Review Article

Differences in Multidisciplinary and Interdisciplinary Treatment Programs for Fibromyalgia: A Mapping Review

Table 2

Description of the included studies.

ReferenceCountryDesignType of studyComparison groupSubjects (dropout)OutcomesOverall quality

Åkerblom et al., 2015 [25]SwedenNoncontrolled studyOutcome predictorsN/A409 (145)Pain, psychological factors, pain interferenceMedium
Amris et al., 2014 [26]NetherlandsRCTComparison with controlWL191 (21)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, movementHigh
Anderson and Winkler, 2006 [27]USControlled trialComparison with controlTAU98 (5)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, tender pointsLow
Angst et al., 2006 [28] SwitzerlandNoncontrolled studyComparison with controlTAU225 (100)QOL, pain, pain interference, psychological factorsLow
Angst et al., 2009 [29]Controlled trialPre-post evaluationTAU331 (121)QOL, pain, psychological factorsLow
Bailey et al., 1999 [30]CanadaNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A149 (43)Pain, pain interference, psychological factors, FIQ, physical fitnessLow
Bourgault et al., 2015 [31]CanadaRCTComparison with controlWL58 (15)QOL, pain, psychological factors, pain interference, FIQ, perception of improvementMedium
Carbonell-Baeza et al., 2011 [32] SpainControlled trialComparison with controlTAU + education75 (10)Tender points count, pain threshold, physical fitness, BMIMedium
Carbonell-Baeza et al., 2011 [33]Controlled trialComparison with controlTAU + education75 (10)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQMedium
Carbonell-Baeza et al., 2012 [34]Controlled trialComparison with additional treatmentBiodanza38 (7)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, physical fitness, tender pointsMedium
Casanueva-Fernández et al., 2012 [35]SpainRCTComparison with controlTAU + education34 (6)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, fatigue, sleep, tender points count, pain threshold, physical fitnessMedium
Castel et al., 2013 [36]SpainRCTComparison with controlTAU155 (28)Pain, psychological factors, FIQ, sleepHigh
Cedraschi et al., 2004 [37]SwitzerlandRCTComparison with controlWL164 (35)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, tender points count, satisfactionHigh
De Rooij et al., 2013 [38]NetherlandsNoncontrolled studyOutcome predictorsN/A138 (18)Pain, psychological factors, pain interference, perception of improvementLow
Gustafsson et al., 2002 [39]SwedenControlled trialComparison with controlTAU43 (2)Movement, pain drawings, pain, QOL, pain interferenceLow
Hammond and Freeman, 2006 [40]UKRCTComparison with controlRelaxation training183 (80)FIQ, psychological factors, physical activity, healthcare use, perception of improvementMedium
Hamnes et al., 2012 [41]NorwayRCTComparison with controlWL147 (29)Psychological factors, FIQ, care-management skillsMedium
Hooten et al., 2007 [42] USNoncontrolled studyComparison between male and femaleN/A66 (7)QOL, pain, psychological factors, pain interference, drug usageLow
Hooten et al., 2007 [43]Noncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A159 (17)QOL, pain, pain interference, activity, psychological factorsLow
Kas et al., 2015 [44]USControlled trialComparison with additional treatmentMultidisciplinary + increased exercise79 (0)FIQMedium
Keel et al., 1998 [45]SwitzerlandRCTComparison with controlRelaxation training32 (5)Pain, psychological factors, sleep, changes in drug treatment, satisfactionLow
Kroese et al., 2009 [46]NetherlandsNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A105 (5)FIQ, QOL, satisfactionLow
van Eijk-Hustings et al., 2013 [47]RCTComparison with controlAerobic exercise and TAU203 (69)QOL, activity, FIQ, healthcare use, sick leaveMedium
Lemstra and Olszynski, 2005 [48]CanadaRCTComparison with controlFamily physician79 (8)Pain, pain interference, psychological factorsHigh
Lera et al., 2009 [49]SpainRCTComparison with additional treatmentMultidisciplinary + CBT83 (27)QOL, FIQ, psychological factors, tender points countHigh
Marcus et al., 2014 [50]USNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A274 (67)Pain, ADL, movement, FIQLow
Martìn et al., 2012 [51] SpainRCTComparison with controlPharmacotherapy180 (70)QOL, pain, psychological factors, pain interference, FIQ, satisfactionMedium
Martìn et al., 2014 [52]RCTComparison with controlPharmacotherapy180 (70)FIQ, psychological factors, satisfactionMedium
Martìn et al., 2014 [53]RCTComparison with controlPharmacotherapy180 (70)FIQMedium
Martìn et al., 2014 [54]RCTComparison with controlPharmacotherapy180 (70)Pain, FIQMedium
Martins et al., 2014 [55]BrazilControlled trialComparison with controlTAU27 (0)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, sleepLow
Mengshoel et al., 1995 [56]NorwayNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A16 (3)Pain, fatigue, sleep, adjustments of daily lifeLow
Michalsen et al., 2013 [57]GermanyControlled trialComparison with additional treatmentOther multidisciplinary treatments48 (6)Pain, psychological factors, FIQ, sleep, BMIMedium
Nielson and Jensen, 2004 [58]CanadaNoncontrolled studyOutcome predictorsN/A253 (55)QOL, pain, psychological factors, pain interference, activityMedium
Persson et al., 2012 [59]SwedenNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A813 (304)Pain, psychological factors, pain interference, activityLow
Ripley et al., 2003 [60]USNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A21 (0)Pain, psychological factors, FIQ, fatigue, sleep, comorbiditiesLow
Romeyke et al., 2014 [61]AustriaControlled trialComparison with controlMultidisciplinary + hyperthermia104 (0)Pain, chronic pain stage, severity of symptoms, pain interferenceLow
Salgueiro et al., 2013 [62]SpainNoncontrolled studyOutcome predictorsN/A72 (0)Pain, FIQ, QOL, psychological factorsLow
Saral et al., 2016 [63]TurkeyRCTComparison with controlLong term versus short term versus no treatment66 (7)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, fatigue, sleep, tender points count, pain threshold, physical functioningMedium
Stein and Miclescu, 2013 [64]SwedenNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A59 (8)Pain, psychological factors, QOL, sick leave duration, healthcare use, drug usageLow
Suman et al., 2009 [65]ItalyNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A25 (0)Pain, psychological factors, tender points count, pain thresholdLow
Turk et al., 1998 [66]USNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A70 (3)Pain, psychological factors, pain interference, FIQ, disability, marital satisfactionMedium
Van Koulil et al., 2011 [67]NetherlandsRCTComparison with controlWL158 (45)Physical fitnessHigh
van Wilgen et al., 2007 [68]NetherlandsNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A65 (0)QOL, pain, psychological factors, FIQ, physical fitnessLow
Wennemer et al., 2006 [69]USNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A23 (3)QOL, FIQ, movementLow
Worrel et al., 2001 [70] USNoncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A100 (26)Pain, psychological factors, FIQ, pain interference, sleep, fatigueLow
Pfeiffer et al., 2003 [71]Noncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A100 (22)QOL, FIQ, psychological factorsLow
Oh et al., 2010 [72]Noncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A984 (463)QOL, FIQ, satisfactionLow
Vincent et al., 2013 [73]Noncontrolled studyPre-post evaluationN/A7 (0)QOL, FIQ, psychological factors, fatigueLow