A Batch Authentication Design to Protect Conditional Privacy in Internet of Vehicles

Table 1

A review of authentication schemes.

Scheme	PKI/ID-based	ECC/bilinear-based	Batch authentication
Raya et al. [12]	PKI	ECC	No
Sun et al. [13]	PKI	Bilinear-based	No
Jiang et al. [14]	ID-based	Bilinear-based	Yes
Azees et al. [15]	ID-based	Bilinear-based	Yes
Ali et al. [16]	ID-based	Bilinear-based	Yes
Mei et al. [17]	ID-based	Bilinear-based	Yes
Cui et al. [18]	ID-based	ECC	Yes
Xie et al. [19]	ID-based	ECC	Yes
Gayathri et al. [20]	ID-based	ECC	Yes
Sutra et al. [21]	ID-based	ECC	Yes
Thumbur et al. [22]	ID-based	ECC	Yes