Authenticated Blind Issuing of Symmetric Keys for Mobile Access Control System without Trusted Parties

Table 13

Comparison of properties.

	Wang-Zhao	Niu-Wang	Proposed
	protocol	protocol	protocol
Authentication	√	√	√
Blindness of secret keys	√	√	√
Blind key issuing	(^∗1)	(^∗1)	√
Non-PKI requirement	√	√	√
Replay attack resistance	√	√	√
MITM attack resistance	√	√	√
Empowered issuing			√
Independent key generation			√
Non-TTP requirement			√
Specific-key revocation			√
Storage-free choice			√