Adaptive Differential Evolution Based on Simulated Annealing for Large-Scale Dynamic Economic Dispatch with Valve-Point Effects

Table 15

Statistical comparison for Case 5-7.

Method	F(B) ($)	F(A) ($)	F(W) ($)	SD	Time (min)
Case 5: 100-unit system
GA [45]	10,908,741	11,584,628	11,987,675	NA	9.04
PSO [45]	10,366,076	10,766,385	11,310,279	NA	5.89
FA [45]	10,197,269	10,419,457	11,216,243	NA	1.3
FAPSO [47]	10,200,860	10,207,245	10,211,461	NA	NA
SAFA [45]	10,183,819	10,286,043	10,388,958	NA	1.41
CSO [43]	10,183,633	10,185,287	10,192,352	1323	NA
ADE-SA	10,181,267	10,181,953	10,182,649	749.47	7.692
Case 6: 200-unit system
CSO [43]	20,409,722	20,414,842	20,437,874	4792	NA
ADE-SA	20,392,355	20,398,717	20,405,289	2017.10	13.542
Case 7: 500-unit system
CSO [43]	51,044,611	51,050,457	51,082,986	6067	NA
ADE-SA	51,032,830	51,040,129	51,055,302	4109.83	31.169

NA denotes that the value was not available in the literature.