Modelling and Simulation in Engineering / 2022 / Article / Tab 1 / Review Article
Shear Strengthening of RC Beams with FRP Composites: Database of FE Simulations and Analysis of Studied Parameters Table 1 Database of numerical studies assessing parameters of RC beams strengthened in shear with externally bonded FRP composites and validating with and without experimental tests.
Specimen Section Configuration Fiber Kaliakin et al. [25 ] C1 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 — 2.67 59.6 0 2.05 0 — — — 200 — — 38.3 37.7 C2 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 — 2.67 74.3 0 2.05 0 — — — 200 — — 39.8 39.3 C3 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 — 2.67 54.5 0 2.05 0 — — — 200 — — 38.5 38 C4 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 — 2.67 56.5 0 2.05 0 — — — 200 — — 36 35.5 A1 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 1.04 2.67 54.5 3.28 2.05 0 CT-U 90 A 200 11.03 0.0225 77.4 78.4 A2 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 1.04 2.67 58.0 3.28 2.05 0 CT-U 90 A 200 11.031 0.0225 60.1 — E1 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 0.46 2.67 50.2 1.44 2.05 0 CT-U 90 E-G 200 14.27 0.0134 73.5 — E2 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 0.46 2.67 58.0 1.44 2.05 0 CT-U 90 E-G 200 14.27 0.0134 67.9 61.5 G1 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 0.58 2.67 52.7 1.833071 2.05 0 CT-U 90 G 200 20.96 0.0095 71 64.3 G2 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 0.58 2.67 56.6 1.833071 2.05 0 CT-U 90 G 200 20.960 0.0095 72.9 66 45G1 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 0.58 2.67 56.6 1.833071 2.05 0 CT-U 45 G 200 20.960 0.0095 75.1 68 45G2 T 88.9 63.5 127 63.5 152.4 0.58 2.67 50.2 1.833071 2.05 0 CT-U 45 G 200 20.960 0.0095 94.5 85.6 Arduini et al. [26 ] B4 R 350 — 400 300 350 0.51 3.14 39.6 0.113333 0.37 0.28 CT-U 90 C 200 400 0.0075 — — Amir [27 ] IF R 175 — 200 127 175 2 2.61 36.5 3.149606 1.80 0.21 CTS 45 C 200 34.13 — — — Vecchio and Bucci [28 ] Beam 1 R 935 — 1000 550 935 — 2.16 44.7 — 0.81 0.06 — — — 492 — — 1700 1800 Beam 2 R 935 — 1000 550 935 1 2.16 44.7 0.363636 0.81 0.06 CTS 90 C 492 230 0.0142 2528 — Lee et al. [29 ] Model 1 T 192.8 75 230 140 267.8 — 2.98 25 — 4.46 0.18 — — — 200 — — — 64 Model 2 T 192.8 75 230 140 267.8 — 2.98 25 — 4.46 0.18 — — — 200 — — — 48 Model 3 T 192.8 75 230 140 267.8 1.2 2.98 25 0.337458 4.46 0.18 ST-U 90 C 200 165 0.014 — 78 Model 4 T 192.8 75 230 140 267.8 1.2 2.98 25 0.337458 4.46 0.18 ST-U 90 C 200 165 0.014 — 93 Kachlakev et al. [30 ] Control beam R — — 768.35 305 704.85 2.59 16.7 0 0.54 0 — — — 200 — — 476 454 Shear beam R 679.45 — 768.35 305 704.85 5.2 2.59 14.7 3.409836 0.54 0 CTS 90 Glass 200 21 — 689 525 Flexure/shear beam R 679.45 — 768.35 305 704.85 5.2 2.59 13.0 3.409836 0.54 0 CTS + flexural strengthening 90 C/glass 200 62-21 — 712 930 Wong and Vecchio [31 ] RWOA-1 R 470 — 560 305 470 0.84 3.89 22.6 0.367213 1.67 — ST-S 90 C 217.87 72.4 0.011 493 — RWOA-2 R 470 — 560 305 470 0.84 4.86 25.9 0.367213 2.16 — ST-S 90 C 217.87 72.4 0.011 457 — RWOA-3 R 470 — 560 305 470 0.84 6.80 43.5 0.367213 2.65 — ST-S 90 C 205.46 72.4 0.011 436 — Beam 1 (De rose) R 935 — 560 550 935 2.16 44.7 — 0.81 0.06 — — — 492 — — 1700 1800 Beam 2 (De rose) R 935 — 560 550 935 1 2.16 44.7 0.363636 0.81 0.06 CTS 90 C 492 230 0.0142 2528 2465 Santhakumar et al. [32 ] C48 R 164.05 — 203.2 127 164.05 — 2.78 36.5 — 1.93 0.21 — — — 200 — — — — IIIFu R 164.05 — 203.2 127 164.05 1.49 2.78 36.5 2.36063 1.93 0.21 CT-U 45 C 200 28.3 0.009 — — IE R 164.05 — 203.2 127 164.05 2.18 2.78 36.5 3.43937 1.93 0.21 CT-U 90 C 200 34.1 0.009 — — Elyasian et al. [33 ] SB-90 R 320.5 — 380 230 320.5 0.18 2.85 31 0.156522 1.33 0.18 CTW 90 C 200 228 0.018 451 — SB-90-0 R 320.5 — 380 230 320.5 0.36 2.85 31 0.313043 1.33 0.18 CTW 90 