Robust Fuzzy Control for Fractional-Order Uncertain Hydroturbine Regulating System with Random Disturbances
The robust fuzzy control for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system is studied in this paper. First, the more practical fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system with uncertain parameters and random disturbances is presented. Then, on the basis of interval matrix theory and fractional-order stability theorem, a fuzzy control method is proposed for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system, and the stability condition is expressed as a group of linear matrix inequalities. Furthermore, the proposed method has good robustness which can process external random disturbances and uncertain parameters. Finally, the validity and superiority are proved by the numerical simulations.
Due to the advantages of describing actual projects, especially for the description of memory and hereditary properties of numerous materials and processes [1, 2], fractional calculus has attracted more and more people’s attention. It has been verified that many practical systems could be elegantly expressed with fractional calculus, such as power system , permanent magnet synchronous motor system , mechanical system , and chemical processing system .
The hydroturbine regulating system is a core component for safe and stable operation of hydropower station system. For a long time up to now, the integer-order model is usually adopted [7–9]. However, as we all know, the hydroturbine regulating system is integration of hydraulic, mechanical, and electrical parts. This complex composition makes it a strong coupling, nonlinear, and nonminimum phase system [10–12]. So the integer-order model may not be suitable for perfectly describing the hydroturbine regulating system. Besides, due to the memory character and history-dependence of hydraulic servo system, the more practical fractional-order model is considered accordingly in this study. Many studies have shown that the hydroturbine regulating system may exhibit irregular nonlinear vibrations when the system is under parameter variations and external random disturbances [13–15]. Therefore, it is very important to design nonlinear controller for the stable operation of fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system. Until now, some nonlinear control schemes have been proposed for fractional-order systems, such as sliding mode control , predictive control , adaptive control , and pinning control . However, few of the above-mentioned methods consider the uncertainty and random disturbances.
Fuzzy control is a robust method, which can deal with external disturbances [20–22]. Besides, with the help of fuzzy linearization and linear matrix theory, the uncertain parameters can be well processed [23–25]. There have been many results applying fuzzy control to integer-order nonlinear systems [26–29]. However, there is little literature about fractional-order nonlinear fuzzy control and there is almost no relevant result for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system.
According to the above analysis, some advantages are shown in this study. Firstly, the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system with uncertain parameters and random disturbances is presented, which is more in accordance with practical engineering. Secondly, a fuzzy control method is proposed for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system, and the stability condition is expressed as a group of linear matrix inequalities (LMIs). Furthermore, the proposed method has good robustness which can process external random disturbances and uncertain parameters. Even if the system is with six uncertain parameters, the controller designed for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system is still valid. Lastly, numerical simulations have demonstrated the effectiveness and superiority when compared with traditional PID control method.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system is introduced. Section 3 presents the robust fuzzy controller design for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system. Simulations are shown in Section 4. And the paper is ended in Section 5.
2. The Fractional-Order Hydroturbine Regulating System
The integer-order hydroturbine regulation system is given as where , , , and are the rotor angle deviation of the generator, the relative deviation of the rotational speed of the generator, the hydroturbine output incremental torque deviation, and the incremental deviation of the guide vane opening, respectively.
The hydraulic servo system has significant historical reliance. Since it is a powerful advantage for fractional calculus to describe the function which has significant historical reliance, the fractional-order hydraulic servo system is adopted.
According to fractional calculus, the fractional-order hydraulic servo system is obtained aswhere is the major relay connector response time.
According to (1) and (2) and for convenience, we use to replace . Then, the fractional-order mathematical model of hydroturbine regulation system could be represented as where , s, , , , , s, s, , , , , and .
Considering the universality of disturbances, the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system could be represented as
Figure 1 shows the state trajectories of fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (4) with initial value . It clearly shows that the system states are in irregular and unstable nonlinear vibrations. So the effective controller should be designed for the vibration inhibition and stable operation of the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system.
(a) State trajectory of
(b) State trajectory of
(c) State trajectory of
(d) State trajectory of
3. Robust Fuzzy Controller Design
3.1. Interval Matrix Theory
When the uncertain parameters are considered, the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system could be rewritten as where , and .
To discuss the parameter uncertainties of the coefficient matrix of the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (5), the following interval matrix theory is introduced.
The linear fractional-order interval system is given as  where the interval uncertain matrix satisfies
, where and are the lower and upper bounds of matrix , respectively.
The matrix could be equivalent presented aswhere where is the identity matrix th column.
Note that, for any and , there is
3.2. Parallel Distributed Compensation (PDC) Controller
Rule : IF is and and is where the fuzzy set is and is the IF-THEN rules number, is the state vector, , are the premise variables, the fractional order is , and the control input is . The Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy model total output is introduced aswhere
The new fuzzy controller is designed on the basis of parallel distributed compensation (PDC) and represented as follows.
Rule : IF is and and is
The parallel distributed compensation controller is shown as follows:where represents the feedback gain.
According to the term , (15) can be equally written as
3.3. Takagi-Sugeno Fuzzy Model of Fractional-Order Hydroturbine Regulating System
For the convenience of the coefficient matrix, the Maclaurin series expansion is introduced:
Assume ; here . The Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy model is established, with the following two rules to describe the dynamic behavior of the system: : IF is , THEN ; : IF is , THEN .
