| Scale-instance | PSO-LS | PSO | GA |
| 10-1 | 666.8100 | 669.9850 | 666.8100 | 10-2 | 186.3200 | 186.4200 | 186.3200 | 10-3 | 273.2200 | 274.3000 | 273.6150 | 10-4 | 232.3720 | 229.3980 | 236.8330 | 10-5 | 1,114.7300 | 1,115.6540 | 1,117.5780 | 30-1 | 4,956.7030 | 4,938.7220 | 4,724.9780 | 30-2 | 18,087.6580 | 18,563.0790 | 19,007.3440 | 30-3 | 6,810.1500 | 6,919.5320 | 7,286.0000 | 30-4 | 9,355.2740 | 9,612.9000 | 9,701.4130 | 30-5 | 10,393.8770 | 10,603.2970 | 11,060.3790 | 50-1 | 47,373.0790 | 49,662.6280 | 50,611.0100 | 50-2 | 68,891.7570 | 70,747.0140 | 79,298.5780 | 50-3 | 61,826.2370 | 64,119.7600 | 67,243.0500 | 50-4 | 68,777.6710 | 70,193.7050 | 77,970.5510 | 50-5 | 29,073.9680 | 30,776.0000 | 33,192.1830 | 70-1 | 135,271.7270 | 143,512.1820 | 158,553.0030 | 70-2 | 164,900.6270 | 171,377.4080 | 183,845.9250 | 70-3 | 128,195.6660 | 135,871.2800 | 150,625.1680 | 70-4 | 110,219.4880 | 118,058.2520 | 138,250.7180 | 70-5 | 161,958.1090 | 166,567.7950 | 192,447.0210 | 100-1 | 287,348.7000 | 308,337.3160 | 452,220.2050 | 100-2 | 316,831.4730 | 339,679.4730 | 491,640.0870 | 100-3 | 363,915.9090 | 392,756.4790 | 550,393.6550 | 100-4 | 512,024.2470 | 541,724.8160 | 705,187.0550 | 100-5 | 352,616.9280 | 384,112.2770 | 588,789.3920 | 300-1 | 13,726,081.6490 | 14,313,663.8880 | 35,374,531.8320 | 300-2 | 12,896,793.1160 | 13,395,467.6770 | 34,768,966.6680 | 300-3 | 10,358,806.2330 | 10,809,516.3790 | 30,715,756.5610 | 300-4 | 13,422,518.7670 | 14,022,110.8640 | 35,002,552.1430 | 300-5 | 10,851,867.1710 | 11,269,214.0880 | 29,338,328.5100 |
|
|