Research Article
A Memetic Algorithm for Multiskill Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling Problem under Linear Deterioration
Table 5
Comparison of results of GVNS-MA and GVNS-
on the set of 45 new generated instances in Section
5.4.
| instances | GVNS-MA | GVNS- | | | | | | | | |
| 100-10-26-15_1 | 632.74 | 146.08 | 274.99 | 635.08 | 163.91 | 309.99 | -12.21 | -12.73 | 100-10-47-9_1 | 694.45 | 206.66 | 349.51 | 696.66 | 197.36 | 364.15 | 4.50 | -4.19 | 100-10-48-15_1 | 648.51 | 193.34 | 286.55 | 649.11 | 174.83 | 244.17 | 9.57 | 14.79 | 100-10-64-9_1 | 687.22 | 222.47 | 312.41 | 678.09 | 191.71 | 348.78 | 13.83 | -11.64 | 100-10-64-15_1 | 693.46 | 192.91 | 309.49 | 673.75 | 190.47 | 297.09 | 1.26 | 4.01 | 100-20-22-15_1 | 188.83 | 161.71 | 256.15 | 187.22 | 146.31 | 225.34 | 9.52 | 12.03 | 100-20-46-15_1 | 258.62 | 154.94 | 240.39 | 256.60 | 142.55 | 228.86 | 8.00 | 4.80 | 100-20-47-9_1 | 188.64 | 222.79 | 258.72 | 182.12 | 252.05 | 293.80 | -13.13 | -13.56 | 100-20-65-15_1 | 888.01 | 172.61 | 207.43 | 870.85 | 220.43 | 187.68 | -27.70 | 9.52 | 100-20-65-9_1 | 183.69 | 237.32 | 354.53 | 188.66 | 264.17 | 333.25 | -11.31 | 6.00 | 100-5-22-15_1 | 4865.86 | 184.44 | 270.23 | 4866.02 | 224.41 | 295.76 | -21.67 | -9.45 | 100-5-46-15_1 | 6350.3 | 264.37 | 457.83 | 6720.42 | 270.03 | 488.58 | -2.14 | -6.72 | 100-5-48-9_1 | 5520.60 | 154.46 | 264.23 | 5520.60 | 189.28 | 311.00 | -22.54 | -17.70 | 100-5-64-15_1 | 5544.26 | 338.39 | 413.58 | 5555.52 | 322.48 | 461.02 | 4.70 | -11.47 | 100-5-64-9_1 | 5281.77 | 222.77 | 323.46 | 5287.14 | 200.70 | 350.71 | 9.91 | -8.42 | # | | 7 | 9 | | 8 | 6 | | | # | | 8 | 6 | | 7 | 9 | | | # | | 15 | 15 | | 15 | 15 | | | # | | | | | | | -3.29 | -2.98 |
|
|