Deep-Mining Backtracking Search Optimization Algorithm Guided by Collective Wisdom

Table 11

Comparison of statistical results for the tension/compression spring design problem.

Method	Worst	Mean	Best	Std	FEs
GA-DT	0.012973	0.12742	0.12681	5.90E − 05	80000
MDE	0.012674	0.012666	0.012665	2.0E − 06	24000
CPSO	0.012924	0.012730	0.012675	5.20E − 05	23000
HPSO	0.012719	0.012707	0.012665	1.58E − 05	81000
DEDS	0.012738	0.012669	0.012665	1.25E − 05	24000
HEAA	0.012665	0.012665	0.012665	1.4E − 09	24000
DELC	0.012666	0.012665	0.012665	1.3E − 07	20000
PSO-DE	0.012665	0.012665	0.012665	1.2E − 08	24950
ABC	NA	0.012709	0.012665	0.012813	30000
MBA	0.012900	0.012713	0.012665	6.30E − 05	7650
SSOC	0.012868	0.012765	0.012665	9.29E − 05	25000
BSA-SAε	0.012666	0.012665	0.012665	1.62E − 07	80000
BSA	0.012669	0.012666	0.012665	7.24E − 07	43220
MBSAgC	0.012665	0.012665	0.012665	1.25E − 07	22680