C 200 228 0.018 468 — SB-45 R 320.5 — 380 230 320.5 0.18 2.85 31 0.156522 1.33 0.18 CTW 45 C 200 228 0.018 529 — SB-45-0 R 320.5 — 380 230 320.5 0.36 2.85 31 0.313043 1.33 0.18 CTW 45 C 200 228 0.018 528 — Otoom et al. [34 ] S03-1 R 260 — 305 150 260 2.92 28 — 4.12 — — — 200 — — 154 — S03-2 R 260 — 305 150 260 0.16 2.92 28 0.088 4.12 — ST-U 90 C 200 228 0.0165 262 265 Qu et al. [35 ] S0-2-0 R 260 — — — 260 — 2.15 31.8 — 2.9 0.19 — 0 — — — — — — S-CU-2-1 R 260 — — — 260 — 2.15 37.6 0.074 2.9 0.19 ST-U 90 C — 235 — — — Smith et al. [36 ] BS3 — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — BS5 — — — — — — — — — — — — ST-U — — — — — — — Godat et al. [37 ] B-1 R — — 200 150 170 3 30.5 — 2.98 — — — — 182 — — 40 41 B-8 R 170 — 200 150 170 0.16 3 35.4 0.222667 2.98 — CT-U 90 C 182 230 0.015 86 90 TR30D1 R 250 — 300 150 250 3 31.4 — — 0.33 — — — 210 — — 322 323 TR30D3 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.16 3 31.4 0.22 — 0.33 CTS 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 323 336 TR30D4 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.33 3 31.4 0.44 — 0.33 CTS 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 400 399 TR30D2 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.49 3 31.4 0.66 — 0.33 CTS 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 422 414 BT1 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 — 3 35 — 2.30 — — — — 200 — — 178 184 BT2 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.22 2.30 — CT-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 309 313 BT3 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.33 3 35 0.44 2.30 — CT-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 310 313 BT4 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.088 2.30 — ST-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 324 325 BT5 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.088 2.30 — ST-S 90 C 200 228 0.0166 243 247 BT6 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.22 2.30 — CT-U + anchorage 90 C 200 228 0.0166 442 453 US R 216 — 250 150 216 2.5 35 — — — — — — 200 — — 114 119 RS90 R 216 — 250 150 216 1 2.5 35 0.666667 — — ST-S 90 C 200 150 0.014 184 197 RS135 R 216 — 250 150 216 1 2.5 35 0.444444 — — Inclined ST-S 45 C 200 150 0.014 194 202 Godat et al. [38 ] RC1 R — — 200 100 166 2.04 51.2 — 4.1 — — 90 — 200 235 — 160 166 U4 R 166 — 200 100 166 0.111 2.04 51.2 0.1332 4.1 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 203 213 RC2 R — — 400 200 330 2.06 49.7 — 4.5 — — 90 — 200 235 — 709 745 U5 R 330 — 400 200 330 0.222 2.06 51.2 0.1332 4.5 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 809 813 RC3 R — — 600 300 498 2.04 50.5 — 4.2 — — 90 — 200 235 — 1626 1659 U6 R 498 — 600 300 498 0.33 2.04 51 0.1332 4.2 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 2018 2053 Lee et al. [39 ] SO3-1 R 253.33 — 305 150 253.33 3 27.5 — 4.23 — — 90 — 200 — — 154 — SO3-2 R 253.33 — 305 150 253.33 0.16 3 27.5 0.088 4.23 — ST-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 262 — SO3-4 R 253.33 — 305 150 253.33 0.16 3 27.5 0.22 4.23 — CT-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 289 — SO3-5 R 253.33 — 305 150 253.33 0.33 3 27.5 0.44 4.23 — CT-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 339 — Godat et al. [40 ] RC1 R — — 200 100 166 2.04 51.2 — 4.1 — — 90 — 200 235 — 160 166 U4 R 166 — 200 100 166 0.11 2.04 51.2 0.1332 4.1 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 203 213 RC2 R — 400 200 330 2.06 49.7 — 4.5 — — 90 — 200 235 — 709 745 U5 R 330 — 400 200 330 0.22 2.06 51.2 0.1332 4.5 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 809 813 RC3 R — — 600 300 498 2.04 50.5 — 4.2 — — 90 — 200 235 — 1626 1659 U6 R 498 — 600 300 498 0.33 2.04 51 0.1332 4.2 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 2018 2053 W7 R 498 — 600 300 498 