Three-Phase Methodology Incorporating Scatter Search for Integrated Production, Inventory, and Distribution Routing Problem

Table 4

Results for 200 customers instances.

	MAPM	RTS	SS
	Obj.	Obj.	Obj.	(MAPM)	RTS	Vehicles
1	996151	1030684	1033864	3.79	0.31	13
2	978373	1010158	995600	1.76	−1.44	13
3	986147	1016681	983290	−0.29	−3.28	13
4	962937	1042854	1004710	4.34	−3.66	13
5	970638	1023680	1004463	3.48	−1.88	13
6	965646	1025262	967194	0.16	−5.66	13
7	980562	1038746	1011310	3.14	−2.64	13
8	1014809	1066068	1001545	−1.31	−6.05	13
9	967738	1018420	984520	1.73	−3.33	13
10	1093230	1035240	1024832	−6.26	−1.01	13
11	1008080	1037705	981277	−2.66	−5.44	13
12	998951	1035350	995275	−0.37	−3.87	13
13	984918	1063024	1028545	4.43	−3.24	13
14	964301	1024491	1002466	3.96	−2.15	13
15	981167	1026787	997539	1.67	−2.85	13
16	1017777	1033656	1028718	1.07	−0.48	13
17	1073640	1022250	1067403	−0.58	4.42	13
18	1003670	1063306	1030854	2.71	−3.05	13
19	997348	1065705	1053589	5.64	−1.14	13
20	981788	1027134	1001820	2.04	−2.46	13
21	974384	1044771	965862	−0.87	−7.55	13
22	1065780	1045790	1001734	−6.01	−4.21	13
23	1070520	1027042	1014335	−5.25	−1.24	13
24	978491	1045014	973569	−0.50	−6.84	13
25	1029327	1024239	983691	−4.43	−3.96	13
26	961728	1043128	988534	2.79	−5.23	13
27	1028006	1030753	995478	−3.16	−3.42	13
28	1011689	1032478	994108	−1.74	−3.72	13
29	1015741	1019371	1048934	3.27	2.90	13
30	985496	1027915	1024006	3.91	−0.38	13