The membership functions are taken as follows:
In view of the above description, there is
So the fractional-order Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy model of the hydroturbine regulating system can be represented as
3.4. Controller Design
According to the PDC law, one has
Then, (20) could be rewritten as
Assumption 1. The parameter uncertainties considered here are norm-bounded in the following form:where are known real constant matrices of appropriate dimensions and is a diagonal random matrix with Lebesgue-measurable elements and satisfies ; is the identity matrix with an appropriate dimension.
Theorem 3. Assume the system matrix meets the Lyapunov function; that is, there is real positive definite symmetric matrix as well as semipositive definite matrix meeting . The fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (25) then will converge to the equilibrium point asymptotically.
Proof. Assume is an eigenvalue of the system matrix and the eigenvector is ; one can easily getFor both sides of (27), making conjugation and transpose, one hasFor (27) left side, multiplying , one can be obtainFor (28) right side, making the similar treatment and multiplying , one can also getCombining (29) and (30), one can easily getAccording to Theorem 3, is a seminegative definite matrix. So, for any nonzero vector , one hasCombining (31) and (32), one can easily getIt means, for all eigenvalues of matrix , there isReferring to Lemma 2, the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (25) then will converge to the equilibrium point asymptotically. The proof is complete.
The following more flexible theorem is presented on the basis of Theorem 3.
Theorem 4. For any system variables , there exists a real positive definite symmetric matrix meeting is called function). The fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (25) then will converge to the equilibrium point asymptotically. The condition could be equivalently given as
Proof. From Theorem 3, there isAccording to (36), one can easily getwhere is a semipositive definite matrix. That is to say, for any system variable , there isSubstituting (26) to (38), one hasThe positive definite symmetric matrix is supposed asIntroducing (40) to (39), one getsFor , (41) could be rewritten asIt is clear that Theorem 4 is equivalent to Theorem 3. The proof is finished.
Based on the above theorems, the more practical stability conditions are proposed as follows.
Theorem 5. The fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (25) then will converge to the equilibrium point asymptotically, once there exist a plus constant , a positive definite matrix , and the controller gain matrices which satisfy the following LMIs: where
, and is unit matrix.
Proof. Based on Theorem 4, choose as function for system (25).Considering that andselectThere followsSelect , and there is Taking the transpose of both sides in (49), one obtainsAccording to (50) and (49), one gets By substituting (51) into (48), one has Note that , so (52) can be equally represented as Accordingly, (25) can be assured as long as the following inequalities hold.It is clear that the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (25) then will converge to the equilibrium point asymptotically once (54) are satisfied.
With the help of Schur’s theorem , one can easily transform (54) to the standard form of linear matrix inequalities, which are presented as (43). The proof is complete.
4. Numerical Simulations
Considering the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system (4) with uncertain parameters, , , , , , and .
Therefore, , , , , , and .
To take control of the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system with uncertain parameters, we take , , and and can be calculated. The value of can also refer to Section 3.1.
According to the above theorems and , in the environment of Matlab 7.0 LMI toolbox we acquire
Figure 2 shows the simulation results of the traditional PID control method as well as the proposed scheme in this paper. It is clear that when the controller is applied, the system state variables quickly converge to zero point, which verifies the effectiveness. Compared with the traditional PID control method, it needs shorter transition time and the overshoot is more smaller than the designed scheme, which shows the superiority and good robustness of the proposed method.
(a) State trajectory of
(b) State trajectory of
(c) State trajectory of
(d) State trajectory of
The robust fuzzy control for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system was studied in this paper. First, mathematical model of the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system with uncertain parameters and random disturbances was introduced. Second, a fuzzy control method was proposed for fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system. Furthermore, the stability condition of the fractional-order hydroturbine regulating system was given as a group of linear matrix inequalities and the detailed mathematical proofs were presented. Besides, the method could handle the case of time-varying parameters and random disturbances, which has shown the good robustness. Finally, the validity and superiority were verified by the simulation results.
The scheme designed is simple and easy to implement and could be applied to similar fractional-order nonlinear systems. In the future, we will consider and extend the approach to other fractional-order hydroturbine governing systems, such as hydropower systems with time delay.
The authors declare that there are no competing interests regarding the publication of this paper.
This work was supported by the Scientific Research Foundation of the National Natural Science Foundation (51509210 and 51479173), the Science and Technology Project of Shaanxi Provincial Water Resources Department (Grant no. 2015slkj-11), the 111 Project from the Ministry of Education of China (B12007), and Yangling Demonstration Zone Technology Project (2014NY-32).
C. S. Li, J. Z. Zhou, J. Xiao, and H. Xiao, “Hydraulic turbine governing system identification using T–S fuzzy model optimized by chaotic gravitational search algorithm,” Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, vol. 26, no. 9, pp. 2073–2082, 2013.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. D. Lai, Y. Zhu, G. L. Liao, X. Zhang, T. Wang, and W. B. Zhang, “Lateral vibration response analysis on shaft system of hydro turbine generator unit,” Advances in Vibration Engineering, vol. 12, no. 6, pp. 511–524, 2013.View at: Google Scholar
T. Takagi and M. Sugeno, “Fuzzy identification of systems and its applications to modeling and control,” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 116–132, 1985.View at: Google Scholar
I. Elishakoff and M. Ohsaki, Optimization and Anti-Optimization of Structures under Uncertainty, Imperial College Press, London, UK, 2010.View at: Publisher Site
D. J. Ling, Bifurcation and Chaos of Hydraulic Turbine Governor, Hohai University, Nanjing, China, 2007.
D. Matignon, “Stability results for fractional differential equations with applications to control processing,” Computational Engineering in Systems and Application, vol. 2, pp. 963–968, 1996.View at: Google Scholar