Review Article

Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis of Noninvasive Brain Stimulation on Dysphagia after Stroke

Table 1

Characteristics of the included studies.

StudiesCountrySampleAgeDuration (h/d/w/m)ModalityIntervention lengthStimulationOutcomes

Kumar et al., 2011 [17]United States7/7tDCS10 dPharyngeal motor cortex of the unaffected side, 2 mADOSS
Shigematsu et al., 2013 [18]Japan10/10tDCS10 dPharyngeal motor cortex of the affected side, 1 mADOSS
Ahn et al., 2017 [19]Korea13/13tDCS2 wBilaterally pharyngeal motor cortices, 1 mADOSS
Pingue et al., 2018 [20]Italy8/122 (m)tDCS10 dPharyngeal motor cortex of the affected side, 2 mADOSS, PAS
An, 2018 [21]China32/32tDCS2 wPharyngeal motor cortex of the unaffected side,2 mADOSS, SSA
Li et al., 2020 [22]China23/24tDCS3 wBilaterally pharyngeal motor cortices,1.4 mASSA
Mao et al., 2020 [23]China20/20tDCS8 wPharyngeal motor cortex of the unaffected side, 1.6 mADOSS, FDS
Park et al., 2013 [24]Korea9/9rTMS2 wPharyngeal motor cortex of the unaffected side, 5 HzPAS
Lim et al., 2014 [25]Korea14/15rTMS2 wPharyngeal motor cortex of the unaffected side, 1 HzPAS, FDS
Zheng et al., 2017 [26]China45/45rTMS20 dFrom the anterolateral cortex of the skull to the front of the primary motor area, the lowest part of the anterior central gyrus, and the back part of the inferior frontal gyrus, 5 HzSSA, WST
Ünlüer et al., 2019[27]Turkey15/13rTMS1 wCorresponding cortex area of suprahyoid muscle of the unaffected side, 1 HzPAS
Cai et al., 2019[28]China20/20rTMS2 wBilateral corresponding cortex area of suprahyoid muscle, 10 HzSSA
Ou et al., 2019[29]China20/20rTMS2 wCorresponding cortex area of suprahyoid muscle of the unaffected side, 5 HzSSA, PAS
Jiao et al., 2019[30]China30/30rTMS4 wFrom the anterolateral cortex of the skull to the front of the primary motor area, the lowest part of the anterior central gyrus, and the back part of the inferior frontal gyrus, 3 HzDOSS, PAS
Jiao et al., 2020[31]China20/20rTMS2 wFrom the anterolateral cortex of the skull to the front of the primary motor area, the lowest part of the anterior central gyrus, and the back part of the inferior frontal gyrus of the affected side, 3 HzDOSS
Fang et al., 2020[32]China30/30Not givenrTMS2 wPharyngeal motor cortex of the unaffected side, 5 HzSSA, WST
Zhang et al., 2020[33]China14/15rTMS2 wCorresponding cortex area of suprahyoid muscle of the unaffected side, 5 HzPAS, FDS
Zhong et al., 2021[34]China38/35rTMS2 wCorresponding cortex area of suprahyoid muscle of the affected side, 5 HzSSA, PAS