0.33 2.04 51 0.222 4.2 — CTW 90 C 200 235 0.0151 2221 2203 You et al. [41 ] T4-12-control I 817 — — 152 944 — 2.9 68.5 0 — 0.31 — — — 178 210 — 894 903 T4-18-control I 817 — — 152 944 — 2.9 68.7 0 — 0.2 — — — 178 210 — 912 858 T4-18-S90-NA I 817 — — 152 944 0.31 2.9 69.1 0.14 — 0.2 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 983 961 T4-18-S90-CMA I 817 — — 152 944 0.31 2.9 69.8 0.14 — 0.2 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1085 1010 T4-18-S90-DMA I 817 — — 152 944 0.31 2.9 70 0.14 — 0.2 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1005 1023 T4-12-control-deck I 817 — — 152 944 — 2.9 73.5 0 — 0.31 — — — 178 210 — 1090 1112 T4-12-S90-SDMA I 817 — — 152 944 0.31 2.9 71.2 0.14 — 0.31 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1139 1174 T3-12-control I 655 — — 152 782 — 3.4 61.3 0 — 0.31 — — — 178 210 — 1121 1014 T3-12-S90-NA I 655 — — 152 782 0.31 3.4 61.4 0.14 — 0.31 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1201 1152 T3-12-S90-NA-PC I 655 — — 152 782 0.31 3.4 65.3 0.14 — 0.31 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1085 1143 T3-12-S90-DMA I 655 — — 152 782 0.31 3.4 71.6 0.14 — 0.31 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1108 1143 T3-18-control I 655 — — 152 782 — 3.4 66.1 0 — 0.2 — — — 178 210 — 1121 912 T3-18-S90-NA I 655 — — 152 782 0.31 3.4 69.8 0.14 — 0.2 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 943 907 T3-18-S90-HS I 655 — — 152 782 0.31 3.4 70.2 0.14 — 0.2 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 979 894 T3-18-S90-SDMA I 655 — — 152 782 0.31 3.4 71.9 0.14 — 0.2 ST-U 90 C 178 210 0.017 1045 907 Hawileh et al. [ TB 1-60-90° T 260 120 75 285 335 0.12 5 32.4 0.1666 0.98 0 ST-S 90 C 205 231 0.017 57.17 55.07 TB 1-0-90° T 260 120 75 285 335 0.12 5 32.4 0.2 0.98 0 CT-S 90 C 205 231 0.017 — 65.13 TB 1-17-90° T 260 120 75 285 335 0.12 5 32.4 0.58 0.98 0 ST-S 90 C 205 231 0.017 — 60 TB 1-153-90° T 260 120 75 285 335 0.12 5 32.4 0.06 0.98 0 ST-S 90 C 205 231 0.017 — 47 TB 2-60-90° T 260 120 75 285 335 0.24 5 32.4 0.333 0.98 0 ST-S 90 C 205 231 0.017 — 58 TB 3-60-90° T 260 120 75 285 335 0.36 5 32.4 0.5 0.98 0 ST-S 90 C 205 231 0.017 — 63 TB 1-60-45° X T 260 120 75 285 335 0.12 5 32.4 0.166 0.98 0 Inclined ST-S 45 C 205 231 0.017 — 65 Hawileh et al. [43 ] FS-200-C R 400 — 80 500 400 0.381 0.8 21 0.95 1.54 0.46 CT-U 90/0 C 200 230 0.015 270.5 270 FS-250-C R 400 — 80 500 400 0.381 0.8 21 0.95 1.54 0.46 CT-U 90/0 C 200 230 0.015 182 186 FS-250-T R 400 — 80 500 400 0.381 0.8 21 0.95 1.54 0.46 CT-U 90/0 C 200 230 0.015 219.4 219.3 FS-250-B R 400 — 80 500 400 0.381 0.8 21 0.95 1.54 0.46 CT-U 90/0 C 200 230 0.015 186.6 185.5 Chen et al. [3 ] SO3-1 R 260 — 305 150 260 — 2.92 27.5 — 4.12 — — — — 200 — — 154 — SO3-2 R 260 — 305 150 260 0.16 2.92 27.5 0.088 4.12 — ST-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 262 — BS3 R 403.22 — 450 200 403.22 — 3.1 37.5 — 2.33 0.07 — — — 200 — — 136.6 — BS5 R 403.22 — 450 200 403.22 0.11 3.1 36 0.013875 2.33 0.07 ST-U 90 C 200 233 0.015 170 — Dirar et al. [44 ] F/295/LP1/4.5 T 295 105 245 105 295 0.39 3.8 24 0.249524 4.5 0.21 CT-U 90 C 200 238 0.018 135 114.8-134.4-134.4 F/295/LP2/4.5 T 295 105 245 105 295 0.39 3.8 27 0.249524 4.5 0.21 CT-U 90 C 200 238 0.018 133.5 127.2-153.6-142.4 F/215/LP1/4.6 T 215 105 165 105 215 0.39 3.8 32 0.249524 4.6 0.21 CT-U 90 C 200 238 0.018 122.5 113-132.6-132.4 F/215/LP2/4.6 T 215 105 165 105 215 0.39 3.8 25 0.249524 4.6 0.21 CT-U 90 C 200 238 0.018 102.5 96.6-115.6-109 F/295/LP1/3.3 T 295 105 245 105 295 0.39 3.8 28 0.249524 3.3 0.21 CT-U 90 C 200 238 0.018 96.5 125-108-119 Godat et al. [45 ] SGU-1-1 R — — — 150 — — 1.5 — — — — — — — — — — 355 368 S0-2-0 R — — — 150 — — 1.5 — — — — — — — — — — 222 230 SGU-2-1a R — — — 150 — — 1.5 — — — — — — — — — — 301 300 SGU-2-1b R — — — 150 — — 1.5 — — — — — — — — — — 516 515 SGU-2-2 R — — — 150 — — 2.15 — — — — — — — — — — 285 301 SGU-2-3 R — — — 150 — — 2.15 — — — — — — — — — — 347 366 SCU-2-1 R — — — 150 — — 2.15 — — — — — — — — — — 294 291 SGO-2-1 R — — — 150 — — 2.15 — — — — — — — — — — 530 538 SGUB-2-1 R — — — 150 — — 2.8 — — — — — — — — — — 306 314 SGU-3-1 R — — — 150 — — 2.8 — — — — — — — — — — 221 239 R1 T — — — 225 — — 2.8 — — — — — — — — — — 495 515 0.75D T — — — 225 — — 3 — — — — ST-U — — — — — 762 804 0.6D T — — — 225 — — 3 — — — — ST-U — — — — — 797 816 0.5D T — — — 225 — — 3 — — — — ST-U — — — — — 892 940 RC1 R 166 — 200 100 166 — 2.04 51.2 — 4.1 — — 90 — 200 235 — 160 166 U4 R 166 — 200 100 166 0.11 2.04 51.2 0.1332 4.1 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 203 213 RC2 R 330 — 400 200 330 — 2.06 49.7 — 4.5 — — 90 — 200 235 — 709 745 U5 R 330 — 400 200 330 0.22 2.06 51.2 0.1332 4.5 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 809 813 RC3 R 498 — 600 300 498 — 2.04 50.5 — 4.2 — — 90 — 200 235 — 1626 1659 U6 R 498 — 600 300 498 0.33 2.04 51 0.1332 4.2 — ST-U 90 C 200 235 0.0151 2018 2050 W7 R 498 — 600 300 498 — 3 — — — — — — — — — 0.0151 2221 2203 B-1 R 170 — 200 150 170 — 3 30.5 — 2.98 — — — — 182 — — 40 41 B-8 R 170 — 200 150 170 0.16 3 35.4 0.222667 2.98 — CT-U 90 C 182 230 0.015 86 90 TR30D1 R 250 — 300 150 250 3 31.4 — — 0.33 — — — 210 — — 322 323 TR30D3 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.16 3 31.4 0.22 — 0.33 CTS 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 323 336 TR30D4 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.33 3 31.4 0.44 — 0.33 CTS 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 400 399 TR30D2 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.49 3 31.4 0.66 — 0.33 CTS 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 422 414 BT1 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 3 35 — 2.30 — — — — 200 — — 178 184 BT2 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.22 2.30 — CT-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 309 313 BT3 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.33 3 35 0.44 2.30 — CT-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 310 313 BT4 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.088 2.30 — ST-U 90 C 200 228 0.0166 324 325 BT5 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.088 2.30 — ST-S 90 C 200 228 0.0166 243 247 BT6 T 256.66 100 305 150 356.66 0.16 3 35 0.22 2.30 — CT-U + anchorage 90 C 200 228 0.0166 442 453 US R 216 — 250 150 216 2.5 35 — 1.63 0.21 — — — 200 — — 114 119 RS90 R 216 — 250 150 216 1 2.5 35 0.666667 1.63 0.21 ST-S 90 C 200 150 0.014 184 197 RS135 R 216 — 250 150 216 1 2.5 35 0.444444 1.63 0.21 Inclined ST-S 45 C 200 150 0.014 194 202 Godat et al. [46 ] B-1 R 170 — 200 150 170 — 3 30.5 — 2.98 — — — — 182 — — 80 82-82 B-8 R 170 — 200 150 170 0.16 3 35.4 0.222667 2.98 — CT-U 90 C 182 230 0.015 172 180-159 TR30D1 R 250 — 300 150 250 — 3 31.4 — — 0.33 — — — 210 — — 322 323-323 TR30D3 R 250 — 300 150 250 0.16 3 31.4 0.22 — 0.33 ST-S 90 C 210 233.6 0.015 323 336-300 US R 216 — 250 150 216 — 2.5 35 — 1.63 0.21 — — — 200 — — 114 119-119 RS90 R 216 — 250 150 216 1 2.5 35 0.666667 1.63 0.21 ST-S 90 C 200 150 0.014 184 162-176 RS135 R 216 — 250 150 216 1 2.5 35 0.444444 1.63 0.21 Inclined ST-S 45 C 200 150 0.014 194 202-184 Imperatore et al. [47 ] TM1 T 273 210 315 260 483 — — 19.1 — 0.72 0.15 ST-U 45 C — 65.5 0.00822 450 — TM2 T 268 210 310 260 478 — — 25.5 — 0.72 0.15 ST-U 45 C — 65.5 0.00822 500 — Sayed et al. [48 ] 2S-1 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 30 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 163.1 2S-2 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 174.3 2S-3 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.3 1.8 30 0.15 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 180.8 