Research Article
Clarifying Cutting and Sewing Processes with Due Windows Using an Effective Ant Colony Optimization
Table 3
Effectiveness test results for small problems contrast to PSO and ACO.
|
Data type | | , , | , , | , , = 0.50 | EACO versus PSO | EACO versus ACO | EACO versus PSO | EACO versus ACO | EACO versus PSO | EACO versus ACO |
| | 3 | −25.66% | −11.31% | 34.26% | 33.64% | −21.21% | −10.33% | | 4 | −13.20% | −5.31% | 18.51% | 21.27% | −9.64% | 12.88% | I | 5 | 17.80% | 18.55% | 46.28% | 37.25% | 44.39% | 37.15% | 6 | 21.69% | 19.91% | 25.41% | 38.25% | 38.19% | 29.65% | | 7 | 16.48% | 40.80% | 56.13% | 48.26% | 27.74% | 28.62% | | 8 | 16.23% | 13.40% | 31.26% | 27.05% | 30.25% | 43.27% |
| | 3 | 30.71% | 18.07% | 42.52% | 30.13% | 18.22% | 37.67% | | 4 | 27.18% | 13.95% | 13.29% | 10.47% | 27.02% | 32.01% | II | 5 | 43.73% | 5.65% | 33.15% | 53.24% | 29.41% | 45.84% | 6 | 23.63% | 14.28% | 43.19% | 38.53% | 18.46% | 52.61% | | 7 | 2.58% | 10.19% | 32.03% | 41.21% | 52.25% | 65.48% | | 8 | 7.10% | 14.11% | 18.24% | 30.23% | 29.24% | 39.47% |
| | 3 | 10.59% | 6.69% | 35.41% | 40.62% | 50.14% | 2.02% | | 4 | 25.76% | 29.34% | 27.56% | 32.26% | 21.52% | 23.97% | III | 5 | 37.75% | 49.63% | 31.26% | 42.25% | 43.25% | 58.25% | 6 | 11.83% | −0.62% | 28.15% | 22.56% | −15.59% | 8.03% | | 7 | 5.34% | 9.09% | −21.13% | 61.51% | 34.28% | 44.96% | | 8 | 15.85% | 34.46% | 29.24% | 42.87% | 29.16% | 26.47% |
| | 3 | 35.35% | 43.03% | 39.15% | 65.02% | 59.38% | 75.43% | | 4 | 39.91% | 33.85% | −10.67% | 35.38% | 24.91% | 35.17% | IV | 5 | 26.40% | 46.95% | 53.55% | 56.19% | 33.28% | 32.32% | 6 | 21.36% | 16.57% | 30.57% | 32.57% | 61.45% | 65.16% | | 7 | 7.16% | 22.04% | 25.73% | 28.82% | 26.41% | 47.29% | | 8 | 36.66% | 13.27% | 27.23% | 33.53% | 33.72% | 34.84% |
| Avg. improvement | | 18.43% | 19.02% | 28.76% | 37.63% | 28.59% | 36.18% |
|
Total improvement (EACO versus PSO) | | 25.26% | | | |
|
Total improvement (EACO versus ACO) | | 30.94% | | |
|
|