Research Article

Optimal Inventory Policy Involving Ordering Cost Reduction, Back-Order Discounts, and Variable Lead Time Demand by Minimax Criterion

Table 2

Summary of the optimal solution procedure ( E A C in weeks and η = 0.7, δ = 0).

E A C 𝑛 ( 𝑄 𝑛 , 𝐴 𝑛 , 𝜋 𝑥 𝑛 , 𝐿 𝑛 ) E A C 𝑛 E A C 𝑛 / E A C 𝑛 𝑝 = 0 . 0 EVAI 𝑝 = 0 . 2

0(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
0.5(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
1(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
10(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
20(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
40(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
80(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
100(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133

0(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
0.5(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
1(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
10(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
20(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
40(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
80(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
100(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220
(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220

p = 0.4
0(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
0.5(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
1(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
10(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
20(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
40(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
80(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
100(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237
(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237

p = 0.6
0(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
0.5(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
1(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
10(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154., 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
20(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
40(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
80(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
100(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212
(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212

p = 0.8
0(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
0.5(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
1(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
10(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
20(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
40(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
80(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
100(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171
p = 1.0
0(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
0.5(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
1(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
10(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
20(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
40(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
80(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
100(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133
(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133

p = 0.0
0(145,140, 77.420, 3)3731.3883430.876(151,146, 77.521, 3)3428.8302.0461.00060
0.5(145,141, 77.424, 3)3765.7603475.731(154,149, 77.562, 3)3471.9103.8211.00110
1(146,141, 77.431, 3)3781.2843494.414(155,150, 77.580, 3)3490.0194.3951.00126
10(148,143, 77.460, 3)3816.6673532.005(157,152, 77.615, 3)3527.2634.7411.00134
20(148,143, 77.464, 3)3820.2273535.434(157,152, 77.619, 3)3530.7094.7251.00134
40(148,143, 77.466, 3)3822.1253537.240(157,152, 77.620, 3)3532.5244.7161.00134
80(148,143, 77.467, 3)3823.1053538.166(157,152, 77.621, 3)3533.4564.7101.00133
100(148,143, 77.467, 3)3823.3033538.354(157,152, 77.621, 3)3533.6444.7101.00133
(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133

p = 0.2
0(145,140, 77.415, 3)3739.2223477.626(154,148, 77.559, 3)3473.4904.1361.00119
0.5(145,140, 77.421, 3)3773.2823526.203(156,151, 77.603, 3)3519.5576.6461.00189
1(146,141, 77.428, 3)3788.7243545.816(157,152, 77.621, 3)3538.3477.4691.00211
10(147,142, 77.457, 3)3824.0423583.914(159,154, 77.656, 3)3575.9737.9401.00222
20(148,143, 77.460, 3)3827.6063587.301(160,154, 77.660, 3)3579.3867.9141.00221
40(148,143, 77.462, 3)3829.5053589.078(160,154, 77.661, 3)3581.1807.8981.00221
80(148,143, 77.463, 3)3830.4873589.989(160,154, 77.662, 3)3582.1007.8891.00220
100(148,143, 77.463, 3)3830.6863590.173(160,154, 77.662, 3)3582.2867.8871.00220
(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220

p = 0.4
0(145,140, 77.414, 3)3741.9233488.279(154,149, 77.565, 3)3483.6824.5971.00132
0.5(145,140, 77.419, 3)3775.9153537.551(157,151, 77.609, 3)3530.2457.3061.00207
1(146,141, 77.427, 3)3791.3383557.216(158,152, 77.627, 3)3549.1448.0721.00227
10(147,142, 77.454, 3)3826.6413595.519(160,154, 77.663, 3)3586.8288.6911.00242
20(148,143, 77.459, 3)3830.2053598.779(160,155, 77.666, 3)3590.2378.5421.00238
40(148,143, 77.461, 3)3832.1053600.552(160,155, 77.668, 3)3592.0278.5251.00237
80(148,143, 77.462, 3)3833.0873601.460(160,155, 77.669, 3)3592.9458.5151.00237
100(148,143, 77.462, 3)3833.2863601.643(160,155, 77.669, 3)3593.1308.5131.00237
(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237