2S-4 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.066667 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 163.0 2S-5 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 152.3 2S-6 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 218.8 2S-7 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 162.9 2S-8 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 178.8 2S-9 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.5 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 178.7 2S-10 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 2.25 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 172.9 2S-11 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.333333 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 198.3 2S-12 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 280.2 2S-13 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 20 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 141.4 2S-14 R 360 — 400 120 360 0.1 1.8 50 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 190.4 2S-15 R 360 — 400 400 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 182.1 2S-16 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 197.8 2S-17 R 280 — 300 200 280 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 143.2 2S-18 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 172.9 2S-19 R 560 — 600 200 560 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-S 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 247.9 U-jac.-1 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 30 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 206.5 U-jac.-2 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 229.1 U-jac.-3 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.3 1.8 30 0.15 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 247.0 U-jac.-4 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.066667 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 211.7 U-jac.-5 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 205.9 U-jac.-6 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 268.8 U-jac.-7 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 201.9 U-jac.-8 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 231.8 U-jac.-9 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.5 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 242.7 U-jac.-10 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 2.25 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 225.0 U-jac.-11 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.333333 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 209.1 U-jac.-12 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 360.2 U-jac.-13 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 20 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 172.1 U-jac.-14 R 360 — 400 120 360 0.1 1.8 50 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 243.9 U-jac.-15 R 360 — 400 400 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 211.9 U-jac.-16 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 246.7 U-jac.-17 R 280 — 300 200 280 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 185.2 U-jac.-18 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 210.5 U-jac.-19 R 560 — 600 200 560 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-U 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 278.7 Wrapped-1 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 30 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 255.4 Wrapped-2 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 301.8 Wrapped-3 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.3 1.8 30 0.15 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 322.8 Wrapped-4 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.066667 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 272.2 