A Hybrid Approach to the Optimization of Multiechelon Systems

Table 7

(a) The results of numerical examples for 2E-CVRP-TW (hard windows). (b) The results of numerical examples for 2E-CVRP-TW (soft windows, penalty = 30).

(a)

E-n13-k4
	40	50	60	70	80	90	100	110	130	150	160
E-n13-k4-01	—	—	—	—	—	—	280	280	280	280	280
E-n13-k4-07	—	224	224	224	224	224	224	224	224	224	224
E-n13-k4-11	—	—	304	276	276	276	276	276	276	276	276
E-n13-k4-20	—	294	280	276	276	276	276	276	276	276	276
E-n13-k4-26	—	248	248	248	248	248	248	248	248	248	248
E-n13-k4-32	—	—	262	246	246	246	246	246	246	246	246
E-n13-k4-33	—	258	258	258	258	258	258	258	258	258	258
E-n13-k4-40	—	284	284	254	254	254	254	254	254	254	254
E-n13-k4-46	—	—	308	308	280	280	280	280	280	280	280
E-n13-k4-54	—	—	—	324	304	304	304	304	304	304	304

(b)

E-n13-k4
	40	50	60	70	80	90	100	110	130	150	160
E-n13-k4-01	358	354	346	346	310	310	280	280	280	280	280
E-n13-k4-07	270	224	224	224	224	224	224	224	224	224	224
E-n13-k4-11	306	306	304	276	276	276	276	276	276	276	276
E-n13-k4-20	366	294	280	276	276	276	276	276	276	276	276
E-n13-k4-26	292	248	248	248	248	248	248	248	248	248	248
E-n13-k4-32	322	278	262	246	246	246	246	246	246	246	246
E-n13-k4-33	336	258	258	258	258	258	258	258	258	258	258
E-n13-k4-40	344	284	284	254	254	254	254	254	254	254	254
E-n13-k4-46	344	310	308	308	280	280	280	280	280	280	280
E-n13-k4-54	342	334	334	324	304	304	304	304	304	304	304