The Opposition-Based Learning Parameter Adjusting Harmony Search Algorithm Research on Radars Optimal Deployment

Table 7

The comparison results for the 10 algorithms for .

HS	Mean	0.998004	0.001642	−1.03163	0.397887	3.9	−3.86278	−3.29425	1.051415	−0.99385	−186.731
	SD	5.04e − 16	0.001702	2.09e − 11	8.64e − 12	4.929503	1.88e − 10	0.051146	0.078868	0.004762	4.72e − 09
IHS	Mean	0.998004	0.000897	−1.03163	0.397887	253.6464	−3.86278	−3.29425	1.001683	−0.99287	−186.731
	SD	3.18e − 16	0.000263	6.36e − 13	2.17e − 13	408.3936	1.89e − 11	0.051146	0.009185	0.00437	1.99e − 10
GHS	Mean	0.998004	0.00106	−1.03162	0.397905	7.503757	−3.86278	−3.27444	1.041427	−0.9932	−186.73
	SD	9.98e − 10	0.000175	1.63e − 05	3.54e − 05	10.23882	9.71e − 07	0.059242	0.062066	0.004532	0.001356
SAHS	Mean	0.998004	0.007824	−1.03127	0.398256	766.1257	−3.73393	−3.31403	1.450669	−0.99034	−186.708
	SD	9.81e − 07	0.011861	0.000473	0.000726	2342.809	0.29301	0.060157	0.336652	0.005987	0.038899
IGHS	Mean	0.998004	0.000817	−1.03163	0.79677	9.300002	−3.81125	−3.28236	1.216004	−0.99028	−186.731
	SD	2.86e − 16	8.04e − 05	4.91e − 16	0.907177	11.61494	0.196121	0.057005	0.242904	4.52e − 16	2.18e − 14
NDHS	Mean	0.998004	0.000816	−1.03163	0.397887	12.9	−3.86278	−3.2784	1.00011	−0.99487	−186.731
	SD	7.86e − 16	0.000375	3.37e − 11	5.89e − 11	13.23358	3.16e − 12	0.058273	0.000436	0.007723	2.79e − 09
ITHS	Mean	0.998004	0.002268	−1.03134	0.398301	1140.022	−3.86277	−3.28233	1.098494	−0.99066	−186.693
	SD	2.99e − 06	0.001873	0.000761	0.000535	21.81583	1.9e − 05	0.057028	0.145211	0.006242	0.073549
EHS	Mean	0.998004	0.000871	−1.03162	0.397918	3.001621	−3.86278	−3.29425	1.008312	−0.99255	−186.705
	SD	1.73e − 07	3.56e − 05	1.47e − 05	9.55e − 05	0.008459	4.54e − 13	0.051146	0.030837	0.004176	0.082658
SGHS	Mean	0.998017	0.001167	−1.03163	0.637217	3	−3.78518	−3.26651	1.000023	−0.99001	−186.731
	SD	7.38e − 05	0.000754	1.35e − 12	0.730263	5.21e − 11	0.235773	0.060328	9.55e − 05	0.005703	1.92e − 10
OLPDHS	Mean	0.998004	0.000869	−1.03163	0.397887	3.000001	−3.86278	−3.28236	1.0000	−1	−186.731
	SD	5.59e − 11	3.44e − 05	1.66e − 08	6.8e − 07	1.89e − 06	8.99e − 07	0.050005	0.000364	0	6.12e − 05