Wrapped-5 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 252.8 Wrapped-6 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.2 2.05 0.25 CT-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 355.8 Wrapped-7 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 270.5 Wrapped-8 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 305.7 Wrapped-9 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.5 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 307.6 Wrapped-10 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 2.25 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 272.1 Wrapped-11 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.333333 2.05 0.25 CT-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 288.3 Wrapped-12 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.2 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 482.0 Wrapped-13 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 20 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 209.1 Wrapped-14 R 360 — 400 120 360 0.1 1.8 50 0.05 2.05 0.25 ST-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 313.1 Wrapped-15 R 280 — 300 400 280 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 217.8 Wrapped-16 R 360 — 400 200 360 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 282.8 Wrapped-17 R 560 — 600 200 560 0.1 1.8 30 0.1 2.05 0.25 CT-W 90 C 240 200 0.015 — 435.0 Manos et al. [49 ] CRB R 322 — 360 200 322 — 2.79 22.4 — 2.43 — — — — 202.7 — — 39.44 39.44 CRBs R 322 — 360 200 322 — 2.79 25.9 — 2.43 0.33 — — — 202.7 — — 90.60825 87.89 RB200C R 322 — 360 120 322 0.13 2.79 22.4 0.109167 2.43 — ST-U 90 C 202.7 41.784 0.009 97.99 97.99 RB200Ca R 322 — 360 120 322 0.13 2.79 22.4 0.109167 2.43 — ST-U + anchorage 90 C 202.7 41.784 0.009 115.3301 118.79 RB200S R 322 — 360 120 322 0.11 2.79 25.9 0.098667 2.43 — ST-U 90 SFRP 202.7 36.35 0.009 94.12903 87.54 RB200Sa R 322 — 360 120 322 0.11 2.79 25.9 0.098667 2.43 — ST-U + anchorage 90 SFRP 202.7 36.35 0.009 122.25 112.47 RB150C R 322 — 360 120 322 0.13 2.79 22.4 0.145556 2.43 — ST-U 90 C 202.7 41.784 0.009 100.6566 99.65 RB150Ca R 322 — 360 120 322 0.13 2.79 22.4 0.145556 2.439125 — ST-U + anchorage 90 C 202.7 41.784 0.009 123.0408 120.58 RB150S R 322 — 360 120 322 0.11 2.79 22.4 0.131556 2.439125 — ST-U 90 SFRP 202.7 36.35 0.009 103.1383 96.95 RB150Sa R 322 — 360 120 322 0.11 2.79 22.43 0.131556 2.439125 — ST-U + anchorage 90 SFRP 202.7 36.35 0.009 118.7692 123.52 Qapo et al. [50 ] Control I 457.2 — — 102 457.2 — 2.5 — — 1.23 0 — 90 — 186.6-204.5 — — 117.4 129,5 IB-05 I 457.2 — — 102 457.2 1.25 2.5 70.8 1.466728 1.23 0 ST-U 90 C 186.6-204.6 6.585 0.015 161.9 162 IB-10 I 457.2 — — 102 457.2 1.25 2.5 70.8 0.733364 1.23 0 ST-U 90 C 186.6-204.7 6.585 0.015 119.2 149.7 Ibars et al. [51 ] U90S5-a R 250 — 420 250 370 0.29 3.5 36.9 0.88 2.03 0.10 ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.015 341 341 U90S5-b R 250 — 420 250 370 0.29 3.5 28.0 0.88 2.03 0.10 ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.015 326 315 U90S3-a R 250 — 420 250 370 0.17 3.5 20.5 0.53 2.03 0.10 ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0155 285 263 U90S3-b R 250 — 420 250 370 0.17 3.5 22.5 0.53 2.03 0.10 ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0155 204 — U90S3-c R 250 — 420 250 370 0.17 3.5 28.0 0.53 2.03 0.10 ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0155 320 311 W90S5 R 370 — 420 250 370 0.29 3.5 49.9 0.88 2.03 0.10 ST-W 90 C 200 240 0.015 383 402 W90S3-ab R 370 — 420 250 370 0.17 3.5 37 0.53 2.03 0.10 ST-W 90 C 200 240 0.0155 432 408 W90S3-b R 370 — 420 250 370 0.17 3.5 37 0.53 2.03 0.10 ST-W 90 C 200 240 0.0155 394 408 Al Jawahery et al. [52 ] R — — — 150 260 0.3 2.4 44.5 0.177778 1.546154 — ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0204 233.24 225 R — — — 150 210-260 — 2.97-2.4 