A Novel HDR Image Zero-Watermarking Based on Shift-Invariant Shearlet Transform

Table 9

Robustness comparisons in resisting TM attacks.

Number	Attack type	Wang’s [37]	Bai’s [38]	Proposed
		BER	BER	BER
1	TM1	0.0456	0.1104	0.0198
2	TM2	0.0387	0.1234	0.0142
3	TM3	0.0723	0.0697	0.0417
4	TM4	0.0237	0.0687	0.0085
5	TM5	0.1010	0.0615	0.0730
6	TM6	0.0254	0.0560	0.0112
7	TM7	0.0431	0.0707	0.0254
8	TM8	0.0391	0.0538	0.0032
9	TM9	0.0488	0.1199	0.0146
10	TM10	0.0940	0.0964	0.0337
11	TM11	0.0413	0.0685	0.0161
12	TM12	0.0364	0.0809	0.0088
13	TM13	0.2044	0.0666	0.1663
14	TM14	0.1410	0.1389	0.1956
Average	0.0682	0.0847	0.0451