Research Article
A Hybrid Dynamic Probability Mutation Particle Swarm Optimization for Engineering Structure Design
Table 6
The running time of the eight algorithms on different test functions.
| ā | CWDEPSO | MPSPSO-ST (s) | JADE (s) | PSO (s) | DE | AIWCPSO | SinDE | DEPSO |
| | 1.0653s | 0.7287 | 0.9723 | 0.1651 | 0.3861s | 0.1721s | 0.3552s | 11.5504s | | 1.0995s | 0.9503 | 1.0811 | 0.1796 | 0.4291s | 0.2171s | 0.4515s | 21.9234s | | 1.3302s | 1.3954 | 1.3192 | 0.2940 | 0.6151s | 0.2938s | 0.6389s | 14.7475s | | 1.2175s | 1.0766 | 1.1902 | 0.2430 | 0.5144s | 0.2323s | 0.5097s | 22.8226s | | 1.1963s | 1.1725 | 1.1746 | 0.2579 | 0.5292s | 0.2528s | 0.5412s | 32.0585s | | 1.1079s | 0.9551 | 1.1744 | 0.2043 | 0.4396s | 0.2085s | 0.4317s | 23.2556s | | 1.0881s | 0.8567 | 1.1179 | 0.2091 | 0.4183s | 0.1911s | 0.4090s | 21.2581s | | 1.4138s | 1.1077 | 1.3764 | 0.2626 | 0.5914s | 0.2577s | 0.5376s | 28.5731s | | 1.2172s | 1.0532 | 1.2247 | 0.2400 | 0.4730s | 0.2285s | 0.4757s | 20.5048s | | 1.3385s | 1.5277 | 1.4469 | 0.3153 | 0.6731s | 0.3209s | 0.6608s | 41.6464s | | 1.1542s | 0.9217 | 1.1914 | 0.2010 | 0.4477s | 0.2228s | 0.4591s | 22.5763s | | 1.2787s | 1.1229 | 1.2366 | 0.2419 | 0.5173s | 0.2373s | 0.5246s | 28.8664s | | 1.2617s | 1.3655 | 1.3003 | 0.2950 | 0.6161s | 0.2943s | 0.6128s | 32.3458s | | 33.2016s | 80.7301 | 34.8477 | 16.0725 | 33.4909s | 16.0757s | 33.8106s | 826.263s | | 39.6449s | 96.0686 | 40.4186 | 18.7720 | 38.1136s | 18.8152s | 36.9709s | 989.603s | | 3.6889s | 4.2173 | 3.9664 | 0.7780 | 1.6266s | 0.8859s | 1.5547s | 74.861s | | 4.7480s | 6.9420 | 6.2873 | 1.4950 | 2.5856s | 1.4324s | 3.2057s | 209.717 | | 5.0012s | 6.7874 | 5.4142 | 1.4410 | 2.8880s | 1.4071s | 2.9385s | 92.6985s | | 5.6041s | 2.6887 | 6.1948 | 1.6221 | 3.3629s | 1.5848s | 3.3518s | 126.543s | | 8.2152s | 11.0186 | 8.0453 | 2.1772 | 4.5801s | 2.2404s | 4.2489s | 227.856s | | 3.5906s | 2.7018 | 3.6265 | 0.6090 | 1.3123s | 0.5891s | 1.2948s | 62.803s | | 3.1939s | 1.8792 | 3.4971 | 0.2735 | 0.9010 | 0.3507 | 0.9208 | 51.538s | | 0.9269s | 0.6128 | 0.9996 | 0.1083 | 0.3092s | 0.1103s | 0.3138s | 4.9359s | | 1.4982s | 1.9853 | 1.4977 | 0.3796 | 0.8699s | 0.3763s | 0.8538s | 17.9298s |
|
|