Research Article
A New Imperialist Competitive Algorithm for Multiobjective Low Carbon Parallel Machines Scheduling
Table 4
Comparisons among MOMA, ACO, ICA1, and new ICA on AVG.
| | MOMA | ACO | ICA1 | New ICA | | | | | | | | |
| | 65.0 | 4284.8 | 56.4 | 4299.6 | 68.1 | 4144.9 | 57.0 | 4090.4 | | 486.0 | 5676.6 | 331.5 | 5006.6 | 390.8 | 5288.5 | 292.1 | 4976.3 | | 71.2 | 8852.8 | 40.9 | 8772.5 | 166.3 | 113187 | 42.8 | 8815.5 | | 1038.5 | 14091.6 | 864.7 | 13590.1 | 865.2 | 14598.2 | 693.1 | 13229.3 | | 261.3 | 9382.7 | 234.4 | 9702.1 | 373.3 | 12442.4 | 169.2 | 9817.7 | | 160.5 | 7492.1 | 144.2 | 7429.6 | 466.1 | 12116.8 | 113.2 | 7580.5 | | 3783.3 | 16170.0 | 3212.2 | 16624.5 | 3745.1 | 21015.5 | 2122.5 | 15361.4 | | 867.0 | 16640.3 | 681.7 | 14456.6 | 1964.6 | 27652.4 | 379.2 | 14215.9 | | 378.0 | 10193.2 | 327.0 | 9917.7 | 1237.8 | 22180.8 | 174.3 | 9939.3 | | 225.6 | 15917.4 | 210.9 | 15568.1 | 1000.85 | 28624.0 | 91.3 | 15580.1 | | 3281.2 | 20688.2 | 3353.5 | 20922.4 | 5821.7 | 34995.0 | 1960 | 19405.7 | | 1262.8 | 13977.3 | 1341.8 | 12847.2 | 4251.4 | 31254.6 | 655.5 | 11552.4 | | 951.7 | 22710.6 | 941.7 | 22686.0 | 3291.4 | 48613.3 | 416.1 | 20696.4 | | 1160.0 | 30869.8 | 380.9 | 18989.3 | 2987.9 | 62847.9 | 163.6 | 18456.3 | | 2675.1 | 23006.5 | 3442.7 | 23513.0 | 7412.3 | 50818.8 | 1972.7 | 22049.0 | | 2005.0 | 29498.0 | 1799.4 | 26628.0 | 6143.1 | 67251.9 | 869.1 | 24351.5 | | 750.9 | 19579.8 | 950.5 | 19980.4 | 5321.6 | 60929.4 | 405.7 | 19255.9 | | 4479.1 | 39922.6 | 4707.4 | 35942.0 | 12306.8 | 91298.3 | 2416.6 | 32750.1 | | 2890.0 | 29353.2 | 3270.4 | 29007.4 | 9670.1 | 71468.9 | 1406.2 | 26648.1 | | 1340.0 | 25829.9 | 1142.6 | 21910.3 | 7699.5 | 85988.5 | 434.7 | 19997.7 | | 8872.0 | 52160.2 | 9851.8 | 51504.6 | 24125.9 | 118001.4 | 4895.2 | 45484.0 | | 2688.6 | 34085.4 | 2956.4 | 32941.1 | 14207.1 | 115536.4 | 1339.4 | 30486.1 | | 576.6 | 22785.5 | 770.1 | 21811.6 | 10505.2 | 114924.6 | 231.8 | 20557.3 | | 9223.9 | 51447.5 | 12186.2 | 48382.6 | 33668.1 | 135846.2 | 6006.9 | 43092.3 | | 3855.4 | 38299.9 | 4844.6 | 36326.4 | 21764.8 | 127503.5 | 2274.0 | 32632.4 | | 1323.8 | 28139.1 | 1757.2 | 26291.4 | 15884.7 | 132815.9 | 579.9 | 24413.5 | | 12727.7 | 70269.8 | 17488 | 67196.6 | 42108.6 | 171637.6 | 8687.0 | 59111.7 | | 5581.1 | 35524.7 | 7020.9 | 33513.2 | 28278.5 | 115073.2 | 3086.6 | 29394.6 | | 2759.7 | 37720.7 | 3019.1 | 34398.4 | 20894.1 | 150294.9 | 1199.6 | 31177.5 | | 5962.6 | 58193.9 | 7539.0 | 53527.8 | 37930.3 | 215962.5 | 3213.7 | 47173.8 | | 2562.9 | 28535.4 | 3244.6 | 29012.2 | 26132.5 | 144387.1 | 1125.2 | 25759.7 |
|
|
