Mathematical Problems in Engineering / 2016 / Article / Tab 3

Research Article

Fusion of IR and Visual Images Based on Gaussian and Laplacian Decomposition Using Histogram Distributions and Edge Selection

Table 3

Comparison with the existing methods (the improved ratio of the averaging method; the performance ranking is shown in parentheses).

MethodsUN CampDuneTrees

Li’s [16]1.277 (5)1.154 (5)1.402 (5)
Lewis’s [19]1.515 (3)1.435 (3)1.575 (4)
Saeedi’s [21]1.663 (1)1.568 (2)1.795 (2)
Proposed
(large parameters)
1.562 (2)1.578 (1)1.851 (1)
Proposed
(optimal parameters)
1.400 (4)1.365 (4)1.603 (3)

Li’s [16]1.075 (4)1.033 (4)1.015 (4)
Lewis’s [19]1.059 (5)1.019 (5)1.011 (5)
Saeedi’s [21]1.178 (1)1.120 (1)1.099 (2)
Proposed
(large parameters)
1.146 (2)1.101 (2)1.105 (1)
Proposed
(optimal parameters)
1.130 (3)1.093 (3)1.087 (3)