Research Article

Providing Databases for Different Indoor Positioning Technologies: Pros and Cons of Magnetic Field and Wi-Fi Based Positioning

Table 11

Pros and cons for magnetic field and Wi-Fi fingerprinting positioning.

ProsCons

Magnetic fieldBeing fully infrastructure-lessVector only contains 3 values
Good accuracy Requires user movement
Continuous mappingHigh dependence on user’s velocity
Continuous positioningHigh dependence on user’s orientation
Fast mapping procedure Large reference database
Refreshment frequency @ 10 Hz

Wi-Fi fingerprintingBeing partially infrastructure-lessAffected by people presence
Good accuracyAffected by user movement
Average of 17 WAPs per FP5 GHz band not being in all devices
“Small” reference databaseRefreshment frequency @ 0.2 to 0.3 Hz
Discrete databaseRequired feature selection
Allows precise spatiotemporal analysisPresence of mobile hotspots
1-NN valid and fast solution