Research Article

Fix-and-Optimize and Variable Neighborhood Search Approaches for Stochastic Multi-Item Capacitated Lot-Sizing Problems

Table 4

Computational results on S-MICLSP-L.

Algorithm

FO1-P 727790.95 436.31 15.36 82.41 37.00
FO1-R 741102.74 414.03 20.48 73.96 23.00
FO1-T 717907.32 429.78 14.52 83.69 33.00
FO1-PR 723629.97 442.17 13.00 80.94 45.00
FO1-PT 716389.74 452.53 13.32 87.00 42.00
FO1-PRT 712618.87 474.03 13.00 91.04 46.00


FO2--L1 −2.40−0.94−5.27−11.77 4.42 96.59 85.00
FO2--L2 −3.17−1.73 5.20−2.02 4.20 96.31 87.00
FO2--L3 −3.93 −2.50 13.38 5.59 3.94 95.80 88.00
FO2--L1 −1.10 0.37 −8.28−14.58 8.90 94.39 63.00
FO2--L2 −2.36 −0.91 0.06−6.81 8.38 96.03 62.00
FO2--L3 −2.81−1.36 9.21 1.71 8.00 98.80 68.00
FO2--L1 1.95 3.47−10.49−16.63 10.64 85.49 53.00
FO2--L2 0.71 2.22−3.92−10.52 9.68 89.13 50.00
FO2--L3 −0.63 0.85 4.70−2.49 9.00 92.03 56.00
FO-VNS-L1 −6.56−5.17 172.67 153.95 4.94 100.00 83.00
FO-VNS-L2−7.32 −5.94 172.74 154.01 4.54 100.00 84.00
FO-VNS-L3−7.54−6.16 173.38 154.61 4.02 100.00 84.00
4.14 5.69 172.56 153.84 7.84 93.76 71.00
−8.61 −7.25 8187.93 7618.80 0.00 100.00 90.00