Comparison of Modified Cartilage Shield Tympanoplasty with Tympanoplasty Using Temporalis Fascia Only: Retrospective Analysis of 142 Cases

Table 3

Comparison of success rates of different graft materials in tympanoplasty.

Author	Graft material	Take-up (%)
Dornhoffer [6]	Perichondrium	85
Borkowski et al. [7]	Cartilage, perichondrium	100
Neumann et al. [8]	Cartilage palisade	100
Indorewala [9]	Fascia lata	95
Indorewala [9]	Temporalis fascia (TF)	66
Mundra et al. [10]	TF/perichondrium with cartilage slice	98.94
Present series	Cartilage shield with perichondrium	98.46
Present series	Temporalis fascia (TF)	89.61