Review Article

Can We Trust the Literature on Risk Factors and Triggers for Low Back Pain? A Systematic Review of a Sample of Contemporary Literature

Table 1

Characteristics of included studies on risk factors of LBP.

First author, year, countryStudy designAnticipated finding(s)First-time episode, episode, or prevalence†‡Definition of preceding nonepisode§“No prior history of LBP” queriedType of LBP according to our definition

Anand, 2013, India [5]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, associated risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Alperovitch-Najenson, 2010, Israel [6]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, associated risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Auvinen, 2010, Finland [7]LongitudinalRisk factorsEpisodeNoneNAMixed/unclear
Capkin, 2015, Turkey [8]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Cho, 2012, South Korea [9]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Coenen, 2013, Netherlands [10]Prospective cohortRisk factorPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Erick, 2014, Botswana [11]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Ernat, 2012, North America [12]Retrospective, database analysisIncidence, risk factorsFirst-timeNAUnclearMixed/unclear
Fajardo Rodriguez, 2016, Colombia [42]Cross-sectionalCharacterising LBPPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Gaowgzeh, 2015, Saudi Arabia [13]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Gold, 2017, North America [43]LongitudinalPredicting factors, risk factorsEpisodeNoneNARecurring episode
Hussain, 2017, Pakistan [44]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, associated risk factorPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Jia, 2016, China [14]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Kanchanomai, 2015, Thailand [15]ProspectiveAnnual incidence, risk factors for the onsetFirst-timeNANoMixed/unclear
Katsavouni, 2014, Greece [16]Cross-sectionalRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Kelley, 2017, North America [45]Cross-sectionalRelated factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Kherad, 2016, Sweden [46]Cross-sectionalRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Knox, 2014, North America [17]Retrospective database analysisIncidence, risk factorsFirst-timeNAUnclearMixed/unclear
Labbafinejad, 2016, Iran [47]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Lallukka, 2016, Finland [48]LongitudinalDeterminant factors, riskEpisodeNoneNoMixed/unclear
Lin, 2014, Taiwan [18]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Lin, 2012, Taiwan [19]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Mattila, 2017, Finland [49]ProspectivePredicting factorEpisodeNoneNoMixed/unclear
Mikkonen, 2016, Finland [20]Prospective cohortRiskEpisodeNoneNAMixed/unclear
Mitchell, 2010, Australia [21]ProspectiveFactors predicting new-onset LBPEpisodeNoneNAMixed/unclear
Mohd Anuar, 2016, Malaysia [50]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, associated risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Mohseni-Bandpei, 2011, Iran [22]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Murtezani, 2011, Kosovo [23]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Ng, 2014, Australia [24]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Nissen, 2014, Denmark [25]RetrospectiveRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Noda, 2015, Sri Lanka [26]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Rafeemanesh, 2017, Iran [51]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Ramond-Roquin, 2015, France [27]Prospective cohortRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Shemory, 2016, North America [28]Retrospective database analysisRelative risk, incidence, risk factorsFirst-timeNANoneMixed/unclear
Sikiru, 2010, Nigeria [29]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Şimşek, 2017, Turkey [52]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Steffens, 2015, Australia [30]Case-crossoverRisk factorsEpisodeYesNARecurring episode
Sterud, 2013, Norway [31]ProspectiveRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Triki, 2015, Tunisia [32]RetrospectivePrevalence, causes of injuriesFirst-timeNAYesFirst-time episode
Udom, 2016, Thailand [53]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, associated risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Van Hilst, 2015, Netherlands [33]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, associated risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Vandergrift, 2012, North America [34]ProspectiveRisk factors, risk of incidenceEpisodeNoneNARecurring episode
Vargas-Prada, 2013, Spain [35]ProspectiveFactors predicting the incidence and prevalenceEpisodeYesNoRecurring episode
Furtado, 2014, Brazil [36]Cross-sectionalRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Yang, 2016, North America [54]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Ye, 2017, China [55]Cross-sectionalRisk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear
Yue, 2012, China [37]Cross-sectionalPrevalence, risk factorsPrevalenceNoneNAMixed/unclear

According to authors or obvious from text: first-time episode: when the very first episode of LBP was investigated; episode: when any pain-free period preceding the recurrent episode under scrutiny could be identified; prevalence: when explicitly stated by authors or based on their objectives and method, a mixture of all types of LBP was investigated. §An application of a pain-free period preceding the episode under scrutiny. Were included in this category since the study population was mostly of an old adult age. NA: not applicable.