Research Article
Deep-Mining Backtracking Search Optimization Algorithm Guided by Collective Wisdom
Table 12
Comparison of best solutions for the welded beam design problem.
| Method | GA-DT | MDE | CPSO | HPSO | ABC | MBA | BSA-SAε | BSA | BSAISA | MBSAgC |
| | 0.205986 | 0.205730 | 0.202369 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | 0.205729 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | | 3.471328 | 3.470489 | 3.544214 | 3.470489 | 3.470489 | 3.470493 | 3.470489 | 3.470489 | 3.470489 | 3.47049 | | 9.020224 | 9.036624 | 9.04821 | 9.036624 | 9.036624 | 9.036626 | 9.036624 | 9.036624 | 9.036624 | 9.036624 | | 0.206480 | 0.205730 | 0.205723 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | 0.205729 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | 0.205730 | | −0.074092 | −0.000335 | −12.8399796 | NA | 0.000000 | −0.001614 | −1.55E − 10 | −5.32E − 07 | 0 | −2.2628E − 09 | | −0.266227 | −0.000753 | −1.247467 | NA | −0.000002 | −0.016911 | −4.30E − 09 | −9.02E − 06 | 0 | −1.8335E − 09 | | −4.95E − 04 | −0.0000000 | −1.49E − 03 | NA | 0.0000000 | −2.40E − 07 | −1.55E − 15 | −7.86E − 12 | −5.55E − 17 | −2629E − 13 | | −3.430044 | −3.432984 | −3.429347 | NA | −3.432984 | −3.432982 | −3.4330 | −3.432984 | −3.43294 | −3.4330 | | −0.080986 | −0.080730 | −0.079381 | NA | −0.080730 | −0.080729 | −8.07E − 02 | −0.080730 | −0.080730 | −0.080730 | | −0.235514 | −0.235540 | −0.235536 | NA | −0.235540 | −0.235540 | −0.2355 | −0.235540 | −0.235540 | −0.2355 | | −58.666440 | −0.000882 | −11.681355 | NA | 0.000000 | −0.001464 | −1.85E − 10 | −1.13E − 07 | −5.46E − 12 | −4.0927E − 10 | | 1.728226 | 1.724852 | 1.728024 | 1.724852 | 1.724852 | 1.724853 | 1.724852 | 1.724852 | 1.724852 | 1.724852 |
|
|