Energy-Efficient Scheduling for a Job Shop Using Grey Wolf Optimization Algorithm with Double-Searching Mode

Table 3

Comparison results for different algorithms.

Index	Instancce	TLBO				HGWO				DMGWO
		Best	Avg	ARPD	T	Best	Avg	ARPD	T	Best	Avg	ARPD	T
1	FT06	372.3	400.3	7.52	37.1	372.3	376.5	1.13	13.0	372.3	378.3	1.61	5.5
2	FT10	13155.8	14211.8	49.42	189.6	9822.7	10634.3	11.81	65.0	9511.2	10260.24	7.88	18.9
3	FT20	14375.4	17241.7	69.31	345.6	11516.8	12552.7	23.27	66.0	10183.4	11489.3	12.82	21.4
4	LA01	3963.2	4727.1	64.97	80.0	2865.4	3130.9	9.27	21.4	2865.4	3081.9	7.56	8.3
5	LA02	3531.8	3956.3	86.46	79.4	2121.8	2509.1	18.25	21.3	2200.6	2529.2	19.20	8.0
6	LA03	4777.2	5112.9	47.58	77.0	3464.6	3908.6	12.82	21.1	3744.2	3939.3	13.70	8.0
7	LA04	4364.8	4622.5	58.09	77.8	2934.2	3262.3	11.57	21.0	2924.0	3115.9	6.56	8.0
8	LA05	4547.0	4755.8	22.93	81.2	3868.6	4149.4	7.26	21.2	4059.6	4174.8	7.92	7.8
9	LA06	8135.4	9242.1	42.62	178.2	6942.3	7253.5	11.93	40.2	6480.4	6947.0	7.20	13.8
10	LA07	8899.9	9418.7	45.62	176.4	6665.3	7078.2	9.44	40.3	6467.9	6803.6	5.19	13.9
11	LA08	7777.6	8474.6	64.56	184.1	5381.6	5855.6	13.70	40.3	5149.9	5697.1	10.63	13.1
12	LA09	8593.2	9496.0	61.67	177.4	6004.5	6779.3	15.42	39.6	5873.6	6257.9	6.54	13.8
13	LA10	9648.7	10303.0	38.17	171.9	7456.6	7917.5	6.18	39.5	7495.6	7853.4	5.32	13.8
14	LA11	15544.2	16590.8	38.94	333.2	12795.2	13203.2	10.57	64.7	11940.6	12872.4	7.80	21.2
15	LA12	12664.4	13228.8	42.32	331.4	9416.6	9901.5	6.53	65.7	9295.0	9974.3	7.31	21.3
16	LA13	15006.2	15563.2	47.39	338.8	10808.4	11580.1	9.67	64.9	10559.2	11390.6	7.87	21.4
17	LA14	17479.0	18805.6	29.54	333.9	14517.4	15542.4	7.06	65.5	14595.4	15989.2	10.14	21.6
18	LA15	16251.8	16993.9	36.92	334.7	12425.8	13400.6	7.97	64.4	12411.4	13008.0	4.81	21.8
19	LA16	14492.9	15869.3	32.47	182.0	11979.8	13086.8	9.24	63.1	11979.8	12690.6	5.93	19.5
20	LA17	13146.6	14391.7	35.69	182.9	10606.0	11490.1	8.34	62.0	10606.0	11558.0	8.98	18.7
21	LA18	12855.4	14588.5	54.68	183.7	10241.1	10688.2	13.33	62.2	9431.4	10564.0	12.01	18.6
22	LA19	12475.0	13215.9	56.53	185.6	8443.0	9484.7	12.34	61.9	8443.0	9156.8	8.45	18.6
23	LA20	15653.6	17613.8	32.24	181.3	13521.8	14362.1	7.82	63.1	13320.0	14149.4	6.23	18.6
24	LA21	21510.9	22242.2	86.38	426.6	11934.1	13853.9	16.09	122.7	12320.6	13344.7	11.82	34.1
25	LA22	21873.5	22429.0	70.34	422.8	13476.6	14466.0	9.86	116.3	13167.4	14102.6	7.10	33.6
26	LA23	19924.8	21070.1	109.50	417.2	10311.1	11248.6	11.85	117.0	10057.2	11101.7	10.39	33.5
27	LA24	18822.2	20179.1	101.28	431.0	10271.5	12389.9	23.58	119.2	10025.5	11501.1	14.72	33.6
28	LA25	20193.5	22058.7	75.82	419.4	13110.0	14392.6	14.72	117.7	12546.1	13800.9	10.00	33.6
29	LA26	27738.2	30390.6	99.74	817.7	15215.0	17455.7	14.73	197.7	15934.2	17142.0	12.67	50.7
30	LA27	27596.2	30652.0	91.42	800.3	16013.2	17738.3	10.77	203.2	16796.6	17551.7	9.61	50.0
31	LA28	28440.4	31144.0	96.00	803.4	15889.8	18211.8	14.61	203.9	15922.4	18244.7	14.82	49.7
32	LA29	28901.6	31343.6	69.21	790.3	18524.0	20412.4	10.19	200.5	18694.2	20205.0	9.07	49.3
33	LA30	32110.6	33845.3	69.03	805.0	20429.0	21392.4	6.84	207.1	20023.4	20896.1	4.36	49.2
34	LA31	50140.7	54193.6	55.78	2137.1	36974.3	39046.6	12.24	434.4	34787.6	36839.3	5.90	88.2
35	LA32	55044.1	56783.2	55.99	2011.3	37168.4	38154.3	4.81	444.6	36402.4	37161.4	2.09	87.5
36	LA33	49378.8	52924.8	58.14	1674.4	34788.7	36123.5	7.94	425.7	33466.2	35538.7	6.19	87.4
37	LA34	51422.3	54523.5	60.00	1857.8	34494.4	37743.5	10.76	434.0	34077.1	36436.9	6.92	92.2
38	LA35	57561.1	59842.1	55.39	1794.1	40544.9	42996.0	11.64	434.4	38511.5	40783.8	5.90	93.3
39	LA36	43779.1	45924.3	47.81	587.3	32033.0	34732.9	11.79	251.7	31070.4	33365.9	7.39	60.6
40	LA37	43986.0	46232.3	44.11	596.9	32552.6	33660.8	4.92	253.5	32082.3	32980.9	2.80	59.9
41	LA38	39819.45	42084.6	47.51	634.3	28530.4	30706.1	7.63	249.2	29835.1	30725.1	7.69	58.8
42	LA39	39469.9	42439.5	75.81	611.3	24615.9	26750.9	10.82	254.4	24139.1	24966.4	3.43	58.0
43	LA40	38279.0	40019.4	66.12	640.3	24942.3	28096.8	16.63	255.4	24091.0	26508.0	10.03	58.3