A New Imperialist Competitive Algorithm for Multiobjective Low Carbon Parallel Machines Scheduling

Table 3

Comparisons among MOMA, ACO, ICA1, and new ICA on WOR.

	MOMA		ACO		ICA1		New ICA
		65	4284.8	58	3978.7	104	5567.2	59	3562.7
	509	6621.4	345	5026.6	580	5470.6	301	5090.9
	87	8790.1	50	9282.9	307	13706.5	59	8882.9
	1149	15091.0	906	13940.9	1063	17773.4	704	12740.3
	283	9367.8	261	9097.7	572	15152.1	195	9154.0
	146	7059.2	156	7640.0	712	13399.8	128	8048.4
	3864	14856.1	3365	18781.4	4790	26693.8	2164	16395.0
	911	17356.0	725	13732.6	2754	33195.8	400	13861.2
	403	10306.2	356	9656.7	2019	27188.6	193	9783.6
	359	17569.1	229	15118.9	1659	36914.3	116	16647.7
	3403	20247.4	3492	19547.1	7946	38695.1	2064	19526.6
	1310	14868.1	1389	12914.2	6092	33508.8	768	12133.7
	1062	24214.1	990	23511.2	4480	53144.3	474	23154.6
	1293	31052.0	395	19309.4	3968	68440.8	197	19277.9
	2830	23633.6	3511	23270.9	9211	58114.9	2063	21944.6
	2348	35228.8	1857	25752.1	8102	77000.0	938	24496.9
	827	20484.6	944	18988.6	6582	68940.3	453	20752.6
	4754	44360.3	4807	37446.8	15357	107062.8	2531	33887.4
	3956	31656.2	3372	29914.8	13505	80182.4	1505	27595.6
	1617	29421.0	1207	22810.1	10015	99105.3	535	22093.5
	9185	55098.9	10230	53571.8	30227	132490.7	5212	48209.9
	2822	33247.7	3066	34228.2	20336	138752.4	1455	33806.7
	714	22619.7	811	21343.0	13539	129451.0	285	22320.0
	9683	56680.2	12490	48304.2	46450	179610.1	6226	43798.2
	4468	41928.6	5017	37636.6	25597	148557.0	2497	34139.7
	1569	30121.8	1842	26161.1	19943	153944.5	685	26339.8
	13439	79430.0	17822	67572.5	54463	199616.5	8687	58893.9
	6084	35743.2	7162	34106.5	34111	113485.7	3262	30318.8
	3125	43934.0	3118	34478.9	25433	168075.6	1301	32160.0
	6490	62264.3	7729	52519.3	46779	238774.3	3299	47618.0
	2829	31359.5	3382	29615.7	32229	165592.3	1248	28203.8