastasis at surgery or those who have undergone only palliative surgery. It remains unclear whether chemotherapy immediately after locally curative surgery for patients without distant metastasis is effective to prolong the survival of PTC-SCC patients, because we did not perform a comparative study. However, it may be an alternative in order to control minute carcinoma lesions that remained unresected in local lesions and micrometastases in distant organs. Another strategy is to initiate chemotherapy when recurrence is clinically detected. Since one of the local recurrences disappeared in patient no. 5, this may also promise a certain level of effect.

EBRT is another adjuvant therapy for local control. However, previous studies of SCCT and PTC-SCC showed controversial findings of its effectiveness [2, 3, 18, 19]. In our series, 3 patients underwent EBRT immediately after surgery. Two patients showed no evidence of local recurrence, but in 1 patient, local recurrences became apparent during EBRT. Therefore, we cannot conclude that EBRT has a significant effect on the local control of PTC-SCC. However, it may be better to perform postoperative EBRT, especially for cases with significant extension to adjacent organs, because multimodality therapy should be considered for aggressive diseases such as PTC-SCC.

In summary, we have presented our experience of treating 10 patients with PTC-SCC, which is difficult to diagnose preoperatively. Long-term survival can be expected for PTC-SCC patients if locally curative resection can be performed and distant metastasis at surgery is not detected. Adjuvant chemotherapy and EBRT may contribute to the control of carcinoma recurrence, but further studies of a large number of patients are necessary to establish therapeutic protocols for PTC-SCC patients.


  1. K. Y. Lam and A. Sakamoto, “Squamous cell carcinoma,” in Pathology and Genetics of Tumours of Endocrine Organs, R. A. Delellis, R. V. Lloyd, P. U. Heitz et al., Eds., p. 81, International Agency for Research on Cancer, Lyon, France, 2004. View at: Google Scholar
  2. F. Booya, T. J. Sebo, J. L. Kasperbauer, and V. Fatourechi, “Primary squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid: report of ten cases,” Thyroid, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 89–93, 2006. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  3. A. M. Cook, L. Vini, and C. Harmer, “Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid: outcome of treatment in 16 patients,” European Journal of Surgical Oncology, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 606–609, 1999. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  4. W. J. Simpson and J. Carruthers, “Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid gland,” The American Journal of Surgery, vol. 156, no. 1, pp. 44–46, 1988. View at: Google Scholar
  5. A. K. Sarda, S. Bal, Arunabh, M. K. Singh, and M. M. Kapur, “Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid,” Journal of Surgical Oncology, vol. 39, no. 3, pp. 175–178, 1988. View at: Google Scholar
  6. C. G. Kleer, T. J. Giordano, and M. J. Merino, “Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid: an aggressive tumor associated with tall cell variant of papillary thyroid carcinoma,” Modern Pathology, vol. 13, no. 7, pp. 742–746, 2000. View at: Google Scholar
  7. T. Higashiyama, Y. Ito, M. Hirokawa et al., “Induction chemotherapy with weekly paclitaxel administration for anaplastic thyroid carcinoma,” Thyroid, vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 4–14, 2010. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  8. L. H. Sobin and C. H. Wittekindeds, UICC; TNM Classification of Malignant Tumors, Wiley-Liss, New York, NY, USA, 6th edition, 2002.
  9. M. Okamoto, S. Furuichi, Y. Nishioka et al., “Expression of toll-like receptor 4 on dendritic cells is significant for anticancer effect of dendritic cell-based immunotherapy in combination with an active component of OK-432, a streptococcal preparation,” Cancer Research, vol. 64, no. 15, pp. 5461–5470, 2004. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  10. Y. Ito, C. Tomoda, T. Uruno et al., “Ultrasonographically and anatomopathologically detectable node metastases in the lateral compartment as indicators of worse relapse-free survival in patients with papillary thyroid carcinoma,” World Journal of Surgery, vol. 29, no. 7, pp. 917–920, 2005. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  11. Y. Ito, C. Tomoda, T. Uruno et al., “Prognostic significance of extrathyroid extension of papillary thyroid carcinoma: massive but not minimal extension affects the relapse-free survival,” World Journal of Surgery, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 780–786, 2006. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  12. Y. Ito, M. Hirokawa, M. Fukushima et al., “Prevalence and prognostic significance of poor differentiation and tall cell variant in papillary carcinoma in Japan,” World Journal of Surgery, vol. 32, no. 7, pp. 1535–1543, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  13. Y. Ito and A. Miyauchi, “Prognostic factors and therapeutic strategies for differentiated carcinomas of the thyroid,” Endocrine Journal, vol. 56, no. 2, pp. 177–192, 2009. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  14. M. I. Syed, M. Stewart, S. Syed et al., “Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid gland: primary or secondary disease?” The Journal of Laryngology and Otology, vol. 125, no. 1, pp. 3–9, 2010. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  15. Y. Ito, T. Higashiyama, M. Hirokawa et al., “Investigation of the validity of UICC stage grouping of anaplastic carcinoma of the thyroid,” Asian Journal of Surgery, vol. 32, no. 1, pp. 47–50, 2009. View at: Google Scholar
  16. K. Shimaoka and Y. Tsukada, “Squamous cell carcinomas and adenosquamous carcinomas originating from the thyroid gland,” Cancer, vol. 46, no. 8, pp. 1833–1842, 1980. View at: Google Scholar
  17. T. Harada, K. Shimaoka, K. Yakumaru, and K. Ito, “Squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid gland—transition from adenocarcinoma,” Journal of Surgical Oncology, vol. 19, no. 1, pp. 36–43, 1982. View at: Google Scholar
  18. T. Y. Huang and D. Assor, “Primary squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid gland: a report of four cases,” American Journal of Clinical Pathology, vol. 55, no. 1, pp. 93–98, 1971. View at: Google Scholar
  19. X. H. Zhou, “Primary squamous cell carcinoma of the thyroid,” European Journal of Surgical Oncology, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 42–45, 2002. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar

Copyright © 2012 Yasuhiro Ito et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Related articles

No related content is available yet for this article.
 PDF Download Citation Citation
 Download other formatsMore
 Order printed copiesOrder

Related articles

No related content is available yet for this article.

Article of the Year Award: Outstanding research contributions of 2021, as selected by our Chief Editors. Read the winning articles.