Research Article
Shared Mechanism-Based Self-Adaptive Hyperheuristic for Regional Low-Carbon Location-Routing Problem with Time Windows
Table 7
Efficiency of the proposed mathematical model.
| Instance | RLRPRCC-TT | RLRPRCC-TD | △TC | △VC | △FEC/CE | △PC | △TD | △TT | △TC | △VC | △FEC/CE | △PC | △TD | △TT |
| 25DC1 | 1.66 | -15.45 | 37.89 | -43.21 | 26.03 | -15.28 | 1.56 | -20.00 | 44.64 | -54.31 | 38.43 | -14.61 | 25DC2 | 2.62 | -20.00 | 48.49 | -45.32 | 39.54 | -13.31 | 2.12 | -20.00 | 47.53 | -52.46 | 39.89 | -13.46 | 25DC3 | 3.84 | -14.68 | 42.70 | -41.02 | 29.70 | -14.44 | 2.39 | -19.27 | 43.29 | -48.19 | 42.10 | -13.93 | 25DR | 1.80 | -15.45 | 36.12 | -47.22 | 22.26 | -18.75 | 1.72 | -15.45 | 38.16 | -56.38 | 28.02 | -18.90 | 50DC1 | 3.31 | -14.65 | 42.87 | -55.92 | 16.01 | -23.80 | 1.71 | -7.58 | 24.71 | -39.90 | 9.68 | -15.67 | 50DC2 | 3.19 | -14.65 | 36.25 | -47.41 | 9.69 | -21.30 | 1.46 | -6.06 | 18.07 | -31.00 | 2.31 | -13.35 | 50DC3 | 6.00 | -14.65 | 40.38 | -48.94 | 10.58 | -22.28 | 4.18 | -7.58 | 28.37 | -45.64 | 13.32 | -15.00 | 50DR | 5.72 | -16.16 | 46.79 | -49.96 | 17.76 | -20.81 | 5.91 | -14.65 | 46.51 | -51.34 | 23.87 | -17.50 | 75DC1 | 2.99 | -17.90 | 46.74 | -62.16 | 16.83 | -26.99 | 2.77 | -17.90 | 46.17 | -64.85 | 19.53 | -25.56 | 75DC2 | 4.75 | -17.90 | 52.44 | -61.70 | 22.34 | -25.17 | 2.53 | -19.84 | 42.50 | -55.41 | 21.70 | -20.07 | 75DC3 | 4.85 | -22.14 | 58.43 | -65.55 | 21.85 | -30.25 | 3.44 | -22.14 | 53.00 | -64.90 | 22.75 | -27.99 | 75DR | 5.58 | -12.08 | 36.35 | -43.79 | 16.23 | -16.32 | 9.31 | -12.08 | 51.88 | -58.65 | 33.20 | -16.56 | 100DC1 | 2.31 | -16.48 | 35.70 | -54.71 | 8.04 | -23.17 | 1.34 | -15.93 | 31.37 | -59.39 | 4.19 | -23.10 | 100DC2 | 0.43 | -16.97 | 28.96 | -44.40 | 6.49 | -20.75 | 0.30 | -16.19 | 28.36 | -47.42 | 10.75 | -19.34 | 100DC3 | 3.58 | -16.62 | 37.37 | -48.89 | 11.35 | -21.16 | 1.21 | -17.17 | 30.65 | -51.81 | 13.24 | -20.60 | 100DR | 7.57 | -5.30 | 37.58 | -31.25 | 26.13 | -7.69 | 7.21 | -5.30 | 37.75 | -42.62 | 30.92 | -7.90 | Average | 3.76 | -15.69 | 41.57 | -49.47 | 18.80 | -20.09 | 3.07 | -14.82 | 38.31 | -51.52 | 22.12 | -17.72 | Median | 3.45 | -15.81 | 39.14 | -48.15 | 17.30 | -20.99 | 2.25 | -16.06 | 40.33 | -52.13 | 22.23 | -17.03 |
|
|