Review Article

Manganese-Induced Parkinsonism due to Ephedrone Abuse

Table 1

Summary of clinical and MRI data from the different reports (EDTA: ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, GP: globus pallidus, GPi: internal part of globus pallidus, NCh: head of caudate nucleus, PAS: para-aminosalicylic acid, SI: signal intensity, SN: substantia nigra, SNr: reticular part of substantia nigra, STN: subthalamic nucleus, y: years).

PublicationNo. of the subjectsAge (y)Time to the symptomsInitial symptomsMRI findingsTreatmentOutcome

Levin 2005 [33]2115–36 (21 ± 5.8)3–14 (6.8 ± 4.9) monthsDisorders of speech (33%) and gait (29%), fatigue (29%), bradykinesia (14%), affective symptoms (19%)T1 bilateral symmetric SI in GPi, SNr—18 (86%); no correlation with duration of usage, dosage nor severity of the symptomsEDTA, l-dopa, clonazepam, amantadineSpontaneous regression of the symptoms—29%, worsening—33% even after 4 y abstinence
Sikk et al. 2007, 2010 [14, 34]4 (case reports)24–426 months–8 yGait disorder—2, hypophonia—2T1 SI increase in GP, putamen, NCh—2 cases; decrease of SI in the same areas—1Not reportedInitial improvement then stable—1, stable still using—1, slow progression of the symptoms—2
De Bie et al. 2007 [19]1 (case report)36Not exactly reported, possibly 4–16 monthsDecrease of libido; sleepiness, slownessSymmetric SI increase in GP, SN dentate nucleus, and pontine tegmentumPramipexole, selegiline, l-dopaNo improvement
Sanotsky et al. 2007 [15]6 (case reports)23–452 months–1 ySpeech and gait disorder—1, plus bradyphrenia or depression—2, slowness—2, hyperthermia—1Striking bilateral SI increase of lentiform nucleus, SN, dentate nucleusEDTA, cerebrolysin, amantadine, l-dopaMild to moderate improvement—4, no improvement—2
Meral et al. 2007 [35]2 (case reports)21 and 32Unknown, 4 monthsBradykinesia, gait and speech disordersBilateral SI increase in GP. After withdrawal of injections, improvement of MRI in case 2Not reportedNo improvement
Stepens et al. 2008 [17]2337.5 ± 6.55.8 ± 4.5 yGait disturbance—20 (87%), hypophonia—3 (13%)T1 SI increase in GP—all 10 active users, in SN—9; former users had lesser degrees of change (SI increase in GP—11, SN—2, anterior midbrain—3)L-dopa in 3 patientsNo substantial improvement in 13 subjects after withdrawal for 2–6 y
Selikhova et al. 2008 [16]1318–46 (29.9)8.5 ± 3.2 monthsLoss of balance—7, slurred speech—4, mood disorders—2T1 SI increase mostly in GPi,—all; other frequently involved structures—STN, SNr, putamenL-dopa, amantadine, EDTA,Significant residual deficit; delayed progression in some cases
Colosimo and Guidi 2009 [18]1 (case report)282 yGait and speech disturbance, mental slowness, generalized fatigueRepeated MRI normalNot reportedSome deterioration of motor signs
Yildirim et al. 2009 [36]1 (case report)299.5 y since start of abuse, 5 y abstinenceGate disturbance, mood disordersNormalPiracetam, carbamazepine, fluoxetine, l-dopaGradual worsening over time
Varlibas et al. 2009 [37]3 (case reports)15–192–6 yPostural instability, face and limb dystonias, tremor, dysphonia, dysarthria, bradykinesiaBilateral symmetric SI increase in dentate nucleus, white matter of cerebellum, GP and putamenEDTA, PAS, l-dopaNo improvement