A Lattice-Based Authentication Scheme for Roaming Service in Ubiquitous Networks with Anonymity

Table 6

Security comparison of the scheme.

	S1	S2	S3	S4	S5	S6	S7	S8	S9	S10	Security
Wu et al. [18]							×		×		8
Grope and Hwang [17]	×	×						×			7
Wen et al. [13]	×	×		×	×			×	×		4
Jiang et al. [12]	×				×		×		×		6
Farash et al. [16]	×	×		×	×	×		×	×	×	2
Alzahrani et al. [31]										×	9
Lu et al. [34]	×		×						×		7
Lee et al. [20]			×		×				×		8
Ostad-Sharif et al. [33]							×				9
Khatoon and Singh Thakur [32]								×			9
Ours											10

S1: conditional anonymity, S2: forward security, S3: untraceability, S4: mutual authentication, S5: resistance to replay attacks, S6: resistance to man-in-the-middle attack, S7: user login authentication, S8: resistance to device-stealing attacks, S9: resistance to privileged-inside attack, S10: secure user password change.