60 — 1.94-1.54 — — — — 200 240 0.0204 113.5 118.2 A1-10U90 R — — — 150 160-260 0.3 3.9-2.4 49 0.1 2.51-1.54 — ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0204 173.21 170.5 A2-10U45 R — — — 150 160-260 0.3 3.9-2.4 51.5 0.1 2.51-1.55 — ST-U 45 C 200 240 0.0204 171.523 160 R — — — 150 110-160 0.3 5.68-3.9 42.5 0.1 3.65-2.51 — ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0204 171.445 158 A2-15U45 R — 150 110-260 0.3 5.68-2.4 60 0.1 3.65-1.54 — ST-U 45 C 200 240 0.0204 168.149 164 Rf2U90 R — — — 150 210 0.3 2.97 60.7 0.1 1.91 — ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0204 163.157 134 B1-5INJ R — — — 150 210-260 — 2.97-2.4 58.5 1.91-1.54 — — — — 200 240 0.0204 108 152.8 B1-10U90 R — — — 150 210-310 0.3 2.97-2.01 44 0.1 1.91-1.29 — ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0204 140.049 130.8 B2-10U45 R — — — 150 210-310 0.3 2.97-2.02 61 0.1 1.91-1.30 — ST-U 45 C 209 (assumed) 240 0.0204 153.45 110 B1-15U90 R — — — 150 210-360 0.3 2.97-1.73 62 0.1 1.91-1.11 — ST-U 90 C 200 240 0.0204 140.74 136 B2-15U45 R — — — 150 210-360 0.3 2.97-1.73 50.1 0.1 1.91-1.11 — ST-U 45 C 200 240 0.0204 119.664 110 Jin et al. [53 ] CBF-S-0.0555 R 180 — 200 80 180 1 2 39.5 0.0555 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-0.0555 R 360 — 400 160 360 2 2 39.5 0.0555 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-0.0555 R 540 — 600 240 540 3 2 39.5 0.0555 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-0.0555 R 720 — 800 320 720 4 2 39.5 0.0555 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-S-0.111 R 180 — 200 80 180 2 2 39.5 0.111 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-0.111 R 360 — 400 160 360 4 2 39.5 0.111 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-0.111 R 540 — 600 240 540 6 2 39.5 0.111 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-0.111 R 720 — 800 320 720 8 2 39.5 0.111 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-S-0.222 R 180 — 200 80 180 4 2 39.5 0.222 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-0.222 R 360 — 400 160 360 8 2 39.5 0.222 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-0.222 R 540 — 600 240 540 12 2 39.5 0.222 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-0.222 R 720 — 800 320 720 16 2 39.5 0.222 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-S-1.11 R 180 — 200 80 180 20 2 39.5 1.11 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-1.11 R 360 — 400 160 360 40 2 39.5 1.11 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-1.11 R 540 — 600 240 540 60 2 39.5 1.11 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-1.11 R 720 — 800 320 720 80 2 39.5 1.11 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-S-2.22 R 180 — 200 80 180 40 2 39.5 2.22 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-2.22 R 360 — 400 160 360 80 2 39.5 2.22 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-2.22 R 540 — 600 240 540 120 2 39.5 2.22 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-2.22 R 720 — 800 320 720 160 2 39.5 2.22 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-S-4.44 R 180 — 200 80 180 80 2 39.5 4.44 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-4.44 R 360 — 400 160 360 160 2 39.5 4.44 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-4.44 R 540 — 600 240 540 240 2 39.5 4.44 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-4.44 R 720 — 800 320 720 320 2 39.5 4.44 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-S-8.88 R 180 — 200 80 180 160 2 39.5 8.88 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-M-8.88 R 360 — 400 160 360 320 2 39.5 8.88 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-L-8.88 R 540 — 600 240 540 480 2 39.5 8.88 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — — CBF-U-8.88 R 720 — 800 320 720 640 2 39.5 8.88 1.24 0.12 ST-S 90 C 210 212 0.0198 — —