p = 0.6
0(145,140, 77.415, 3)3740.9863477.898(153,148, 77.555, 3)3473.9823.9161.00113
0.5(145,140, 77.421, 3)3775.0373526.154(156,151, 77.599, 3)3519.7696.3851.00181
1(146,141, 77.427, 3)3790.4763545.698(157,152, 77.617, 3)3538.4977.2001.00203
10(147,142, 77.456, 3)3825.7923583.761(159,154, 77.653, 3)3576.0907.6711.00215
20(148,143, 77.460, 3)3829.3563587.152(159,154, 77.656, 3)3579.5067.6461.00214
40(148,143, 77.461, 3)3831.2563588.932(159,154, 77.658, 3)3581.3027.6301.00213
80(148,143, 77.462, 3)3832.2373589.844(160,154, 77.658, 3)3582.2227.6221.00213
100(148,143, 77.463, 3)3832.4363590.028(160,154, 77.659, 3)3582.4097.6201.00213
(148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2413590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6121.00212
p = 0.8
0(145,140, 77.417, 3)3737.2853456.812(152,147, 77.539, 3)3453.8492.9631.00086
0.5(145,140, 77.422, 3)3771.4723503.469(155,150, 77.582, 3)3498.3465.1231.00146
1(146,141, 77.430, 3)3786.9483522.514(156,151, 77.599, 3)3516.7835.7311.00163
10(147,143, 77.458, 3)3822.2913560.458(158,153, 77.635, 3)3554.2166.2431.00176
20(148,143, 77.461, 3)3825.8543563.868(158,153, 77.638, 3)3557.6466.2221.00175
40(148,143, 77.463, 3)3827.7533565.660(158,153, 77.640, 3)3559.4516.2091.00174
80(148,143, 77.464, 3)3828.7343566.579(158,153, 77.641, 3)3560.3776.2021.00174
100(148,143, 77.465, 3)3828.9333566.666(158,153, 77.641, 3)3560.5646.1021.00171
(148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171

p = 1.0
0(145,140, 77.420, 3)3731.3883430.876(151,146, 77.521, 3)3428.8312.0461.00060
0.5(145,141, 77.424, 3)3765.7603475.731(154,149, 77.562, 3)3471.9103.8211.00110
1(146,141, 77.431, 3)3781.2843494.414(155,150, 77.580, 3)3490.0204.3941.00126
10(148,143, 77.460, 3)3816.6673532.005(157,152, 77.615, 3)3527.2644.7411.00134
20(148,143, 77.464, 3)3820.2273535.435(157,152, 77.619, 3)3530.7094.7261.00134
40(148,143, 77.466, 3)3822.1253537.240(157,152, 77.620, 3)3532.5244.7161.00134
80(148,143, 77.467, 3)3823.1053538.167(157,152, 77.621, 3)3533.4564.7111.00133
100(148,143, 77.467, 3)3823.3033538.354(157,152, 77.621, 3)3533.6454.7091.00133
(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133

p = 0.0
0(142,137, 77.367, 3)3630.3183319.556(142,137, 77.364, 4)3306.32913.2271.00400
0.5(143,138, 77.379, 3)3705.6593411.048(150,145, 77.501, 3)3408.0193.0291.00089
1(144,139, 77.394, 3)3737.6913449.035(152,147, 77.536, 3)3444.9404.0951.00119
10(147,142, 77.452, 3)3809.2043524.967(157,151, 77.608, 3)3520.1044.8621.00138
20(148,143, 77.460, 3)3816.3423531.755(157,152, 77.615, 3)3527.0094.7461.00135
40(148,143, 77.464, 3)3820.1413535.369(157,152, 77.618, 3)3530.6424.7271.00134
80(148,143, 77.466, 3)3822.1033537.223(157,152, 77.620, 3)3532.5074.7161.00134
100(148,143, 77.466, 3)3822.5003537.598(157,152, 77.621, 3)3532.8844.7141.00133
(148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.109(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133

p = 0.2
0(142,137, 77.362, 3)3638.7033361.079(144,139, 77.405, 4)3354.2456.8341.00204
0.5(142,138, 77.374, 3)3713.3243460.282(152,147, 77.541, 3)3454.6685.6131.00162
1(143,139, 77.391, 3)3745.1873500.043(155,149, 77.577, 3)3492.9717.0721.00202
10(147,142, 77.448, 3)3816.5713577.010(159,154, 77.650, 3)3568.8948.1161.00227
20(147,142, 77.455, 3)3823.7153583.795(159,154, 77.656, 3)3575.7338.0621.00225
40(148,143, 77.460, 3)3827.5193587.240(160,154, 77.660, 3)3579.3247.9161.00221
80(148,143, 77.462, 3)3829.4833589.063(160,154, 77.661, 3)3581.1647.8981.00221
100(148,143, 77.462, 3)3829.8813589.431(160,154, 77.662, 3)3581.5367.8951.00220
(148,143, 77.464, 3)3831.4903590.915(160,154, 77.663, 3)3583.0357.8801.00220

p = 0.4
0(142,137, 77.362, 3)3641.5203370.810(145,140, 77.411, 4)3365.7245.0851.00151
0.5(142,138, 77.374, 3)3715.9883471.297(153,148, 77.547, 3)3465.2006.0971.00176
1(143,139, 77.390, 3)3747.8133511.377(155,150, 77.584, 3)3503.7247.6531.00218
10(147,142, 77.447, 3)3819.1673588.520(159,154, 77.657, 3)3579.7628.7581.00245
20(147,142, 77.454, 3)3826.3133595.290(160,154, 77.663, 3)3586.5918.6991.00243
40(148,143, 77.459, 3)3830.1183598.719(160,155, 77.666, 3)3590.1748.5451.00238
80(148,143, 77.461, 3)3832.0833600.536(160,155, 77.668, 3)3592.0118.5261.00237
100(148,143, 77.461, 3)3832.4813600.903(160,155, 77.668, 3)3592.3828.5221.00237
(148,143, 77.463, 3)3834.0913602.383(160,155, 77.670, 3)3593.8788.5051.00237

