A New Imperialist Competitive Algorithm for Multiobjective Low Carbon Parallel Machines Scheduling

Table 2

Comparisons among MOMA, ACO, ICA1, and new ICA on BEST.

	MOMA		ACO		ICA1		New ICA
		65	4284.8	56	4316.5	56	4316.5	56	4316.5
	459	6357.5	299	4979.1	285	5095.2	283	4979.1
	64	9017.8	34	8732.8	94	10595.9	32	8790.1
	1003	13959.3	817	13228.5	701	12838.2	690	14352.3
	240	9133.2	199	9363.0	252	11925.5	155	9363.0
	173	6969.1	131	7356.4	234	8543.3	97	7063.8
	3673	14550.2	3043	17291.1	2848	19014.1	2104	16113.8
	826	15724.8	617	14706.7	1430	21788.4	355	14119.3
	355	10224.1	276	9760.1	779	17857.8	156	9836.1
	197	15869.4	190	15325.0	582	23658.3	61	14486.2
	3160	20287.4	3257	20065.4	4413	32267.7	1907	19370.0
	1197	16631.4	1303	10504.0	2937	25036.6	621	10718.7
	864	22537.9	896	22677.1	2187	39664.3	375	20038.8
	1073	19746.7	343	18324.4	1919	51067.8	115	17289.6
	2622	21530.8	3372	24818.4	4756	34906.4	1918	21792.5
	1917	29604.6	1697	26113.0	4290	56967.8	826	24302.9
	658	18938.2	911	20650.6	4131	52051.7	345	18906.4
	4405	40114.0	4450	35485.3	9308	76955.5	2344	32028.0
	2595	27478.8	3033	28249.0	5842	56348.2	1325	26127.6
	1028	22847.1	1104	21434.9	6272	76945.4	391	19089.7
	8522	51214.5	9486	54150.3	18380	102872.3	4785	44933.8
	2554	32634.0	2775	33334.5	10905	99357.3	1270	28796.0
	435	21052.4	723	21349.2	7844	97740.7	186	20600.5
	8773	45778.1	11599	48224.9	28093	124923.7	5854	42417.5
	3450	34563.6	4590	34576.2	18005	115186.6	2120	30726.2
	1159	25442.1	1613	24713.5	11510	110158.3	515	24968.7
	12403	67204.2	17142	65871.5	36559	169238.0	8303	57896.8
	4921	31526.7	6674	32713.7	22069	102733.5	2984	29347.2
	2378	35482.6	2934	33490.5	14639	125260.9	1106	30533.7
	5451	57772.2	7312	52861.4	30813	187739.9	3079	45814.6
	2399	28342.2	3017	28682.6	20876	122877.3	1036	25557.8