Research Article

Effect of Personal Space Invasion on Passenger Comfort and Comfort Design of an Aircraft Cabin

Table 1

Summary of how personal space can be invaded in economy class (quantity: the number of respondents).

Respondents’ description (quantity)Factors (quantity)Dimensions (quantity)

(i) The distance between seats in the same row is too close, and the width of seat surface, armrests, and armrest itself is not enough (27)Interpersonal distance (46)Physical space (128)
(ii) Passengers stay in intimate distance (0–0.45 m, Hall [24]), which may not correspond to their interpersonal relationship (19)
(i) Due to the seat pitch, the space for passengers to move their limbs is limited (16)Room for passengers’ limbs (43)
(ii) Adjacent passengers who sit with their legs/feet outstretched or elbows sticking out of their personal space (20)
(iii) Monopolizing shared spaces including the armrest or controlling whether the armrest is raised or lowered (7)
(i) Fully reclining their seat back (11)Front-row passengers (26)
(ii) Suddenly straightening/reclining the seat back (10)
(iii) Shaking their body on the seat (causes the tray table behind to vibrate) (5)
(i) Passengers placing their belongings in another person’s space (13)Belongings’ placement (13)

(i) Adjacent passengers can cause tactile sensation by opening a newspaper widely, dining, and adjusting their posture (27)Adjacent passengers (53)Tactile sensation (140)
(ii) Adjacent passengers lean when sleeping (26)
(i) Passenger squeezing past or climbing over another passenger, asking others to let them out or reaching or leaning across other passengers (18)Passenger movement (36)
(ii) Cabin crew may also reach across passengers to pass something to the adjacent passenger (10)
(iii) Passenger sitting in an aisle seat, others walking past may invade their personal space (8)
(i) Back-row passenger kicking, pushing, and pulling the back of the seat (16)Back-row passengers (28)
(ii) Back-row passenger unfolding and folding up the tray table on front seat back (12)
(i) Passengers’ belongings have contact with other passengers (23)Contact with objects (23)

(i) Mechanical noise in cabin (8)Noise (33)Other sensory factors (101)
(ii) Passengers nearby being boisterous and loud (including bodily noises) (16)
(iii) Passengers using their audiovisual equipment with external voice (5)
(iv) Noise from cabin passenger service unit (PSU) and entertainment systems (4)
(i) Bodily smells (including perfume) (23)Smell (39)
(ii) The smell of food and drinks (16)
(i) Lighting factors including the cabin lighting system, atmosphere light, and light shield (12)Illumination (29)
(ii) Reading lights and the display lights of electronic equipment (17)

(i) Listening to other passengers’ conversations or talking to them when they do not want to engage in conversation (23)Conversation (23)Interpersonal communication (81)
(i) Passenger looking at other people or at what they are doing (12)Sight (23)
(ii) Unwanted eye contact (11)
(i) A stranger tries to chat with me, even if I do not want to talk with him/her or they ask questions I do not want to answer (such as my salary, my family, or current politics) (35)Content (35)