Deep-Mining Backtracking Search Optimization Algorithm Guided by Collective Wisdom

Table 10

Comparison of best solutions for the tension/compression spring design problem.

Method
GA-DT	0.051989	0.363965	10.890522	−1.3E − 05	−2.1E − 05	−4.061338	−0.722698	0.012681
MDE	0.051688	0.356692	11.290483	−0.000000	−0.000000	−4.053734	−0.727090	0.012665
CPSO	0.051728	0.357644	11.244543	−8.45E − 04	−1.26E − 05	−4.051300	−0.727090	0.012675
HPSO	0.051706	0.357126	11.265083	NA	NA	NA	NA	0.012665
DEDS	0.051689	0.356718	11.288965	NA	NA	NA	NA	0.012665
HEAA	0.051690	0.356729	11.288294	NA	NA	NA	NA	0.012665
DELC	0.051689	0.356718	11.288966	NA	NA	NA	NA	0.012665
ABC	0.051749	0.358179	11.203763	−0.000000	−0.000000	−4.0566663	−0.726713	0.012665
MBA	0.051656	0.35594	11.344665	0	0	−4.052248	−0.728268	0.012665
SSOC	0.051689	0.356718	11.288965	NA	NA	NA	NA	0.012665
BSA-SAε	0.051989	0.356727	11.288425	−7.70E − 09	−3.30E − 09	−4.054	−0.728	0.012665
BSA	0.51694	0.356845	11.281488	−1.05E − 07	−1.77E − 08	−4.054037	−0.727640	0.012665
MBSAgC	0.051689	0.356718	11.288954	−4.15E − 14	−1.13E − 13	−4.0538	−0.7277	0.012665