Research Article

In Vitro Endothelial Cell Proliferation Assay Reveals Distinct Levels of Proangiogenic Cytokines Characterizing Sera of Healthy Subjects and of Patients with Heart Failure

Table 2

Circulating levels of cytokines/chemokines in sera from HF patients stratified based on the endothelial cell proliferation index (“high CI” versus “low CI”).

Cytokines/chemokinesHF patients
“High CI”“Low CI”

EGF126.5 ( )104 ( )n.s
EOTAXIN141.5 ( )117 ( )n.s
G-CSF25.4 ( )23.1 ( )n.s
GM-CSF5.5 ( )3.7 ( )n.s
IFN- 26.7 ( )2.6 ( )n.s
IFN- 3.3 ( )1.5 ( )<0.05
IL-100.4 ( )0.2 ( )n.s
IL-12p40<OOR<OOR/
IL-12p702.1 ( )0.2 ( )n.s
IL-13<OOR<OOR/
IL-151.5 ( )0.3 ( )n.s
IL-17 <OOR<OOR/
IL1ra11.3 ( )6.5 ( )n.s
IL-1 1 ( )1.5 ( )n.s
IL-1 <OOR<OOR/
IL-2<OOR<OOR/
IL-3<OOR<OOR/
IL-4<OOR<OOR/
IL-5<OOR<OOR/
IL-65.7 ( )1.6 ( )n.s
IL-74.7 ( )2.9 ( )<0.05
IL-834.1 ( )16.3 ( )<0.06
IP-10293 ( )342 ( )n.s
MCP-1663.5 ( )471 ( )n.s
MIP-1 4.5 ( )3.8 ( )<0.06
MIP-1β37.3 ( )36.5 ( )n.s
TNF-α10.9 ( )8.7 ( )n.s
TNF-β<OOR<OOR/
VEGF290 ( )85.6 ( )<0.05

CI: cell index. Values are expressed as pg/mL and reported as median (mean ± SD). OOR<: out of (below) detection range; n.s: nonstatistically significant; : statistically significant; : close to statistically significant.