p = 0.6
0(142,137, 77.362, 3)3640.4733361.860(144,139, 77.401, 4)3355.7856.0751.00181
0.5(142,138, 77.375, 3)3715.0833460.331(152,147, 77.537, 3)3454.9705.3611.00155
1(143,139, 77.390, 3)3746.9403499.948(154,149, 77.574, 3)3493.1476.8021.00195
10(147,142, 77.447, 3)3818.3203576.848(159,153, 77.646, 3)3569.0037.8451.00220
20(147,142, 77.454, 3)3825.4653583.641(159,154, 77.652, 3)3575.8487.7921.00218
40(148,143, 77.459, 3)3829.2693587.091(159,154, 77.656, 3)3579.4437.6481.00214
80(148,143, 77.461, 3)3831.2333588.916(159,154, 77.658, 3)3581.2857.6311.00213
100(148,143, 77.462, 3)3831.6313589.285(159,154, 77.658, 3)3581.6587.6271.00213
( 𝑄 𝑛 , 𝐴 𝑛 , 𝜋 𝑥 𝑛 , 𝐿 𝑛 ) (148,143, 77.463, 3)3833.2403590.772(160,154, 77.659, 3)3583.1597.6131.00212

p = 0.8
0(142,137, 77.364, 3)3636.5343343.016(143,138, 77.384, 4)3334.1118.9051.00267
0.5(143,138, 77.377, 3)3711.4563438.123(151,146, 77.520, 3)3433.9704.1531.00121
1(143,139, 77.391, 3)3743.3883477.029(153,148, 77.556, 3)3471.5575.4721.00158
10(147,142, 77.449, 3)3814.8243553.487(158,152, 77.628, 3)3547.0956.3921.00180
20(147,143, 77.457, 3)3821.9653560.217(158,153, 77.635, 3)3553.9686.2491.00176
40(148,143, 77.461, 3)3825.7673563.804(158,153, 77.638, 3)3557.5816.2231.00175
80(148,143, 77.463, 3)3827.7313565.644(158,153, 77.640, 3)3559.4346.2091.00174
100(148,143, 77.463, 3)3828.1283566.015(158,153, 77.640, 3)3559.8086.2071.00174
𝐹 (148,143, 77.466, 3)3829.7373567.416(159,153, 77.642, 3)3561.3196.0961.00171

p = 1.0
0(142,137, 77.367, 3)3630.3183319.556(142,137, 77.364, 4)3306.32913.2271.00400
0.5(143,138, 77.379, 3)3705.6593411.049(150,145, 77.501, 3)3408.0193.0291.00089
1(144,139, 77.394, 3)3737.6913449.036(152,147, 77.536, 3)3444.9404.0951.00119
10(147,142, 77.452, 3)3809.2043524.967(157,151, 77.608, 3)3520.1054.8621.00138
20(148,143, 77.460, 3)3816.3423531.755(157,152, 77.615, 3)3527.0094.7461.00135
40(148,143, 77.464, 3)3820.1413535.369(157,152, 77.618, 3)3530.6424.7271.00134
80(148,143, 77.466, 3)3822.1023537.223(157,152, 77.620, 3)3532.5074.7161.00134
100(148,143, 77.466, 3)3822.5003537.598(157,152, 77.621, 3)3532.8844.7141.00133
E A C 𝑛 ( 𝑄 𝑛 , 𝐴 𝑛 , 𝜋 𝑥 𝑛 , 𝐿 𝑛 ) (148,143, 77.468, 3)3824.1073539.110(157,152, 77.622, 3)3534.4054.7051.00133

Note: we obtain the optimal ( 𝑄 , 𝐴 , 𝜋 𝑥 , 𝐿 ) by the standard procedure, E A C ( 𝑄 , 𝐴 , 𝜋 𝑥 , 𝐿 ) is mixture of normal distribution, and incur an expected annual cost ( 𝑄 , 𝐴 , 𝜋 𝑥 , 𝐿 ) . ( 𝑄 𝑛 , 𝐴 𝑛 , 𝜋 𝑥 𝑛 , 𝐿 𝑛 ) stands for the optimal order quantity, the ordering cost, the back-order price discount, and the optimal lead time, respectively, that the demand in the lead time is mixture of free distribution; E A C 𝑛 ( 𝑄 , 𝐴 , 𝜋 𝑥 , 𝐿 ) is the minimum total expected annual cost. We use E A C = E A C ( 𝑄 , 𝐴 , 𝜋 𝑥 , 𝐿 ) instead of the optimal E A C 𝑛 = E A C 𝑛 ( 𝑄 , 𝐴 , 𝜋 𝑥 , 𝐿 ) , for E A C 𝑛 = E A C 𝑛 ( 𝑄 𝑛 , 𝐴 𝑛 , 𝜋 𝑥 𝑛 , 𝐿 𝑛 ) . In other word, 𝑝 , 𝛿 = 0 . 5 , 1 . 0 and 𝜀 .