A Quasiphysical and Dynamic Adjustment Approach for Packing the Orthogonal Unequal Rectangles in a Circle with a Mass Balance: Satellite Payload Packing

Table 2

Performance comparisons of four algorithms.

Example number	Size	Algorithm	Average	Standard deviation	Minimal	Maximal	Average
1	5	GA + HA [35]	11.7703	0.0335	11.7597	11.8655	0.242
		CA-PSLS [34]	12.2181	0.5214	11.5443	13.0982	11.657
		QPDAA	11.6756	0.0235	11.4737	11.8533	0.953
2	6	IGA [44]	—	—	14.62000	—	18.000
		CA-PSLS [34]	15.19402	—	14.39625	—	19.904
		QPDAA	14.68374	—	14.344996	14.909841	4.963
3	9	GA + HA [35]	18.1709	0.2361	17.8988	18.6041	1.262
		CA-PSLS [34]	20.0899	1.1957	18.3758	22.0803	58.126
		QPDAA	18.2461	0.0694	17.6880	18.5983	1.110
4	20	GA + HA [35]	23.2713	0.4728	22.6396	24.0605	9.989
		CA-PSLS [34]	32.7216	4.0065	27.2863	38.5048	321.071
		QPDAA	22.8368	0.0222	22.3510	23.7884	2.625
5	40	GA [35]	119.2396	1.5087	115.836	120.7099	62.795
		CA-PSLS [34]	253.4165	43.8096	195.5914	306.2740	1367.573
		QPDAA	119.1383	0.6887	115.6252	120.5102	3.375